Summary

  • In July 2019 ARDC sold 44.192.0.0/10 — 4,194,304 contiguous IPv4 addresses — for $109,051,904 of gross proceeds against a $545,260 broker commission, and it printed both numbers in audited statements and in its Form 990.
  • Not one ARDC document reviewed here names the buyer; ARIN's registry record for NET-44-192-0-0-1 names Amazon.com, Inc. (AMAZO-4), registered the same day.
  • Four years of ARDC filings also disagree with each other about what it gave away in 2020, and no document reviewed says which column is right.

The block, the remainder, and the sentence that sold it

The asset was never a single address or a single network. 44.0.0.0/8 was an entire slash-eight, the kind of legacy allocation that predates the regional registry system and that no one has been able to obtain since exhaustion. ARDC carved the top quarter off it. What remained — 44.0.0.0/9 and 44.128.0.0/10 — is still described in the announcement as more than 12 million addresses held for amateur radio use. (ARDC, 18 July 2019)

That is the structural fact a reader should hold onto. A quarter of the space was converted into money. Three quarters stayed as address space. The two halves have lived very different lives since, and the filings treat them separately for good reason: one is an endowment, the other is a network.

ARDC's own FAQ describes what was sold as about four million contiguous addresses and says the proceeds established the endowment that funds its grants programme. It also records two things about how the decision was taken: the Board of Directors decided unanimously, and every potential buyer demanded confidentiality for the transaction. (ARDC FAQ) The FAQ then declines to name the company, calling it only "a very big company with a significant internet presence." (ARDC FAQ)

Confidentiality demanded by every bidder is a real commercial constraint, and ARDC states it plainly. It is not the same thing as an absence of information about the transaction, because the seller chose to publish the arithmetic in full while keeping the counterparty out of its own record. Those are two separate editorial decisions, and only one of them was made in the open.

The audited price

The numbers arrived with the 2019 financial statements. ARDC, the statements say, elected to sell on a one-time basis one quarter of its IPv4 addresses to "a large internet company," yielding $109,051,904 of proceeds. (ARDC, financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2019) The gain was $108,506,644, net of a broker commission of $545,260. (same statements)

The 2019 Form 990 reports the same three amounts — gross sales price, sales expenses, net gain — and nothing that identifies the purchaser. (ARDC, 2019 Form 990) Two document classes, one set of figures, one silence.

The commission deserves its own sentence, because it is the only third-party cost the filings break out. $545,260 on $109,051,904 of gross proceeds is roughly half a percent, and it is presented as a sales expense rather than buried in a professional-fees line. A reader can therefore reconstruct the entire seller-side flow from two documents and still not know who paid it.

The statements also show the shape of the balance sheet immediately after. At 31 December 2019, total assets and net assets without donor restrictions both stood at $109,130,548, with investments of $109,003,070. (same statements) The organisation had, in the space of a year, become an investment pool with a radio mission attached. The auditor's report on those statements is addressed to the Board of Directors and dated 31 July 2020, a year after the sale and eight months after the year end; the retrieved text names no individual officer as its signatory. (same statements)

Twenty-six dollars, and what it is not

44.192.0.0/10 holds 4,194,304 addresses. Divide the printed gross proceeds by that count and the answer is exactly $26.00 per address. That is arithmetic on two published numbers, not a price either party stated. (ARIN record, 2019 statements)

Why does the distinction matter? Because a per-address price is the one number in a transfer like this that other holders of legacy space will quote back at each other for years. If ARDC had announced $26 per address, that would be a public benchmark. What ARDC announced was a gross total against a block size, from which anyone can derive the same figure. The derivable number is exact; it is simply not the sellers' own unit price, and no document reviewed states an agreed price per address.

Readers comparing it to their own valuations should also remember that the commission sits inside the seller's proceeds: the net per address is lower, and the buyer's side of the transaction is not disclosed at all.

The block's contiguity is part of why the division is so clean. A /10 is four million addresses in one piece, with a single registry entry and a single transfer, not a scraped-together portfolio. Scarcity economics does not get a tidier specimen: one seller, one buyer, one date, one number, and a price per unit that appears only when you do the division yourself.

The name in the other registry

ARDC did not publish the buyer. ARIN did, in the ordinary course of doing its job.

The registry record NET-44-192-0-0-1 lists 44.192.0.0/10 as registered to Amazon.com, Inc., handle AMAZO-4, with a registration date of 18 July 2019. (ARIN Whois-RWS record NET-44-192-0-0-1) The date is the same day as the mailing-list announcement. A registry records an organisation, not a contract: the record establishes the registered holder and the date it appears, and does not by itself resolve which Amazon entity signed the purchase agreement. That qualification belongs next to the name, not in a footnote, because the registry is the instrument being read.

So the article's central asymmetry is not an accusation, it is a filing pattern. Across the audited financial statements, the Form 990, the FAQ and the finances page reviewed for this piece, no ARDC document names the counterparty. (2019 statements, 2019 Form 990, FAQ) The counterparty is instead recoverable from a public registry, on a date, by anyone who knows which block to look up. ARDC was not hiding the price; it was declining to state the name, in documents that state almost everything else.

There is also a document that might have carried the name and did not reach this reading. ARDC's finances page lists, among its 2019 records, a "2019-07-30 Courtesy Notice to CA Attorney-General, re Sale of Assets." (ARDC finances) The notice's contents and signatory were not obtained, and this article makes no claim about what it says. Its existence is the point: a filing was made to a state charity regulator twelve days after the announcement, and only its title is in the public index reviewed here.

What the money became

The FAQ says the proceeds established the grants endowment. The filings show what that meant in practice, and they show a grant programme that spends a fraction of what the endowment earns in a good year.

In 2020 ARDC's annual report states that it distributed 22 grants totalling $2,690,312. (ARDC 2020 annual report) Its 2020 grants page lists the individual awards with dates, recipients and purposes, including a $400,000 Foundation for Amateur Radio scholarship award dated 24 November 2020. (ARDC 2020 grants) That page is the closest thing in the record to a receipt for the endowment's purpose: named money leaving the organisation for named work, one line at a time.

The later years are larger and are presented in two bases. ARDC's 2024 annual report tabulates 2021 as $10,798,573 on an accrual basis and $9,247,203 on a cash basis, 2022 as $6,904,678 and $8,004,191, and 2023 as $6,345,764 and $5,880,342. (ARDC 2024 annual report, ARDC 2023 audited statements page) Summing the accrual column with the 2024 Form 990-PF accrual figure gives roughly $27.47 million of grantmaking across 2021–2024; summing the cash column with the 2024 990-PF cash figure gives roughly $27.16 million. Those totals are this article's arithmetic on printed figures, not a statement ARDC made.

Set that against the principal. ARDC's 2023 page reports beginning-of-year assets of $107,895,897 and end-of-year assets of $117,236,719. (ARDC 2023 audited statements page) The 2022 page says the ending 2022 balance of about $108 million was not significantly less than the initial 2020 balance of about $109 million, even after that year's disbursements. (ARDC 2022 audited statements page) By 31 December 2024, audited total assets were $128,192,418 and net assets $127,181,996. (ARDC 2024 financial statements)

The inference a reader can draw, and it is an inference: over the four years to 2024, investment returns outran roughly $27 million of disbursements, so the endowment ended larger than it began. That is what a perpetual fund is supposed to do. It is also the reason the sale can be described without drama as a conversion — an irreversible one — of address space into an income-producing asset that will outlive every director who voted for it.

Three totals for one year, and a column swap

Here the record stops being tidy, and the article should not tidy it.

For 2020 the filings offer three different numbers. The 2020 annual report says 22 grants totalling $2,690,312. (ARDC 2020 annual report) The 2020 Form 990-PF reports $3,004,625 of grants and contributions paid in Part XV, and $3,155,532 on line 25 for the same year. (ARDC 2020 Form 990-PF) The 2024 annual report then tabulates 2020 as $3,155,532 and $3,004,625 in its two columns — that is, the two 990-PF figures, assigned to columns in the opposite order to the 990-PF's own Part XV and line 25 — and does not carry the $2,690,312 figure at all. (ARDC 2024 annual report)

Three figures, two bases, one year, and no document reviewed states which assignment is correct or why the annual report's total differs from the tax return's. This is a reconciliation defect across document classes, not an allegation that anyone misstated anything: each number is attributable to its own filing and its own basis, and an annual report, an accrual return and a cash return can legitimately differ.

But a reader trying to answer the simple question — how much did ARDC give away in 2020? — has to choose an instrument first, and the institution's own later summary makes that choice harder rather than easier by relabelling the columns.

The same kind of gap shows up in 2024, where the audited statements report grant expense net of refunds of $3,100,062 and $6,246,219 for 2024 and 2023 respectively, while the 2024 Form 990-PF reports total assets of $128,192,418 and line 25 contributions, gifts and grants paid of $3,421,327 and $4,029,781. (ARDC 2024 financial statements, ARDC 2024 Form 990-PF) Net of refunds is not the same measure as grants paid, and a 990-PF's two columns are not the same pair as an audited statement's single line. The figures are all plausible; they are simply not interchangeable, and nothing in the record reconciles them.

Who signed, and what the signature covers

The 2019 Form 990 lists the people in office: Brian Kantor as former president and CEO, Kimberly Claffy as a director, A D Barksdale Garbee II as treasurer, Phil Karn as president and John Gilmore as secretary. (ARDC 2019 Form 990) The officer signature block identifies the signing officer as Bdale Garbee, Treasurer. (same return)

That signature is worth stating precisely and no more. A treasurer signs a return because the return requires a treasurer's signature; it attests to the filing, not to a personal decision about who should be named as the buyer. No reviewed document contains a first-person statement by any officer about the confidentiality term or the identity of the counterparty. The people who made the decision are named in the record as an office and as a unanimous Board; the individual who carries the pen on the return is a role, and the role would have carried the pen whoever held it.

So the through-line here is not a person. It is the distance between two documents: a tax return that prints $109,051,904 and $545,260 and $108,506,644, and a registry record that prints a company name against the same block on the same day. Both are public. Only one of them was ever intended to answer the question a reader asks first.

What a reader can still check

Four checks are open, and each has an address rather than an argument.

First, the price. The 2019 statements and the 2019 Form 990 print the gross proceeds, the commission and the gain in the same amounts. Anyone can verify the $26.00 division with a calculator and should label it as derived, because ARDC did not state it.

Second, the counterparty. The ARIN record for NET-44-192-0-0-1 names Amazon.com, Inc. with an 18 July 2019 registration date. (ARIN record) The open question is which Amazon entity contracted, and the registry does not answer it.

Third, the regulator. The finances page lists a 30 July 2019 courtesy notice to the California Attorney General concerning the sale of assets. (ARDC finances) Its contents and signatory are not in this reading, and no conclusion here depends on them.

Fourth, the reconciliation. A reader who wants ARDC's 2020 grantmaking has to pick a document class and say which one; the annual report, the 990-PF's two lines and the 2024 summary table give three answers.

The broader lesson is uncomfortable for anyone who assumes that publication equals disclosure. ARDC published almost everything that could be published about the money — and the money is exact, auditable, cross-referenced across four document classes. The one fact that would let an outsider price the deal properly, the identity of the buyer, sat in a different public register the whole time, waiting for someone to look up the block. (ARDC directory entry)