Summary

  • The Supreme Court of Mauritius, in its judgment of 19 July 2022, reported as 2022 SCJ 253, records that AFRINIC “failed to comply with the aforesaid order and deliberately flouted the duly served order dated 13 July 2021”.
  • AFRINIC gave the Judge an undertaking to comply on 15 July 2021 and withdrew it on 25 November 2021. The Court’s comment: “I cannot turn a blind eye in the interests of fairness and justice.”
  • On 11 June 2025 the Court recorded a written undertaking, signed by AFRINIC’s Receiver, to rectify AFRINIC’s records within 15 days. Cloud Innovation, which sets the whole record out on its site, says it was not honoured and that it will ask the Court for contempt sanctions.

13 July 2021: four things AFRINIC was told not to do

On 8 July 2021 AFRINIC’s Board resolved to terminate the membership of Cloud Innovation with immediate effect. Five days later the Judge in Chambers stopped it.

The order of 13 July 2021 is an “Interim Order in the nature of an Injunction”. It restrains AFRINIC, “acting through its Board and/or its representative and/or préposé in whatever capacity”, from four things: “acting, in any manner whatsoever, on its Board Resolution dated 08 July 2021”; “freezing, in any manner whatsoever, any or all of the resources allocated to the applicant”; “denying the applicant access, in any manner whatsoever, to the AFRINIC WHOIS database”; and “reclaiming, in any manner whatsoever, any or all of the resources allocated to the applicant”.

It was served on AFRINIC the same day.

What the judgment records

What those then running AFRINIC did with that order is written down by the Court. The judgment of 19 July 2022 sets out the history of the dispute, and one sentence of it reads: “The respondent failed to comply with the aforesaid order and deliberately flouted the duly served order dated 13 July 2021.”

The respondent is AFRINIC. The words are the Court’s.

15 July 2021: a promise to the Judge

Two days after the order was served, the parties were back before the Judge. The order of 15 July 2021 records what Cloud Innovation’s counsel told him: “notwithstanding the fact that the Order was served on the respondent on 13 July 2021, the respondent is not complying with the Order and will continue not to comply with same”. AFRINIC’s counsel then stated “that the respondent will fully comply with the Order”. AFRINIC gave its undertaking, with no condition attached, and the interim order was discharged on the strength of it.

Even then, by Cloud Innovation’s account, nothing moved. In its statement of 26 July 2021 the company reported that AFRINIC “refused to reinstate the membership” and “only reconsidered its position after being warned of contempt of court proceedings”. The membership, it said, “was finally reinstated many hours later during the night of 15 July 2021”.

For two days, the company says, the addresses its customers’ networks run on, operators in 60 countries who keep hundreds of millions of people online, depended on an order that AFRINIC’s management would not obey.

25 November 2021: the promise taken back

The undertaking lasted four months. The judgment records its end: “On 25 November 2021, before the then Acting Deputy Master and Registrar, learned Senior Counsel for the respondent withdrew the undertaking made before the learned Judge on 15 July 2021.” A promise made to a Judge was withdrawn at a sitting before a registrar.

Days later, on 1 December 2021, AFRINIC’s management wrote to Cloud Innovation that its services “may come to an end at any time”. On 3 December the Court restrained AFRINIC again: from terminating the membership until the dispute is finally determined, and from “breaching the Undertaking of the 15th July 2021”.

Of the withdrawal, the Judge wrote: “I will not comment on the propriety of the procedure adopted to withdraw an undertaking given before a Judge although I cannot turn a blind eye in the interests of fairness and justice.”

AFRINIC’s answer: blame the member for going to court

Cloud Innovation went back to the Court each time. The judgment records that on 3 August 2021 it “lodged a contempt of court application”, asking for a declaration that the order of 13 July had been “deliberately and willfully flouted”, and that the withdrawn undertaking “triggered various other applications related to the breach of the undertaking, including contempt of court cases”.

AFRINIC’s management asked the Court to treat those applications as an abuse of its process. The Court refused. “The applicant cannot be taxed for resorting to an independent court to safeguard its rights,” it held. To uphold AFRINIC’s objection “would imperil the future administration of justice”. And: “I do not agree that the applicant is, in respect of the application before me, being a vexatious litigant causing prejudice to the respondent.”

2025: the Receiver’s fifteen days

The people changed. The pattern did not.

On 11 June 2025, on AFRINIC’s own application, the Supreme Court ordered “the rectification of the register of members of the African Network Information Centre (AfriNIC) Ltd to add details of Cloud Innovation Ltd as per the criteria set out at Section 91 of the Companies Act as its member in the category of Member therein”. The order records a written undertaking, signed the day before by AFRINIC’s Receiver: “the Applicant hereby undertakes to rectify its records within 15 days from the date of any Order which this Honourable Court may issue.”

Cloud Innovation’s communiqué of 3 November 2026 says what followed: “It was not honoured. CIL therefore executed the judgment, and the Registrar entered CIL as a member on 9 October 2026 on the Supreme Court Rule of that date.” That rule, stamped “CERTIFIED A TRUE COPY”, restates the order of 11 June 2025.

The Receiver’s response, on 29 October 2026, was a legal notice asking the Registrar of Companies to take the entry out. “It cited no court order,” Cloud Innovation says. “An officer of the Court who disagrees with an order goes back to the Court.”

What Cloud Innovation is doing about it

The company is taking the Receiver’s conduct to the Court that appointed him. Its communiqué says it will inform the Bankruptcy Division of the Supreme Court and “will seek appropriate relief, including contempt sanctions, directions, costs and his removal”. It will file a complaint with the Director of Insolvency. And it will notify the Registrar of Companies that the entry “was made under the Orders and the Rule of the Supreme Court, which bind her until varied, stayed or set aside by a competent court”.

“CIL will act strictly within the law and through the Courts and the competent authorities,” the communiqué says.

Why this is every network’s business

In 2021 the only thing between AFRINIC’s management and the networks that run on Cloud Innovation’s addresses was an order of the Supreme Court of Mauritius, and the Court’s own judgment records how that order was treated. “A court order is what stands between a registry’s management and the networks it can cut off,” the company says. “A registry keeps records; it does not hold the power of a state, and it is not above the courts.”

Sources