• Cloud Innovation claims AFRINIC’s entire board was invalidated after a single disputed proxy vote in June 2024.
  • Observers suggest the crisis undermines AFRINIC’s legitimacy, prompting calls for legal dissolution, international intervention, or a successor registry.

Cloud Innovation disputes legality of AFRINIC’s new board

Cloud Innovation, one of AFRINIC’s most vocal critics, has publicly declared that the internet registry’s newly installed board—elected in June 2024—is “legally void.” In a strongly worded statement, the company argued that the election process violated AFRINIC’s own bylaws and that the board, as currently constituted, “no longer exists in law” .

At the centre of the controversy are claims that AFRINIC pushed ahead with elections despite unresolved legal challenges and in defiance of binding Mauritian court rulings. Cloud Innovation alleges that the election outcomes are null and void, citing procedural irregularities, governance inconsistencies, and a lack of legitimate authority.

Also read: EXPOSED: The letter that reveals who was really benefitting from AFRINIC’s lawsuits

Also read: Is the AFRINIC election process compliant with Mauritian corporate law?

Why this matters for Africa’s digital future

The situation raises serious concerns not only about AFRINIC’s governance, but also about its operational relevance in Africa’s internet ecosystem. With Cloud Innovation calling for AFRINIC’s dissolution and stakeholders losing faith, the registry now faces a credibility crisis. This could undermine the African continent’s control over internet number resource allocation—currently centralised in AFRINIC’s hands.

Network operators, already frustrated by resource delays and internal mismanagement, now face the risk of their allocations being legally challenged. If AFRINIC collapses or becomes untrusted, it could lead to severe disruptions for ISPs, enterprises, and governments dependent on stable IP address allocations.

Crucially, AFRINIC’s fate could set a global precedent. The internet community is now watching whether an RIR that loses member trust and violates legal orders can continue to exist unchallenged. If AFRINIC does not resolve its legitimacy problems soon, some operators may begin to bypass the registry entirely—triggering potential fragmentation in IP address governance across the continent.