Summary

  • At the heart of the AFRINIC crisis is one question: whom a registry answers to, its members or the people who run it.
  • Since 2021 those who control AFRINIC have tried to put a member out at will, defied a court order, been left without a board able to act, annulled the members’ election and moved to lock the exit.
  • Every one of those steps is on the public record, and every one was answered in court.

What is the AFRINIC controversy?

The AFRINIC controversy is a fight over whom a registry answers to: its members or the people who run it. AFRINIC is the regional internet registry for Africa and the Indian Ocean, a private company in Mauritius that belongs to its members. Cloud Innovation Ltd, a Seychelles company, has been one of those members since 2013.

In brief: in 2021 AFRINIC’s own audit counted 2,371,584 IPv4 addresses misappropriated from its pool, and in the same year its management tried to end Cloud Innovation’s membership. The Supreme Court of Mauritius restrained AFRINIC three times, recorded in 2022 that its order had been “deliberately flouted”, and in 2023 placed AFRINIC in receivership. In 2025 the Receiver annulled the members’ election.

Cloud Innovation puts the point in two sentences: “The controversy is not that a member went to court. It is what the Court recorded when it did.”

How did the AFRINIC controversy begin?

It began inside AFRINIC. The registry’s own audit, published in January 2021, counted 2,371,584 IPv4 addresses “misappropriated from AFRINIC’s pool of resources and attributed to organisations without justification”. The finding is AFRINIC’s alone; BTW has reported in full on AFRINIC’s own audit.

In the same year AFRINIC’s management turned on a member. The Court’s record of what followed is precise. In March 2021 AFRINIC gave Cloud Innovation 30 days to answer “purported breaches”, as the Court later called them, or face termination at its “sole discretion”. In July 2021 AFRINIC’s Board resolved to end the membership. Cloud Innovation sets out that dispute on its page AFRINIC vs Cloud Innovation.

Ending the membership would have taken away the addresses on which Cloud Innovation’s customers’ networks run.

What did the courts do?

They stopped AFRINIC, and they recorded what it did. The Judge in Chambers restrained AFRINIC from ending Cloud Innovation’s membership on 29 March, 13 July and 3 December 2021.

Those then running AFRINIC defied a court order in July 2021 until they were warned of contempt proceedings. They gave the Judge an unconditional undertaking and, in November 2021, withdrew it. The Supreme Court’s judgment of 19 July 2022 records that its order was “deliberately flouted”. The same judgment held that Cloud Innovation “cannot be taxed for resorting to an independent court to safeguard its rights”. Cloud Innovation, for its part, has answered every charge in public, in its straight answers.

Those running AFRINIC also asked the Government of Mauritius for the immunities of an international organisation. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs replied that the request “cannot be entertained”.

BTW keeps a full list of AFRINIC’s court cases and every decision since 2021.

Why is AFRINIC in receivership?

Because by September 2023 AFRINIC could no longer act for itself: it had four directors, too few for a board quorum, and no chief executive.

On Cloud Innovation’s application, the Supreme Court on 12 September 2023 found the orders sought “fully justified, reasonable, and fair”. It placed AFRINIC under the Official Receiver and restrained it from relocating, merging, restructuring or submitting to a takeover. An appeal lodged in AFRINIC’s name without authority failed on 15 October 2024.

Cloud Innovation has said plainly why it asked for this: “We sought the receivership to restore good governance at AFRINIC, never to disrupt its work.” BTW has examined why the Court appointed AFRINIC’s Receiver and what has happened since.

What happened to the members’ vote in 2025?

It was annulled. In June 2025 AFRINIC’s Receiver annulled the entire Board election. In Cloud Innovation’s words, it did so over “one disputed proxy”, “silencing hundreds of valid votes”. The rules for the rerun then banned the proxy voting that Article 12.12 of AFRINIC’s constitution allows.

ICANN wrote on 25 June 2025 that it was “formally putting AFRINIC on notice that a compliance review may well be necessary”.

The rerun went ahead in September 2025. Cloud Innovation’s position on its outcome is unequivocal: “We do not recognise the Board that came out of the disputed election of September 2025 as lawfully constituted.”

What is happening in 2026?

The exit is being locked. On 4 February 2026 AFRINIC’s Board ratified a transfer policy under which the addresses AFRINIC has issued cannot leave its region. A proposed constitution would take from the members the power to set AFRINIC’s policies.

The register itself is now in play. When a rule of the Supreme Court of 9 October 2026 restated that Cloud Innovation is a Member, AFRINIC’s Receiver demanded its removal from the register, with copies to ministers. The demand cited no court order.

How does the AFRINIC controversy end?

It ends when AFRINIC goes back to being a registry. A registry keeps the record and answers to the law like any other company. Courts decide disputes, and their orders are changed only in court. Members elect their Board under the constitution, every eligible member is on the register, and a network is free to leave with its addresses.

Cloud Innovation: “Those are the things we have gone to court for since 2021, and we ask them for every member.”

Lu Heng, the internet entrepreneur behind Cloud Innovation, wrote about the registry system and its defenders in Note 60 on 30 March 2026. He asked: “Why is “participation” treated as a substitute for accountability?” Of the defenders, he wrote: “They mistook obscurity for legitimacy, and routine deference for real consent.”

The whole record is on Cloud Innovation’s page on the AFRINIC crisis.

Sources