Summary
- AFRINIC’s own account of its audit, published in January 2021, says that “2,371,584 IPv4 addresses were misappropriated from AFRINIC’s pool of resources and attributed to organisations without justification”.
- By the same account, 1,060,864 of those addresses had been reclaimed and 1,310,720, “related to two distinct organisations”, had not. A former employee “was found to have misappropriated” resources from the pool, and AFRINIC reported the matter to the police.
- Cloud Innovation, which sets the findings out on a page of its own, says what would stop it happening again: members with real rights, and a registry that only keeps the record.
What AFRINIC said it found
A regional internet registry has one job that everything else rests on. It keeps an accurate record of who holds which addresses. In January 2021 AFRINIC published the result of what it called “an audit of all IPv4 number resources, which consisted of verifying the rightful custodianship of those resources”.
The central finding takes one sentence, and AFRINIC wrote it: “The audit reveals that 2,371,584 IPv4 addresses were misappropriated from AFRINIC’s pool of resources and attributed to organisations without justification.”
The misappropriation, AFRINIC wrote, “was brought into light around mid-2019”. No court had to establish any of this, and no member and no rival. It is the registry’s account of itself.
A former employee, and a report to the police
AFRINIC’s account goes on: “Following an internal investigation, a former employee was found to have misappropriated IP number resources forming part of AFRINIC’s pool of resources.” The matter, it says, “was reported to the Mauritian Central Criminal Investigation Division”, where an enquiry was then under way.
AFRINIC’s account does not say how many of the 2,371,584 addresses that person took. What it does say is where they went from and how: out of the registry’s own pool, into the names of organisations, “without justification”. Whoever did what, it was done inside AFRINIC’s database, under AFRINIC’s controls.
The count, in AFRINIC’s own figures
Of the 2,371,584 addresses, AFRINIC said 1,060,864 “have been reclaimed, i.e. deregistered from the AFRINIC WHOIS Database”. The other 1,310,720, “related to two distinct organisations”, were “yet to be reclaimed due to ongoing due diligence”. AFRINIC named neither organisation.
That is the registry’s own pool. The audit reports a second problem beside it, in older “legacy” address space: 1,799,168 legacy addresses that “appeared to have been compromised”, of which 936,704 were “currently under dispute and pending determination of rightful custodianship”.
Among the remedies AFRINIC then announced was “the adoption of a fraud and corruption policy, and the introduction of a whistleblowing mechanism”. A registry that adopts a fraud and corruption policy after auditing its own database has told its members what kind of problem it had.
The company that is usually blamed
Cloud Innovation is the AFRINIC member that the registry’s management tried to put out in 2021, and the one usually accused of taking Africa’s addresses. The people who repeat that accusation seldom mention the audit.
The company’s reply is on its page: “AFRINIC registered every address we hold, through its own process, to a member it has had since 2013.” The complaint of AFRINIC’s management, it says, “was never theft: it was about how AFRINIC’s own rules should be read”. AFRINIC’s published account of its audit names no company. And when AFRINIC’s management moved to end Cloud Innovation’s membership, the Supreme Court of Mauritius stopped it three times.
“None of this is our finding,” the company says of the audit. “It is AFRINIC’s own, about its own house.”
What the Court heard in 2024
Has the house been put in order since? The record of the Supreme Court of Mauritius says it has not.
On 25 November 2024 the Official Receiver, appointed by the Court after AFRINIC was left with too few directors to act and no chief executive, told the Court what was happening under him. Despite his instruction to AFRINIC’s staff, he said, “seven IP addresses have been issued without my permission” between 15 and 31 October 2024. The statement is on Cloud Innovation’s public record, with the transcript.
The order made that day records his undertakings, among them that “any entity who has become a member of AfriNIC without your consent from 19th of September 2023 till today, will not have the voting rights”. Addresses issued without the Receiver’s permission, and an order that had to deal with members admitted without his consent: nearly four years after the audit was published, in a registry already in the hands of a court-appointed officer.
Who answers to the members
As things stand, no one does. AFRINIC’s contract with its members caps its liability to a member at six months of fees or 100 USD, whichever is greater. A network whose addresses go astray in AFRINIC’s database can recover, at most, half a year of what it paid AFRINIC.
Nor can most members vote the people in charge out. AFRINIC’s register of members, by the Registrar of Companies’ record of 28 October 2026, names eight directors and one company. Cloud Innovation says that, on its information, more than 2,000 resource members have been left off it. “A member left off the register is left without the rights that come with it,” the company says. “Power that answers to no one does not stay clean.”
What keeps a registry clean
Cloud Innovation’s answer has three parts. Every eligible Resource Member should be recognised under company law, entered in AFRINIC’s register of members and protected by the rights that come with it. Elections should be held under AFRINIC’s constitution, as the Court ordered. And a registry should do one thing: keep an accurate record of who holds which addresses.
“A registry that answers to its members and to the Court,” the company says, “has no room for what AFRINIC’s audit found.”
Sources
- AFRINIC, “A Comprehensive Audit of the AFRINIC WHOIS Database”, January 2021, written by AFRINIC and archived by ARIN.
- Cloud Innovation: “AFRINIC corruption: what AFRINIC’s own audit found”; the public record, 25 November 2024; “AFRINIC court cases”; “AFRINIC’s members”.
- Supreme Court of Mauritius: order of 25 November 2024, SC/COM/MOT/000859/2024, full text and original.
Member Briefing
Read the full trend briefing
Members read the full briefing with the source notes behind every finding.
Strategic Circle
A daily briefing in your language, built from changes we have verified.
Join for USD 20/monthCancel anytime.
Members also get the full research library, a daily briefing on the networks they follow and the private forum.






