Summary
- The AFRINIC court cases run from 2021 to 2026 and the decisions go one way: the Supreme Court of Mauritius restrained AFRINIC three times from ending Cloud Innovation’s membership, placed AFRINIC in receivership on Cloud Innovation’s application and ordered that Cloud Innovation be entered in AFRINIC’s register of members.
- The judgment of 19 July 2022 records that AFRINIC “deliberately flouted” a duly served order, and it rejects AFRINIC’s claim that its member was abusing the Court’s process.
- Still before the Court: AFRINIC’s application to end the receivership, Cloud Innovation’s petition to wind AFRINIC up under the Court’s supervision, and the trial of the dispute itself.
What did the Court decide in the AFRINIC court cases?
AFRINIC publishes a list of the cases it is in. A list tells you who went to court, not who won. The decisions of the Supreme Court of Mauritius are set out here year by year: the date, the case number where there is one, who applied and what the Court ordered, with a link to the document where it is public.
Cloud Innovation, a party to these cases, asks for no trust at all: “We are a party to these cases, so do not take our word for it. Read the orders.” The wider story is in our account of the AFRINIC crisis.
2021: three orders restraining AFRINIC, and an attachment of up to USD 50 million
29 March 2021. The Judge in Chambers restrained AFRINIC from terminating, suspending or revoking Cloud Innovation’s membership.
13 July 2021. An interim injunction restrained AFRINIC from “acting, in any manner whatsoever, on its Board Resolution dated 08 July 2021”, from “freezing, in any manner whatsoever, any or all of the resources allocated to the applicant”, from “denying the applicant access, in any manner whatsoever, to the AFRINIC WHOIS database” and from “reclaiming, in any manner whatsoever, any or all of the resources allocated to the applicant”. The judgment of 19 July 2022 records what AFRINIC did with that order: it “failed to comply with the aforesaid order and deliberately flouted the duly served order dated 13 July 2021”. On 15 July 2021 AFRINIC gave the Judge an unconditional undertaking to comply. What a registry records, and what it can take from a member, is the subject of our article on AFRINIC IPv4 addresses.
23 July 2021. The Commercial Division authorised Cloud Innovation, in support of its claim for damages, to attach up to USD 50 million held in AFRINIC’s name at two banks.
3 December 2021. On 1 December AFRINIC’s management wrote that Cloud Innovation’s services “may come to an end at any time”. Two days later the Court restrained AFRINIC from terminating the membership “pending the final determination of the disputes between the parties”, and from acting in breach of its undertaking.
2022: the Court rejects AFRINIC’s claim of abuse of process
14 February 2022. The Court of Civil Appeal closed Cloud Innovation’s appeal against a judgment of 7 July 2021 without ruling on the merits, because the order of 3 December 2021 already protected its membership.
19 July 2022, reported as 2022 SCJ 253. AFRINIC told the Court that Cloud Innovation’s applications were an abuse of its process. The Judge in Chambers rejected that: “The applicant cannot be taxed for resorting to an independent court to safeguard its rights.” Upholding AFRINIC’s objection, the judgment says, “would imperil the future administration of justice”. And again: “I do not agree that the applicant is, in respect of the application before me, being a vexatious litigant causing prejudice to the respondent.” The same judgment records that the letter from AFRINIC’s management that began the dispute was sent on the “first day of lockdown, when access to justice was very limited”.
2023: AFRINIC is placed in receivership on its member’s application
11 September 2023. The Supreme Court held that AFRINIC’s lawyers could not rely on a 2021 board resolution to appear for it. AFRINIC then had four directors, too few for a quorum, and no chief executive.
12 September 2023, SC/COM/MOT/000156/2023. The applicant was Cloud Innovation. The Court found the orders sought “fully justified, reasonable, and fair”. It appointed the Official Receiver to preserve AFRINIC’s assets and “to see to it that the election process as per the constitution of AfriNIC Ltd be carried out so that a proper board could be constituted”, and it restrained AFRINIC “from relocating and/or subject itself to a takeover or merger, or restructuring or management control in any manner whatsoever”.
2024: the receivership is restored and the election deadline is set
15 October 2024, 2024 SCJ 473. An appeal against the receivership had been brought in AFRINIC’s name by a former director and by lawyers with no mandate. The Court of Civil Appeal upheld Cloud Innovation’s objections that it had been brought without authority, set it aside and restored the receivership order.
25 November 2024, SC/COM/MOT/000859/2024. On Cloud Innovation’s motion, the Supreme Court ordered AFRINIC to conduct its election by the end of June 2025. It recorded the Official Receiver’s undertakings, among them that “any entity who has become a member of AfriNIC without your consent from 19th of September 2023 till today, will not have the voting rights”. What became of that vote is in our article on the AFRINIC election.
2025: the Court orders Cloud Innovation entered in the register of members
4 April 2025, SC/COM/PET/000275/2021. On Cloud Innovation’s petition of 24 May 2021, the Supreme Court granted an order to rectify AFRINIC’s register of members.
11 June 2025, SC/COM/MOT/000399/2025. This time the applicant was AFRINIC itself. On its application the Court varied that order: AFRINIC’s register of members is to be rectified “to add details of Cloud Innovation Ltd as per the criteria set out at Section 91 of the Companies Act as its member in the category of Member therein”. AFRINIC’s Receiver signed a written undertaking to rectify AFRINIC’s records within 15 days, and the Court recorded it.
19 June 2025, SC/COM/MOT/000442/2025. The Court ruled on an application ICANN had brought against AFRINIC’s Receiver. Cloud Innovation was not a party. The ruling notes that “the applicant has no locus standi to enter such an application”. It ordered a communiqué correcting one thing: Cloud Innovation’s earlier listing as a “registered member”, the category AFRINIC’s bylaws keep for directors, was a “wrong classification”, and Cloud Innovation accepts that it was. The ruling contains no order cancelling the order of 11 June 2025. Cloud Innovation: “A correction of category cannot erase an express order to record a member.”
2026: the order becomes a rule of the Court, and the Receiver resists it
14 May 2026, SC/COM/WRT/000338/2026. Without notice to Cloud Innovation, AFRINIC’s Receiver obtained an interim order against it over a press release published by a separate company. The order restrains statements that falsely attribute to the Supreme Court any approval of the leasing or commercialisation of AFRINIC-allocated IP resources. Cloud Innovation’s answer: “No one made that claim: a lawful business needs no court approval, and no one ever said it did.” It is an interim order, not a final judgment.
9 October 2026, SC/COM/PET/000275/2021. The 15 days had passed without rectification, so Cloud Innovation had the judgment executed. After its praecipe of 2 October 2026 the Supreme Court drew up its order as a rule: AFRINIC’s register of members is to be rectified to add Cloud Innovation as its member, and the Registrar of Companies is to make the proper entries within 14 days. The Registrar’s record of 28 October 2026 lists Cloud Innovation as a member from 9 October 2026.
29 October 2026. The Receiver’s answer was a legal notice asking the Registrar to remove the entry. Cloud Innovation: “An officer of the Court who disagrees with an order goes back to the Court.” What the Court asked of that office, and what was done with it, is set out in our article on the AFRINIC Receiver.
What is still before the Court?
SC/COM/MOT/000757/2025. AFRINIC and its Receiver have applied to end the receivership, discharge the Receiver and have the board appointments of September 2025 declared valid. Cloud Innovation opposes the application, because the election departed from AFRINIC’s constitution and from the Court’s orders.
The wind-up petition. In July 2025 Cloud Innovation petitioned to wind AFRINIC up under the Court’s supervision, with its registry services carried on without interruption. Our article on the AFRINIC wind up answers the questions that petition raises.
The Receiver’s conduct. Cloud Innovation will bring the Receiver’s conduct before the Court that appointed him, as its communiqué of 3 November 2026 says.
The trial. As the judgment of 19 July 2022 records, both parties accept that the dispute itself is a serious matter to be tried.
Analysis: where to read the orders, and why to read them
Read the orders, not the summaries. The member asked the Court for protection and received it three times. When AFRINIC itself applied, in June 2025, the order it obtained adds Cloud Innovation to the register of members.
Cloud Innovation’s page on what the Supreme Court of Mauritius decided lists the decisions, and its public record holds the documents. Any summary of the AFRINIC court cases can be checked against the order it claims to describe.
Sources
- Cloud Innovation, AFRINIC’s court cases: what the Supreme Court of Mauritius decided
- Supreme Court of Mauritius, interim order of 13 July 2021
- Supreme Court of Mauritius, judgment of 19 July 2022, 2022 SCJ 253
- Supreme Court of Mauritius, ruling of 11 September 2023 and oral judgment of 12 September 2023
- Supreme Court of Mauritius, order of 25 November 2024, SC/COM/MOT/000859/2024
- Supreme Court of Mauritius, written undertaking of 10 June 2025 and order of 11 June 2025, SC/COM/MOT/000399/2025
- Supreme Court of Mauritius, amended minutes and oral ruling of 19 June 2025, SC/COM/MOT/000442/2025
- Supreme Court of Mauritius, rule of 9 October 2026, SC/COM/PET/000275/2021
- Cloud Innovation, public record
Member Briefing
Read the full trend briefing
Members read the full briefing with the source notes behind every finding.
Strategic Circle
A daily briefing in your language, built from changes we have verified.
Join for USD 20/monthCancel anytime.
Members also get the full research library, a daily briefing on the networks they follow and the private forum.






