Summary

  • The AFRINIC Board has eight seats, and AFRINIC’s members are meant to fill them. The present Board came out of a rerun in September 2025, held under rules that banned the proxy voting Article 12.12 of AFRINIC’s constitution allows.
  • In that rerun the candidates of a single alliance of 40 governments won seven of the eight seats. Cloud Innovation does not recognise this Board as lawfully constituted.
  • Whether the appointments are valid is before the Supreme Court of Mauritius, in SC/COM/MOT/000757/2025. “An application for validation is not an order granting it,” Cloud Innovation says.

What is AFRINIC’s Board for?

A registry’s board answers to its members. AFRINIC is a company, and a company belongs to its members, not to its Board, its Receiver or any government. The members elect the Board to oversee the company that keeps their records.

Cloud Innovation states the limits of the office plainly: “The Board does not own AFRINIC, the addresses it records or the networks that run on them, and eight seats speak for no continent.”

The history of those eight seats since 2021 is short, and each step of it is in a court document.

2021: what did the Board do to a member?

It tried to put one out. On 8 July 2021 AFRINIC’s Board resolved to end Cloud Innovation’s membership with immediate effect. That would have taken back the addresses its customers’ networks run on.

Five days later the Supreme Court of Mauritius blocked the resolution. The interim order of 13 July 2021 restrained AFRINIC from “acting, in any manner whatsoever, on its Board Resolution dated 08 July 2021”.

What happened next is recorded in the judgment of 19 July 2022, reported as 2022 SCJ 253: AFRINIC “failed to comply with the aforesaid order and deliberately flouted the duly served order dated 13 July 2021”. That attempt opened the AFRINIC crisis.

2023: why could the Board no longer act?

Because there was not enough of it left. By September 2023 AFRINIC had four directors, too few for a board quorum, and no chief executive. On 11 September 2023 the Supreme Court held that AFRINIC’s lawyers could not rely on a 2021 board resolution to appear for it.

The next day, on Cloud Innovation’s application, the Court placed AFRINIC in receivership. It found the orders sought “fully justified, reasonable, and fair” and appointed a receiver “to see to it that the election process as per the constitution of AfriNIC Ltd be carried out so that a proper board could be constituted”. Cloud Innovation sought the receivership to restore good governance at AFRINIC, never to disrupt its work.

An appeal against the receivership, lodged in AFRINIC’s name without authority, failed on 15 October 2024. On 25 November 2024, on Cloud Innovation’s motion, the Supreme Court ordered AFRINIC to conduct its election by the end of June 2025. The office the Court created, and what its holder did with it, is the subject of BTW’s report on the AFRINIC Receiver.

2025: how was the present Board seated?

By a rerun. In June 2025 the members voted, and AFRINIC’s Receiver then annulled the entire Board election over what Cloud Innovation calls “one disputed proxy”, “silencing hundreds of valid votes”.

For the rerun the Receiver wrote his own rules. They banned proxies and powers of attorney and allowed online voting only, although Article 12.12 of AFRINIC’s constitution permits proxy voting and the Court had ordered an election under that constitution. His guidelines claimed priority in any conflict of interpretation, so long as they kept to the bylaws’ “spirit”.

Cloud Innovation’s answer is in its statement of 1 November 2026 and on its page on AFRINIC’s elections: “Authority to organise an election does not include authority to remove a voting method the constitution expressly allows: otherwise the organiser chooses which rules bind him and certifies his own compliance.”

The rerun was held in September 2025. The candidates of a single alliance of 40 governments won seven of the eight seats. The eight were entered as AFRINIC’s registered members on 12 September 2025. On Cloud Innovation’s information, more than 2,000 resource members, the networks that are supposed to elect the Board, have been left off AFRINIC’s register of members.

“AFRINIC belongs to its members, who elect its Board,” the company says: “a registry is not a continental government, and its Board should not be filled with the candidates of an alliance of governments.”

What has this Board done since?

“This Board has used its months in office to tighten its hold on the members,” Cloud Innovation says. The record shows four things.

On 4 February 2026 the Board ratified a transfer policy under which the addresses AFRINIC has issued cannot leave its region. In AFRINIC’s own summary, “AFRINIC-issued IPv4 cannot be transferred out of the region”. AFRINIC’s own assessment said what follows: “AFRINIC will not lose its current resource members to other RIRs in outgoing transfers.”

It appointed the six members and the chair of the committee rewriting AFRINIC’s bylaws. The draft leaves out the members’ power to set AFRINIC’s general policies and lets two-thirds of the directors refuse what members propose. BTW has set out the changes in its report on the AFRINIC bylaws; Cloud Innovation’s own page on the proposed constitution gives each article.

It approved the rules for AFRINIC’s 2026 elections: by AFRINIC’s own election guidelines, on 4 February 2026. They again allowed no proxy voting. And by AFRINIC’s own announcements, no Board seat was on the ballot: those elections filled three seats on its Governance Committee and two seats on the Number Council of the Number Resource Organization, for which there were two candidates. The eight seats filled in the rerun were not put to a vote, as BTW’s report on the AFRINIC election sets out.

And it supports removing from the register the member whose application to the Court made its own election possible. “These individuals claim office through the resulting process, yet support removing the member whose action made it possible,” Cloud Innovation says. “Member rights cannot serve only as a route for administrators to gain office.”

Is AFRINIC’s Board lawfully constituted?

That question is before the Court, and it has not been answered. In SC/COM/MOT/000757/2025, AFRINIC and its Receiver have asked the Supreme Court for the Receiver’s discharge, the end of the receivership and a declaration that the September candidates were validly appointed.

Cloud Innovation opposes the application. Its case is that the departures from the constitution exceeded the Receiver’s mandate, breached the Court’s orders and failed to produce valid appointments. “We do not recognise this Board as lawfully constituted,” it says. “An application for validation is not an order granting it.”

It demands the removal of the purported directors through the competent legal procedures, with registry services continuing under lawful authority. Every decision so far is listed in BTW’s guide to the AFRINIC court cases.

What Board are AFRINIC’s members owed?

One they have chosen. “AFRINIC’s members are owed a Board they have chosen,” Cloud Innovation says. That means an election under the constitution as it is written, with the proxy voting it allows, every eligible Resource Member on the register and able to vote, and directors who answer to the members and to the courts.

“Members elect the people who keep their records; nobody else should choose them.”

The record of the eight seats, year by year and with its documents, is on Cloud Innovation’s page on the AFRINIC Board.

Sources