Summary
- AFRINIC’s contract says that if a membership ends, “AFRINIC will immediately revoke the number resources and otherwise cease providing the services without incurring any liability whatsoever”. Its liability is capped at six months of fees or 100 USD, whichever is greater.
- In 2021 AFRINIC’s management, and then its Board, moved to end Cloud Innovation’s membership. The Supreme Court of Mauritius restrained AFRINIC three times, and its judgment records that one of those orders was “deliberately flouted”.
- Under the 2026 transfer policy a member cannot leave with the addresses AFRINIC issued. Cloud Innovation puts it this way: “a member can be put out but cannot walk out”.
The clause
Every network that registers with AFRINIC signs the same Registration Service Agreement. Four of its terms decide what happens to you on a bad day.
Termination. AFRINIC may end the agreement after a written notice inviting the member to show cause. The member has 30 days. The process stops only where AFRINIC “considers in its own discretion” that the member’s answer is satisfactory.
Revocation. If the agreement ends, “AFRINIC will immediately revoke the number resources and otherwise cease providing the services without incurring any liability whatsoever.”
Liability. The most either side can owe is “the greater of the amount paid by The Applicant to AFRINIC during the six months immediately preceding the event giving rise to such liability or 100 USD”.
Amendment. AFRINIC may change the agreement, and changes take effect 30 days after they are posted. “In the event of an express refusal to be bound by the amendment(s) delivery of ‘services’ will be stopped forthwith.”
The same contract has the member acknowledge that its number resources “are not property (real, personal or intellectual)”. Cloud Innovation’s reading of the whole is blunt: “For a network, revoked addresses mean customers offline. For AFRINIC, the price of getting it wrong is a hundred dollars.”
2021: the clause is used
This is not a thought experiment. On 10 March 2021 AFRINIC’s management wrote to Cloud Innovation, a member since 2013. The letter gave the company 30 days to answer what the Supreme Court later called “purported breaches”, and said AFRINIC would “in its sole discretion” determine whether to terminate the agreement and reclaim the addresses.
The Court’s judgment of 19 July 2022 notes when that letter was sent: on the “first day of lockdown, when access to justice was very limited”.
On 8 July 2021 AFRINIC’s Board resolved to terminate the membership with immediate effect. What hung on that resolution, in Cloud Innovation’s words, was the addresses its customers’ networks run on: “operators in 60 countries who keep hundreds of millions of people online”.
“A registry that can put out a member at its sole discretion,” the company says, “holds every network hostage.”
What the Court did, three times
The Judge in Chambers of the Supreme Court of Mauritius restrained AFRINIC three times that year.
On 29 March 2021 the Court restrained AFRINIC from terminating, suspending or revoking the membership.
On 13 July 2021, five days after the Board’s resolution, an interim injunction restrained AFRINIC from “acting, in any manner whatsoever, on its Board Resolution dated 08 July 2021”, from “freezing, in any manner whatsoever, any or all of the resources allocated to the applicant”, from “denying the applicant access, in any manner whatsoever, to the AFRINIC WHOIS database” and from “reclaiming, in any manner whatsoever, any or all of the resources allocated to the applicant”. The judgment records what happened next: AFRINIC “failed to comply with the aforesaid order and deliberately flouted the duly served order dated 13 July 2021”. Two days later it gave the Judge an undertaking to comply in full.
On 1 December 2021 AFRINIC’s management wrote that the company’s services “may come to an end at any time”. On 3 December the Court restrained AFRINIC again, from terminating the membership “pending the final determination of the disputes between the parties”.
AFRINIC’s management then asked the Court to treat the member’s applications as an abuse of its process. The Court refused: “The applicant cannot be taxed for resorting to an independent court to safeguard its rights.”
The draft constitution: officers may end a membership
AFRINIC’s bylaws are being rewritten, and the draft keeps the power and moves it closer to the desk that would use it. Article 8.6 permits the suspension and termination of members to be delegated to officers, subject to safeguards and appeal. Article 8.5 keeps the rule that a terminated member returns its addresses.
“Membership decisions stay tied to control over the addresses a network runs on,” Cloud Innovation says, “the power AFRINIC tried to use against us in 2021.” The members must still approve any amendment. That vote is theirs to use.
Put out, but not free to walk out
A member who distrusts all this might decide to take its addresses to another registry. It cannot, if AFRINIC issued them. Under the transfer policy that AFRINIC’s Board ratified on 4 February 2026, in AFRINIC’s own words, “AFRINIC-issued IPv4 cannot be transferred out of the region”. AFRINIC’s own assessment said what the rule is for: “AFRINIC will not lose its current resource members to other RIRs in outgoing transfers.”
Cloud Innovation draws the two rules together: “So a member can be put out but cannot walk out: AFRINIC may end the relationship and keep the addresses, and the member may not end it and keep them.”
What protects you today
“A court,” the company answers. What stood between its customers’ networks and that power in 2021 was the Supreme Court of Mauritius.
It argues that a place on AFRINIC’s register of members should protect a member too: every eligible Resource Member should be recognised under company law, entered in the register and protected by the rights that come with it.
And it says the contract has the relationship upside down. “We say the opposite of that contract: the network that runs on an address owns it, and the registry only records it.” The case is set out under “Own your IP”. “We advocate secure ownership of lawfully held addresses, continuity of use, transferability and the freedom to change registry: no network should be put out at a registry’s whim.”
Sources
- AFRINIC, Registration Service Agreement.
- Supreme Court of Mauritius: interim order of 13 July 2021; judgment of 19 July 2022, 2022 SCJ 253; the order of 3 December 2021, on Cloud Innovation’s public record.
- Cloud Innovation: “Can AFRINIC terminate your membership, and take your addresses?”; “AFRINIC’s transfer policy”; “AFRINIC’s proposed constitution: what members would lose”; “Own your IP”.
Member Briefing
Read the full trend briefing
Members read the full briefing with the source notes behind every finding.
Strategic Circle
A daily briefing in your language, built from changes we have verified.
Join for USD 20/monthCancel anytime.
Members also get the full research library, a daily briefing on the networks they follow and the private forum.






