Summary

  • AFRINIC in Mauritius: AFRINIC is a private company limited by guarantee, incorporated in Mauritius on 3 February 2004 under file C49338, governed by the Companies Act 2001 and answerable to the Supreme Court of Mauritius. The community chose Mauritius, in the four other registries’ words, “to obtain the benefit of a stable and consistent legal system”.
  • AFRINIC’s management asked the Government of Mauritius to treat it as an international organisation with privileges and immunities. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs replied that the request “cannot be entertained”.
  • On 12 September 2023, on Cloud Innovation’s application, the Supreme Court restrained AFRINIC from relocating or submitting to a takeover “in any manner whatsoever”; the appeal was set aside on 15 October 2024. Proposals heard in 2025 to make AFRINIC immune, move it or dissolve it would each take it out of the Court’s reach.

Is AFRINIC a Mauritian company?

Yes. AFRINIC was incorporated in Mauritius on 3 February 2004; the Registrar of Companies lists it under file number C49338 as a private, domestic company. That is what AFRINIC is: a company with members, under Mauritian law.

Its constitution names it “African Network Information Centre (AfriNIC) Ltd” (Article 2.1) and states: “The Company shall be a private company limited by guarantee.” (Article 3.1). Article 5.1 puts its registered office on the 11th floor of Standard Chartered Tower, Cybercity, Ebène.

The Supreme Court of Mauritius said the same in its ruling of 11 September 2023: “AfriNiC Ltd is duly registered as a company in the territory of Mauritius as a company limited by guarantee.”

AFRINIC’s “About” page calls it “a nonprofit, member-based organisation registered and operating under the Corporate Legal Frameworks of Mauritius”.

Why is AFRINIC based in Mauritius?

Because those who set it up chose Mauritius. AFRINIC’s history page: “In 2004, after a selection of potential host countries, AFRINIC was incorporated in Mauritius.”

The four other regional internet registries gave the reason, writing to the Government of Mauritius on 12 July 2022: the African Internet community “deliberately chose to locate its headquarters in Mauritius in order to obtain the benefit of a stable and consistent legal system”. In the same letter they complained of the orders that legal system had made.

A stable and consistent legal system is one whose orders bind the registry as well. Cloud Innovation: “Nobody imposed Mauritian law on AFRINIC. It chose that legal system, and its members have had the benefit of it.”

Which law governs AFRINIC?

The Companies Act 2001 of Mauritius, together with AFRINIC’s own constitution. The Supreme Court put it plainly in its ruling of 11 September 2023: “a company is bound by its constitution and the governing company laws of the country”.

Under that Act the Court appointed the Official Receiver of AFRINIC on 12 September 2023, on Cloud Innovation’s application, when AFRINIC had neither a quorate Board nor a chief executive. BTW has reported why the Court appointed AFRINIC’s Receiver and what he has done since.

On 11 June 2025 the Court directed that Cloud Innovation be entered in AFRINIC’s register of members “as per the criteria set out at Section 91 of the Companies Act”. A rule of the Court of 9 October 2026 restates that order.

A registry’s policies and communiqués stand below the law of the country where it is incorporated.

Which court decides disputes with AFRINIC?

The Supreme Court of Mauritius. In 2021 its Judge in Chambers restrained AFRINIC three times, on 29 March, 13 July and 3 December, from ending Cloud Innovation’s membership. Its judgment of 19 July 2022 recorded that those then running AFRINIC “deliberately flouted” its order of 13 July 2021.

In September 2023 the Court found the orders Cloud Innovation sought “fully justified, reasonable, and fair”. On 15 October 2024 the Court of Civil Appeal set aside the appeal brought against them (2024 SCJ 473). BTW keeps a record of every AFRINIC court decision since 2021.

Every open question about AFRINIC, from its Board to the winding-up petition (SC/COM/PET/000508/2025), is before that Court. Cloud Innovation: “No committee, no alliance and no other registry can overrule it.”

Is AFRINIC an international organisation?

No. AFRINIC’s management repeatedly asked the Government of Mauritius to recognise it as an international organisation with privileges and immunities. The four other registries backed the request in their letter of 12 July 2022: “AFRINIC has repeatedly asked for recognition from Mauritius of it as an international organization”.

The Ministry of Foreign Affairs replied that the request “cannot be entertained”.

AFRINIC remained what it is: a private company that the networks it serves can take to court. Its management asked to be put above the law its members rely on, and the answer was no.

Can AFRINIC be moved out of Mauritius?

Not while the Court’s order stands. On 12 September 2023, on Cloud Innovation’s application, the Supreme Court made an order “restraining and prohibiting AfriNIC from relocating and/or subject itself to a takeover or merger, or restructuring or management control in any manner whatsoever”. The appeal against the orders of that day was set aside on 15 October 2024.

The idea has not gone away. On 26 October 2025, at Smart Africa’s session during an ICANN meeting, a consultant presenting reforms on Smart Africa’s behalf set out three courses, by ICANN’s transcript: make AFRINIC “immune from third-party lawsuits”, “relocate AFRINIC to a third country”, or “dissolve AFRINIC in its current legal form”. These were proposals, not decisions; no decision to relocate AFRINIC has been published. BTW has set out what Smart Africa has to do with AFRINIC’s Board.

Each of the three is a way out of the Court’s reach. The winding-up Cloud Innovation asks for is the opposite: conducted by that same Court, under its supervision. BTW has answered seven questions on the AFRINIC wind-up.

Lu Heng, the internet entrepreneur behind Cloud Innovation, wrote in Note 2 on 17 September 2025: “AFRINIC can only exist as a neutral librarian.”

Why does it matter where AFRINIC is incorporated?

Because a court is the only thing that has ever stopped those who run AFRINIC. Judges in Mauritius restrained its management three times in 2021, and the Court appointed the Official Receiver when AFRINIC was left without a quorate Board or a chief executive.

An AFRINIC made “immune from third-party lawsuits”, or moved to a country chosen by those who control it, would be out of reach of the Court its members go to today, and a member put out of it would have nowhere to turn.

Lu Heng wrote in the same Note: “And when political influence began to interfere with court-ordered neutrality, the issue became constitutional: the separation of powers is not optional if an institution is to remain credible.” He ended it: “The Internet works because no one owns it. AFRINIC works only if it remembers that.”

Cloud Innovation: “We have confidence in the independence of the judiciary and the institutions of Mauritius. That is why we asked the Court to keep AFRINIC there.”

The full record is on Cloud Innovation’s page AFRINIC in Mauritius.

Sources