Summary

  • AFRINIC IPv4 addresses are numbers in a record that AFRINIC keeps. By AFRINIC’s own account the numbers are allocated to it by Public Technical Identifiers (PTI), the body that coordinates the internet’s identifiers for the whole world. AFRINIC records them. It does not own them.
  • AFRINIC’s contract says that if the agreement ends “AFRINIC will immediately revoke the number resources”, and the transfer policy its Board ratified on 4 February 2026 says “AFRINIC-issued IPv4 cannot be transferred out of the region”. Cloud Innovation: “So a member can be put out but cannot walk out.”
  • AFRINIC’s own audit account of January 2021 says 2,371,584 IPv4 addresses “were misappropriated from AFRINIC’s pool of resources”. On 13 July 2021 the Supreme Court of Mauritius restrained AFRINIC from freezing or reclaiming the addresses registered to Cloud Innovation while the dispute is decided.

What are AFRINIC IPv4 addresses?

They are numbers. Cloud Innovation puts it in one sentence: “An IP address is a number, like a telephone number.” And a number has no homeland: “A number does not belong to a place.”

AFRINIC does not make the numbers and does not own them. By AFRINIC’s own account of itself, the numbers it registers “are allocated to AFRINIC and the four other RIRs by Public Technical Identifiers (PTI)”, the body that coordinates the internet’s identifiers for the whole world. AFRINIC’s part is to write down which network has which numbers. What happens next is the network’s business: “A network uses its addresses where its customers are.” As Cloud Innovation says, “The internet has no customs posts.”

Why does AFRINIC have a region, and does the region own the numbers?

The regions were drawn for convenience. The 1992 document that first proposed regional registries, RFC 1366, gives the reason: registries in different parts of the world “may be better able to serve the local community in terms of language and local customs”. It asked for “just a single regional registry per geographical region”.

Language and local customs: that is the whole case for a region. Cloud Innovation draws the conclusion: “A region is the area one office serves, as a branch serves a district.” “A map of service desks is not a map of owners.”

One registry per region has a consequence that operators feel every day. A network in AFRINIC’s region has one registry and no choice of another. “A sole provider owes its customers more, not less.”

Compare any other record-keeper. “The land registry records every title deed, and the deeds belong to the owners: it owns none of the land.” Cloud Innovation’s verdict on AFRINIC: “Only here does the clerk say the ledger makes him the landlord.”

What does AFRINIC’s contract say about the addresses?

Every network that registers with AFRINIC signs the same agreement, the Registration Service Agreement, and Cloud Innovation’s page Own your IP sets out what it says. In AFRINIC’s contract the member has to acknowledge that the number resources “are not property (real, personal or intellectual)”. If the agreement ends, “AFRINIC will immediately revoke the number resources” and stop its services “without incurring any liability whatsoever”. AFRINIC’s liability to a member is capped at six months of fees or 100 USD, whichever is greater.

That is the contract the clerk wrote for himself. Cloud Innovation says the opposite: “the network that runs on an address owns it, and the registry only records it.” The operator builds the network, wins the customers and carries their traffic. The registry keeps a ledger.

Can AFRINIC IPv4 addresses be transferred out of the region?

AFRINIC says no. Under the transfer policy its Board ratified on 4 February 2026, in AFRINIC’s own words, “AFRINIC-issued IPv4 cannot be transferred out of the region”. AFRINIC’s own assessment said what the rule is for: “AFRINIC will not lose its current resource members to other RIRs in outgoing transfers.”

Read the policy beside the contract. Under the contract, AFRINIC revokes the addresses the moment the agreement ends. Under the policy, the member cannot take its addresses to another registry. Cloud Innovation: “So a member can be put out but cannot walk out.”

Can the AFRINIC record be trusted?

Take AFRINIC’s word for it. Its own account of its audit, dated January 2021 and archived by ARIN, says: “The audit reveals that 2,371,584 IPv4 addresses were misappropriated from AFRINIC’s pool of resources and attributed to organisations without justification.” And: “A former employee was found to have misappropriated IP number resources forming part of AFRINIC’s pool of resources.” AFRINIC’s account does not say how many he took.

Of the 2,371,584, AFRINIC said 1,060,864 had been reclaimed and 1,310,720, “related to two distinct organisations”, had not.

Cloud Innovation states where the fault lay: “The addresses that were found taken without justification were taken inside AFRINIC.” Its own registrations came through the front door: “AFRINIC registered every address we hold, through its own process, to a member it has had since 2013.”

Can AFRINIC take addresses away?

It tried. In July 2021 AFRINIC’s Board resolved to end Cloud Innovation’s membership, which would have taken back the addresses its customers’ networks run on. Cloud Innovation describes those customers as “operators in 60 countries who keep hundreds of millions of people online”.

On 13 July 2021 the Judge in Chambers restrained AFRINIC from “freezing, in any manner whatsoever, any or all of the resources allocated to the applicant” and from “reclaiming, in any manner whatsoever, any or all of the resources allocated to the applicant”. The order restrained AFRINIC from freezing or reclaiming the addresses while the dispute is decided.

That resolution is one chapter of the AFRINIC crisis, and the decisions that followed are listed in our article on the AFRINIC court cases.

Analysis: what protects an operator who runs on AFRINIC IPv4 addresses?

Not geography. Cloud Innovation: “No slogan about where addresses belong protects an operator. A rule that the registry cannot seize them does, with a vote in that registry, a court that will hear the case and the freedom to leave.” What it advocates is “secure ownership of lawfully held addresses, continuity of use, transferability and the freedom to change registry”.

This series follows those protections through the record: the vote, in our article on the AFRINIC election; the office of the AFRINIC Receiver, what the Court asked and what he did; and the seven questions raised by an AFRINIC wind up.

A registry records. It does not own. Cloud Innovation’s page An IP address has no continent sets out the argument in full, and it comes down to one line: the network that runs on an address owns it, and the registry only records it.

Sources