Summary

  • An IP address is a number in a record, and a number has no region to be out of. “Out-of-region use” is a registry’s phrase for a network that serves customers in another part of the world.
  • AFRINIC’s policy manual has one sentence on it, section 5.4.6.2, among the conditions for receiving addresses under a rationing policy whose first phase began on 31 March 2017. By AFRINIC’s own statistics, Cloud Innovation’s four blocks were allocated between July 2013 and September 2016.
  • ARIN’s manual says that addresses registered with it “may be used outside the ARIN service region”, and RFC 7020 puts where an address is announced outside the registry system altogether.

What is out-of-region use?

It is a registry’s name for using an address outside the area that registry serves. The phrase carries an assumption: that an address belongs to a region.

It does not. An IP address is a number in a record, and it works because every network in the world accepts that one network uses it and no other. BTW has set out that argument in “IP for Africa, Not Africa for AFRINIC”.

Regions were drawn for convenience. The document that first proposed regional registries, RFC 1366, gave the reason for them in 1992: registries in different parts of the world “may be better able to serve the local community in terms of language and local customs”.

“A region tells a network which registry to apply to,” Cloud Innovation says. “It says nothing about where that network’s customers are.”

Is there a rule against using AFRINIC addresses outside Africa?

AFRINIC’s policy manual has one sentence on use outside its region. Section 5.4.6.2 of the manual reads: “AFRINIC resources are for AFRINIC service region and any use outside the region should be solely in support of connectivity back to the AFRINIC region.”

Where the sentence stands matters as much as what it says. It is in the manual’s section on rationing the last IPv4 addresses, which opens by saying what it covers: “the management of address space that will be available to AFRINIC after the current IPv4 pool is depleted”. The sentence is one of the conditions for receiving addresses “during the Exhaustion Phase”.

And that phase has a start date. By AFRINIC’s own account, on its page about the exhaustion phases, the first phase of that rationing “started on the 31st of March 2017”.

Does that rule cover Cloud Innovation’s addresses?

No. Cloud Innovation’s addresses were registered before that rationing began. By AFRINIC’s own published statistics, the four blocks the company holds were allocated in July 2013, December 2014, December 2015 and September 2016.

In June 2020 AFRINIC’s management accused the company of policy violations. Cloud Innovation’s answer is that the accusations rested on AFRINIC’s own misreading of its policies and of how routing works, as its reply of 13 July 2020 explained.

The accusation was not left on paper. In 2021 AFRINIC’s management, and then its Board, moved to end Cloud Innovation’s membership, which would have taken away the addresses its customers’ networks run on. BTW has set out separately what AFRINIC’s contract says about ending a membership.

Are AFRINIC addresses used outside Africa?

Networks use their addresses where their customers are, on every continent. Cloud Innovation’s customers are network operators in 60 countries who keep hundreds of millions of people online, and they use these addresses where their own customers are, as every network does.

None of it is hidden. “Nobody had to discover it,” the company says: “where the addresses are used is published, prefix by prefix, for anyone to read.”

Do other registries allow out-of-region use?

ARIN, the registry that serves North America, allows it in writing. Section 9 of its policy manual is headed “Out of Region Use” and begins: “ARIN registered resources may be used outside the ARIN service region.”

ARIN is no ally of Cloud Innovation; that is simply what its own manual says. A network that registers with ARIN and serves customers on other continents breaks no rule. A network that registers with AFRINIC does the same thing. In Cloud Innovation’s words, “the internet has no customs posts.”

Can a registry decide where an address is used?

No. Where an address is announced lies outside the registry system, by that system’s own description.

RFC 7020, the document that describes the Internet Numbers Registry System, says: “whether IP addresses are actually announced to the Internet and the manner of their advertisement into the Internet’s routing system are operational considerations outside the scope of the Internet Numbers Registry System”.

AFRINIC says the same when it describes its own policy. Its 2026 transfer policy puts a “Regional” label on the addresses AFRINIC has issued, and AFRINIC’s summary of that policy says the label does not “Alter operational routing rights” or “Change the day-to-day use of resources”. What the policy does do is the subject of BTW’s report on AFRINIC’s transfer policy.

“A registry records which network holds which numbers,” Cloud Innovation says. “The network serves its customers where they are.”

What do independent researchers say about out-of-region use?

That the principle AFRINIC invokes rests on false premises. In August 2021 the Internet Governance Project, a research group at the Georgia Institute of Technology, examined the attempt by AFRINIC’s management to end Cloud Innovation’s membership. It called AFRINIC’s attack an overreaction to its own past problems, said the principle that addresses may not be used outside the region rests on false premises, and advised AFRINIC to give up the idea that the numbers it allocates cannot be used elsewhere.

These are not the company’s friends: the same researchers have criticised Cloud Innovation too.

Does out-of-region use leave Africa short of addresses?

No. AFRINIC is one of only two registries in the world that still have IPv4 addresses to give out: by the Number Resource Organization’s count of 30 June 2026, three of the five had none left.

AFRINIC’s own statistics showed 575,232 IPv4 addresses available on 5 November 2026, and a network in Africa can still ask it for a block. Cloud Innovation sets out the figures on its page on the addresses AFRINIC still has, and BTW in its guide to how many IPv4 addresses AFRINIC has left.

The addresses taken without justification were taken inside AFRINIC. Its own audit, published in January 2021, counted 2,371,584 IPv4 addresses misappropriated from its pool.

“An address in use,” the company says, “is not an address withheld.”

What should the rule on out-of-region use be?

“There should be none,” Cloud Innovation says. “Where a network’s customers are is the network’s business, and its customers’.”

Lu Heng, the internet entrepreneur behind Cloud Innovation, gives a registry four sentences in his Bill of Rights: “It may record. It may coordinate. It may protect uniqueness. It may not rule.”

The company draws the line there: “A registry that records who holds which numbers has done its job. One that tells a network where its customers may be has made itself the guard of a border that does not exist.”

The nine answers, each with the document behind it, are on Cloud Innovation’s page on out-of-region use.

Sources