Summary

  • Counts of addresses registered with AFRINIC said to be “detected outside Africa” add up a commercial database’s guesses, and they answer a question that no rule on out-of-region use asks.
  • The one sentence in AFRINIC’s policy manual on use outside its region is a condition of the rationing that began on 31 March 2017; Cloud Innovation’s four blocks were allocated between 2013 and 2016.
  • An IP address is a number in a record: it has no continent, no registry decides where it is routed, and ARIN allows use outside its region in writing.

What are the counts of AFRINIC addresses “detected outside Africa”?

They are sums of a database’s guesses, and they answer a question no rule asks.

A commercial database estimates where an address is seen. Somebody adds up those estimates for addresses registered with AFRINIC, and the tally is then published against Cloud Innovation as though it were a finding.

Nobody had to detect anything. Where Cloud Innovation’s addresses are used is published, prefix by prefix, for anyone to read.

Cloud Innovation puts it in one sentence: “A tally of where numbers are seen is not a finding that a rule was broken.”

Do the counts show that a rule was broken?

No: they answer a question no rule asks, and the one sentence that speaks of use outside the region does not reach Cloud Innovation’s blocks.

AFRINIC’s Consolidated Policy Manual has a single sentence on use outside its region. Section 5.4.6.2 reads: “AFRINIC resources are for AFRINIC service region and any use outside the region should be solely in support of connectivity back to the AFRINIC region.”

That sentence stands among the conditions for receiving addresses “during the Exhaustion Phase”, the rationing of the last IPv4 addresses AFRINIC had to allocate. By AFRINIC’s own account, the first phase of that rationing “started on the 31st of March 2017”.

Cloud Innovation’s blocks came first. By AFRINIC’s own statistics, the four blocks were allocated in July 2013, December 2014, December 2015 and September 2016, all before the rationing began, as Cloud Innovation sets out in Did Cloud Innovation break AFRINIC’s rules?. BTW has also examined AFRINIC’s 2020 letter to Cloud Innovation: what it charged, what it cited, and the answer.

Does an IP address belong to a continent?

No. An IP address is a number in a record, and it works because every network in the world accepts that one network uses it and no other.

The document that first proposed regional registries, RFC 1366 of 1992, gave the reason for them: registries in distinct geographic areas “may be better able to serve the local community in terms of language and local customs”. Language and customs are a matter of service, not of territory.

A region tells a network which registry to apply to. It says nothing about where that network’s customers are. BTW has set out why an IP address has no continent.

Can a registry decide where an address is used?

No: where an address is routed lies outside the registry system altogether.

RFC 7020, which describes the Internet Numbers Registry System, says so in terms: “whether IP addresses are actually announced to the Internet and the manner of their advertisement into the Internet’s routing system are operational considerations outside the scope of the Internet Numbers Registry System”.

Even AFRINIC agrees. Its own summary of its 2026 transfer policy says the “Regional” label that policy puts on the addresses AFRINIC has issued does not “Alter operational routing rights” or “Change the day-to-day use of resources”.

A registry records which network holds which numbers. The network serves its customers where they are.

Do other registries have a rule against use outside their region?

ARIN does not: the registry for North America allows such use in writing.

Section 9 of ARIN’s Number Resource Policy Manual is headed “Out of Region Use” and begins: “ARIN registered resources may be used outside the ARIN service region.”

A network that registers with ARIN and serves customers on other continents breaks no rule. The internet has no customs posts. BTW has examined AFRINIC’s rule on out-of-region use and whose addresses it covers.

What should a reader make of such a count?

Ask which rule it measures. For addresses allocated before 31 March 2017 there is none. For any address, a tally of where a database thinks numbers are seen measures a database, not a network’s obligations.

An address is a number: it has no continent, and it serves the network that runs on it, wherever that network’s customers are.

Lu Heng, the internet entrepreneur behind Cloud Innovation, put it plainly in Note 2 on 17 September 2025: “An address book helps you find a house. It does not give its keeper ownership of the city.” He ended the Note with a line that answers every such count: “The Internet works because no one owns it.”

Cloud Innovation answers these counts in full on its page on out-of-region use.

Sources