Summary

  • The AFRINIC bylaws are being rewritten. The draft leaves out the members’ power to set AFRINIC’s general policies, which Article 7.6(iv) of the current constitution gives them.
  • Under the draft, two-thirds of the directors may refuse a proposal that ten members have put forward, and officers may suspend or end a membership, with the addresses returned.
  • The committee writing the draft was appointed by the Board that came out of the disputed election of September 2025. The members must still approve any amendment.

What are AFRINIC’s bylaws, and why do they matter now?

AFRINIC is a company, and its bylaws are that company’s constitution. The two words name the same document: the body rewriting it is called the Bylaws Review Committee, and what it is writing is the proposed constitution.

The document matters because of who AFRINIC’s members are. They are its Resource Members, the networks whose number resources AFRINIC registers. AFRINIC describes itself as “a nonprofit, member-based organisation”. The bylaws decide what those members may decide for themselves, and what is decided for them.

The draft changes that balance in four places. Each is set out below with its article number.

Who is writing the draft?

The Board it would empower. The Board that came out of the disputed election of September 2025 appointed the Bylaws Review Committee’s six members and its chair, with the consent of AFRINIC’s Receiver. The committee reports to that Board, and the Board’s approval is required before the final draft reaches the members.

Cloud Innovation does not recognise that Board as lawfully constituted, and whether its members were validly appointed is before the Supreme Court of Mauritius, in SC/COM/MOT/000757/2025. How it came to hold the eight seats of the AFRINIC Board is a story of its own, and it begins with the AFRINIC election that AFRINIC’s Receiver annulled in June 2025.

“Directors are overseeing a proposal that reduces the members’ control over directors,” Cloud Innovation says. In its statement of 1 November 2026 it put the point in full: “In our view, directors overseeing proposals that would reduce members’ control over those same directors creates a clear conflict of interest. Consultation does not remove it.”

Change 1: who sets AFRINIC’s policies?

Today, the members. Article 7.6(iv) of the current constitution gives them the power to set AFRINIC’s general policies by ordinary resolution.

Article 7.4 of the draft leaves that power out.

Cloud Innovation’s summary takes one sentence: “What the members decide now, the Board would decide for them.”

Change 2: can the directors refuse a members’ proposal?

Under the draft, yes. Article 7.2A of the draft requires a proposal from the members to have the support of ten Resource Members in Good Standing. Even then, two-thirds of all directors may refuse it, with written reasons.

“The people a proposal is meant to hold to account,” the company says, “would decide whether it is heard.”

Change 3: who can end a membership?

Officers could. Article 8.6 of the draft permits the suspension and termination of members to be delegated to officers, subject to safeguards and appeal. Article 8.5 of the draft keeps the rule that a terminated member returns its addresses, under the registration agreement.

For a network, that is the clause that counts. “Membership decisions stay tied to control over the addresses a network runs on,” Cloud Innovation says, “the power AFRINIC tried to use against us in 2021.”

That year AFRINIC’s management, and then its Board, moved to end Cloud Innovation’s membership, which would have taken back the addresses its customers’ networks run on: in the company’s words, “operators in 60 countries who keep hundreds of millions of people online”. Three times in 2021 the Judge in Chambers of the Supreme Court of Mauritius stopped it: on 29 March, on 13 July and on 3 December. The order of 13 July 2021 restrained AFRINIC from “freezing, in any manner whatsoever, any or all of the resources allocated to the applicant” and from “reclaiming, in any manner whatsoever, any or all of the resources allocated to the applicant”.

“What stood between those networks and the clause was a court,” the company says. BTW has set out separately what AFRINIC’s contract says about ending a membership, and Cloud Innovation answers the same question on its page on membership termination. The 2021 attempt opened the AFRINIC crisis that has run ever since.

Change 4: are the networks members of their own company?

The draft keeps them one step away from it. Its Articles 6.5 and 6.6 attach statutory registration and Companies Act rights to directors, while describing Resource Membership as contractual.

The Court has already ordered one member entered in the company’s register. On 11 June 2025, on AFRINIC’s own application, the Supreme Court of Mauritius ordered “the rectification of the register of members of the African Network Information Centre (AfriNIC) Ltd to add details of Cloud Innovation Ltd as per the criteria set out at Section 91 of the Companies Act as its member in the category of Member therein”.

The register today is short. The Registrar of Companies’ record of AFRINIC, issued on 28 October 2026, lists the eight directors, each registered on 12 September 2025, and Cloud Innovation, a member from 9 October 2026. On Cloud Innovation’s information, more than 2,000 resource members have been left off. Its position on AFRINIC’s members is that every eligible Resource Member belongs in that register, with the rights that come with it: “If thousands of members qualify for registration, put thousands of names on the register.”

It puts a question to the members: “Why should those appointed to serve members enjoy stronger legal protections than the members themselves?”

What can the members do?

Vote. The members must still approve any amendment.

“That vote is the last check left, and we ask members to use it,” Cloud Innovation says: “reject the provisions that weaken their control while preserving the administrators’ power over their addresses.”

Its case fits in a line: “A constitution for a members’ registry should give members more say, not less.” And it asks those who present the change as being for the continent one thing: “How does taking power from the networks you serve protect Africa?”

Cloud Innovation’s page on the AFRINIC bylaws sets out each change, with the statement it comes from. Its account of AFRINIC’s Board explains who commissioned the draft.

Sources