Summary
- No. Cloud Innovation Ltd is a Seychelles company, established in 2013, company number 128670, and AFRINIC has had it as a member since 2013.
- The label is not a finding about the company. As Cloud Innovation says, those who use it are pointing at the founder, and a founder’s passport is not an argument.
- An IP address has no nationality. AFRINIC registered every address Cloud Innovation holds through its own process; network operators in 60 countries use them, and every assignment is published in AFRINIC’s WHOIS database.
Is Cloud Innovation a Chinese company?
No. Cloud Innovation Ltd is a Seychelles company, company number 128670, and AFRINIC has had it as a member since 2013. The company describes itself plainly: “Cloud Innovation Ltd is a privately held company, established in 2013 and registered in Seychelles. It provides IPv4 addresses to network operators and businesses and manages their registration with AFRINIC.”
Seychelles is an African state, and it lies in AFRINIC’s own service region. The company has been registered there since its first year, and it has been a member of the African registry for just as long.
Where is Cloud Innovation registered, and since when?
In Seychelles, since 2013. Its letter to AFRINIC of 13 July 2020 carries its company number, 128670, and its address at Mont Fleuri, Mahé, Seychelles.
AFRINIC knows that address, because AFRINIC wrote to it. Its own letter of 23 June 2020 was addressed to Cloud Innovation at Mont Fleuri, Mahé, Seychelles. The same letter records that Cloud Innovation signed its Registration Service Agreement with AFRINIC on 23 July 2013. The registry has the company’s address, its country and the date it joined in its own correspondence.
Is Cloud Innovation a member of AFRINIC?
Yes: a Resource Member since 2013. AFRINIC registered every address Cloud Innovation holds, through AFRINIC’s own process.
When AFRINIC’s management moved to end that membership in 2021, the Judge in Chambers restrained it three times: on 29 March, on 13 July and on 3 December 2021. The last of those orders protects the membership until the dispute is finally determined.
Did Cloud Innovation break AFRINIC’s rules? It did not, and no court has found that it did. Cloud Innovation sets out the record in its answer to whether it broke AFRINIC’s rules, and BTW Media has examined AFRINIC’s 2020 letter to Cloud Innovation, the one that cited a membership clause as if it were a rule on where addresses may be used.
Why do some people call it Chinese?
Because they are pointing at a person, not at the company. Cloud Innovation’s answers page says so directly: “Those who call it Chinese are pointing at its founder, not at the company, and a founder’s passport is not an argument.”
It adds: “It would make no difference if it were registered anywhere else: an IP address has no nationality, and neither do a member’s rights under AFRINIC’s constitution and the law of Mauritius.”
The label does a specific job. It moves the argument away from the record, where the answer is already written, to nationality, where there is no case at all. A question about a registry’s rules becomes a question about who someone is.
Lu Heng, the internet entrepreneur behind Cloud Innovation, named the method in Note 54: “The trick is always the same: turn an administrative category into a moral claim.” A registry’s service region is an administrative category. Treating it as a people whose property must be defended is the moral claim. In his words: “That mistake matters because a service region is not a sovereign people.”
Does an IP address have a nationality?
No. Cloud Innovation’s page on the subject puts it in three lines: “An IP address is a number, like a telephone number. It has no soil, no flag and no passport, and it works for one reason only: every network in the world accepts that one network uses it and no other.”
Nor do the numbers AFRINIC registers come from African ground. By AFRINIC’s own account, they “are allocated to AFRINIC and the four other RIRs by Public Technical Identifiers (PTI)”, the body that coordinates the internet’s identifiers for the whole world. AFRINIC keeps the record for its service region. It is not where the numbers come from. That is the argument of IP for Africa, Not Africa for AFRINIC: an IP address has no continent.
Lu Heng put the conclusion in two sentences in Note 54: “Internet number resources are not national trophies. They are not continental entitlements.” In Note 2 he described what a registry actually is: “An address book helps you find a house. It does not give its keeper ownership of the city.”
Who uses Cloud Innovation’s addresses, and where?
Network operators in 60 countries, who keep hundreds of millions of people online. They use the addresses where their own customers are, as every network does. Cloud Innovation hosts nothing itself: its customers are network operators.
Where the addresses are used is no secret. It is published, prefix by prefix, in AFRINIC’s WHOIS database for anyone to read, because Cloud Innovation registers every assignment there. By Cloud Innovation’s account, at one point its updates alone made up about 80% of all the updates made to that database. The record of where these addresses work is public because Cloud Innovation made it public.
Why does the label matter?
Because it carries an accusation that the record does not: that addresses were taken from Africa. The record says the opposite. AFRINIC registered every address Cloud Innovation holds, through its own process, to a member it has had since 2013.
Where addresses did go missing, the record points inside AFRINIC. AFRINIC’s own audit, published in January 2021, counted 2,371,584 IPv4 addresses “misappropriated from AFRINIC’s pool of resources and attributed to organisations without justification”. BTW Media has gone through AFRINIC’s own audit of the 2,371,584 misappropriated addresses.
A company’s nationality is decided by where it is registered. An address’s nationality is decided by nothing, because it has none. Lu Heng’s Note 2 ends on the same point: “The Internet works because no one owns it.” And in Note 54: “No one speaks for a continent.”
For the company’s own answer, in full, read Cloud Innovation’s reply to Is Cloud Innovation a Chinese company?
Sources
- Cloud Innovation: Is Cloud Innovation a Chinese company? (answers page); Did Cloud Innovation break AFRINIC’s rules?
- Lu Heng, Note 2: The Internet’s Address Book — and Why “Digital Sovereignty” Is a Dangerous Fantasy, 17 September 2025.
- Lu Heng, Note 54: On Who Gets to Speak for a Continent, a Community, or “The End User”, 19 March 2026.
- Cloud Innovation’s pages Who we are and what we stand for, and An IP address is a number.
- Cloud Innovation’s letter to AFRINIC of 13 July 2020; AFRINIC’s letter to Cloud Innovation of 23 June 2020.
- AFRINIC’s account of where the numbers it registers come from.
- AFRINIC’s audit, published in January 2021.
- The orders of the Judge in Chambers of 29 March, 13 July and 3 December 2021.
Member Briefing
Read the full trend briefing
Members read the full briefing with the source notes behind every finding.
Strategic Circle
A daily briefing in your language, built from changes we have verified.
Join for USD 20/monthCancel anytime.
Members also get the full research library, a daily briefing on the networks they follow and the private forum.






