Summary
- The AFRINIC crisis is not a quarrel between a registry and one member. It is what happens when the people who keep a record decide that they own what is recorded, and it has run from 2021 to 2026.
- Those who control AFRINIC have had their own audit find 2,371,584 IPv4 addresses misappropriated, tried to put a member out at will, defied a court order, been left without a board able to act, annulled an election and locked the exit. Each step was answered in the Supreme Court of Mauritius.
- Cloud Innovation says how it ends: “The crisis ends when AFRINIC goes back to being a registry.”
What is the AFRINIC crisis?
A registry keeps a record of which network runs on which addresses. The AFRINIC crisis is what happens when the people who keep that record decide that they own what is recorded.
It has six stages. Each is on the public record. Each is set out here as what those who control AFRINIC did and what the Court answered.
2021: what did AFRINIC’s own audit find?
The first finding against AFRINIC is AFRINIC’s own. Its account of its audit, dated January 2021 and archived by ARIN, says that “2,371,584 IPv4 addresses were misappropriated from AFRINIC’s pool of resources and attributed to organisations without justification”.
That is where the timeline starts. Cloud Innovation: “The crisis began inside AFRINIC.” And: “Power that answers to no one does not stay clean, and this finding is AFRINIC’s own.”
2021: how did AFRINIC try to put a member out?
At will. In March 2021 AFRINIC’s management gave Cloud Innovation 30 days to answer what the Court later called “purported breaches”, or face termination at its “sole discretion”. In July 2021 AFRINIC’s Board resolved to end the membership, which would have taken back the addresses Cloud Innovation’s customers’ networks run on.
The Court answered three times. The Judge in Chambers of the Supreme Court of Mauritius stopped AFRINIC on 29 March, on 13 July and on 3 December 2021. Every decision is listed, with its document, in our article on the AFRINIC court cases.
2021–2022: what did AFRINIC do with the Court’s order?
It defied it. The judgment of 19 July 2022 records that AFRINIC “failed to comply with the aforesaid order and deliberately flouted the duly served order dated 13 July 2021”. AFRINIC gave the Judge an unconditional undertaking on 15 July 2021 and withdrew it in November 2021.
AFRINIC’s management then tried to turn the member’s recourse to the Court into the offence. It asked the Court to treat Cloud Innovation’s applications as an abuse of its process. The Court held: “The applicant cannot be taxed for resorting to an independent court to safeguard its rights.”
AFRINIC’s management also asked the Government of Mauritius for the immunities of an international organisation. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs gave the right answer: the request “cannot be entertained”.
2023: why was AFRINIC placed under the Official Receiver?
Because it had no board able to act. By September 2023 AFRINIC had four directors, too few for a board quorum, and no chief executive.
On Cloud Innovation’s application the Supreme Court found the orders it sought “fully justified, reasonable, and fair”, placed AFRINIC under the Official Receiver and restrained it “from relocating and/or subject itself to a takeover or merger, or restructuring or management control in any manner whatsoever”. An appeal lodged in AFRINIC’s name without authority failed on 15 October 2024.
Cloud Innovation’s purpose was plain: “We sought the receivership to restore good governance at AFRINIC, never to disrupt its work.”
2025: why was the AFRINIC election annulled?
The receivership was there to deliver an election. In June 2025, in Cloud Innovation’s words, AFRINIC’s Receiver annulled the entire vote over “one disputed proxy”, “silencing hundreds of valid votes”. His rules for the rerun banned the proxy voting that AFRINIC’s constitution allows. What the Court asked of that office, and what he did with it, is the subject of our article on the AFRINIC Receiver.
ICANN itself warned that AFRINIC’s ability to function as a regional internet registry was in jeopardy.
Cloud Innovation does not recognise the Board that came out of the election of September 2025 as lawfully constituted, and the validity of its appointments is before the Court. In July 2025 Cloud Innovation petitioned the Court to wind AFRINIC up under its supervision, with registry services carried on without interruption. That petition is before the Court too. Our article on the AFRINIC wind up answers seven questions about it.
2026: how was the exit locked and the Court’s order resisted?
On 4 February 2026 AFRINIC’s Board ratified a transfer policy under which, in AFRINIC’s own words, “AFRINIC-issued IPv4 cannot be transferred out of the region”. That is the exit, locked. What the registry records, and what it can take away, is in our article on AFRINIC IPv4 addresses.
A proposed constitution would take from the members the power to set AFRINIC’s policies.
Then the Court’s own order was resisted. When a rule of the Supreme Court of 9 October 2026 restated that Cloud Innovation is to be entered as a member, AFRINIC’s Receiver demanded its removal from the register, with copies to ministers, and cited no court order for it.
And the election of 2026 put no one on the Board. By AFRINIC’s own announcements, the election it held in 2026 filled three seats on an advisory committee and two community seats; no seat on its Board was on the ballot. Our article on the AFRINIC election has the detail.
Analysis: how does the AFRINIC crisis end?
Cloud Innovation answers in one sentence: “The crisis ends when AFRINIC goes back to being a registry.”
It then says what that means. “A registry keeps the record and answers to the law like any other company.” “Courts decide disputes, and their orders are changed only in court.” “Members elect their Board under the constitution, every eligible member is on the register, and a network is free to leave with its addresses.”
None of it is a favour asked for one company: “Those are the things we have gone to court for since 2021, and we ask them for every member.”
Set that list beside the timeline. An audit that found addresses misappropriated inside the registry. A member to be put out at will. An order defied. A board that could not act. An election annulled. An exit locked. Every item on Cloud Innovation’s list is the repair of one of them, and every stage is documented on its page The AFRINIC crisis: a registry at war with its own members.
Sources
- Cloud Innovation, The AFRINIC crisis: a registry at war with its own members
- AFRINIC’s own account of its audit, January 2021, as archived by ARIN
- Supreme Court of Mauritius, judgment of 19 July 2022, 2022 SCJ 253
- Supreme Court of Mauritius, ruling of 11 September 2023 and oral judgment of 12 September 2023
- Cloud Innovation, AFRINIC’s transfer policy
- Cloud Innovation, AFRINIC’s proposed constitution: what members would lose
Member Briefing
Read the full trend briefing
Members read the full briefing with the source notes behind every finding.
Strategic Circle
A daily briefing in your language, built from changes we have verified.
Join for USD 20/monthCancel anytime.
Members also get the full research library, a daily briefing on the networks they follow and the private forum.






