Summary

  • Cloud Innovation asked for AFRINIC’s Receiver. On 7 March 2023, when AFRINIC had no chief executive, an inquorate board of four and no members’ meeting since June 2022, it went to the Supreme Court of Mauritius at its own cost. No one else came to court.
  • Lawyers acting in AFRINIC’s name said Cloud Innovation should pay USD 100,000 before being heard. On 12 September 2023 the Court was “satisfied that the respondent had the necessary locus standi”, the respondent being Cloud Innovation; on 15 October 2024 the appeal brought in AFRINIC’s name was set aside and the order restored.
  • That receivership is why AFRINIC’s members had an election. Since then the Receiver has annulled it, extended his mandate without Cloud Innovation’s consent and, on 29 October 2026, asked for Cloud Innovation’s removal from the register of members.

Who asked for AFRINIC’s Receiver?

Cloud Innovation did. On 7 March 2023, by motion supported by affidavit, it applied to the Bankruptcy Division of the Supreme Court of Mauritius under section 178 of the Companies Act for interim orders, including the appointment of the Official Receiver as Receiver “for the purpose of holding the ring”, so that AFRINIC’s assets and the value of its business were preserved. The Court of Civil Appeal sets this out in its judgment of 15 October 2024, 2024 SCJ 473.

Cloud Innovation went to court as a member of AFRINIC, in its own words, and it paid: its letter of 14 July 2025 says it “shouldered legal costs to push for a timely election”.

Why did AFRINIC need a Receiver?

AFRINIC needed a Receiver because it could no longer govern itself, and no one else came to court.

The Court of Civil Appeal records that “the appellant’s last AGMM was held in June 2022”. The appellant is AFRINIC; the AGMM is its Annual General Members’ Meeting, and the next one should have been held by September 2023. The same judgment records that AFRINIC “had at best an inquorate board of directors (four only)”. A quorum is five.

AFRINIC has also had no chief executive since November 2022.

No one else asked the Court to act. Cloud Innovation did.

What did AFRINIC’s side argue, and what did the Court decide?

Lawyers acting in AFRINIC’s name argued that Cloud Innovation should not be heard at all; the Court was satisfied that it had standing and made the order.

In a letter of 24 July 2023, those lawyers objected that Cloud Innovation, “being a foreign company not owning any immoveable property in Mauritius, must provide security for costs in the sum of USD 100,000 before being allowed to proceed with the present application”. They also said that it “has no locus standi”, giving as their reason that “it is not a member/shareholder” of AFRINIC.

On 12 September 2023 the Court, “after being satisfied that the respondent had the necessary locus standi to enter the application and that the prayers sought for were justified, reasonable and fair”, made the order. The respondent is Cloud Innovation. The Court appointed the Official Receiver and directed him “to see to it that the election process as per the Constitution of Afrinic Ltd be carried out so that a proper board could be constituted and also for the appointment of the Chief Executive Officer”.

An appeal was then lodged in AFRINIC’s name. On 15 October 2024 the Court of Civil Appeal held that the lawyers “had no locus standi to lodge and appear in the present appeal in the name of the appellant” and set the appeal aside. It wrote: “We restore the Order made by the learned Judge of the Commercial Division of the Supreme Court in an oral judgment delivered on 12 September 2023.” It added: “The reconstitution of the appellant’s Board of directors is certainly a matter of utmost urgency.”

The rest of the litigation is in BTW’s record of every AFRINIC court decision since 2021.

Why did AFRINIC’s members get an election?

Because Cloud Innovation asked for the receivership, and the Court’s order of 12 September 2023 directed the Receiver to carry out the election under AFRINIC’s constitution.

Cloud Innovation then kept the election on the Court’s agenda. On its motion, SC/COM/MOT/000859/2024, the Supreme Court on 25 November 2024 ordered AFRINIC, at the Receiver’s request, to conduct the election process by the end of June 2025, as Cloud Innovation’s public record sets out.

On 12 February 2025 the Court appointed the current Receiver. By Cloud Innovation’s account, it did so on Cloud Innovation’s application, SC/COM/MOT/000082/2025.

Cloud Innovation’s position is plain: without its standing as a member there would have been no receivership, and without the receivership no election.

What has the Receiver done since?

The Receiver annulled the election, extended his mandate without Cloud Innovation’s consent and, on 29 October 2026, asked for Cloud Innovation to be removed from AFRINIC’s register of members.

In June 2025 he annulled the entire Board election over, in Cloud Innovation’s words, “one disputed proxy”. His rules for the rerun banned the proxy voting that Article 12.12 of AFRINIC’s constitution allows.

He obtained an extension of his mandate to 30 September 2025 without Cloud Innovation’s knowledge or consent, though the receivership began on its application, as Cloud Innovation’s follow-up letter records.

On 29 October 2026 the Receiver asked the Registrar of Companies to remove Cloud Innovation from AFRINIC’s register of members, with copies to ministers. AFRINIC’s statement on the notice identified no court order requiring the removal. On 3 November 2026 Cloud Innovation announced that it will bring the Receiver’s conduct before the Court that appointed him. BTW has followed what the Court asked of AFRINIC’s Receiver and what he did.

Lu Heng, the internet entrepreneur behind Cloud Innovation, wrote in Note 21 on 24 December 2025: “I act from inside the system, not outside it.” Going to court, and holding the Receiver to the task the Court gave him, is acting from inside. In the same note he wrote: “Stopping institutional abuse is therefore not disruption. It is system defense.”

A Receiver who asks for Cloud Innovation to be removed from the register of members is denying the ground he stands on: the receivership exists because Cloud Innovation applied for it. The full record is on Cloud Innovation’s page on AFRINIC’s Receiver.

Sources