Summary

  • Lu Heng and AFRINIC: Lu Heng is the internet entrepreneur behind Cloud Innovation, a member of AFRINIC since 2013. The dispute began in 2021, when AFRINIC’s management, and then its Board, moved to end his company’s membership. The Supreme Court of Mauritius stopped it three times.
  • AFRINIC itself registered every address Cloud Innovation holds. The addresses that were found taken without justification were taken inside AFRINIC: its own audit counted 2,371,584.
  • His position is in writing. In Note 78 he says: “An IP address is a number.” “It has no soil, no flag and no passport.” The network that runs on an address owns it, and the registry only records it.

Who is Lu Heng?

Lu Heng is the internet entrepreneur behind Cloud Innovation. He studied International Economics and Business at the University of Groningen, stood for election to the Executive Council of APNIC, the Asia-Pacific internet registry, in 2023, and since 2025 has published his Notes on internet governance at heng.lu.

Cloud Innovation, established in 2013, is one of his businesses in internet infrastructure, and it has been a member of AFRINIC since 2013. He worked inside the registry system for years before his company ever went to court. Of those years he writes, in Note 43: “I did not begin from opposition. I began from participation.”

What is Lu Heng’s dispute with AFRINIC?

It began when AFRINIC’s management tried to put his company out. In 2021 AFRINIC’s management, and then its Board, moved to end Cloud Innovation’s membership. That would have taken back the addresses its customers’ networks run on: in the company’s words, “operators in 60 countries who keep hundreds of millions of people online”.

Through his company, Lu Heng went to the Supreme Court of Mauritius. The Court stopped AFRINIC three times that year: on 29 March, on 13 July, by an interim order that can be read in full, and on 3 December.

The Court has ruled for the company again and again since. On 12 September 2023, on Cloud Innovation’s application, it placed AFRINIC in receivership. On 25 November 2024, on Cloud Innovation’s motion, it set the deadline for AFRINIC’s elections. On 11 June 2025, on AFRINIC’s own application, it ordered that Cloud Innovation be entered in AFRINIC’s register of members. Every decision is listed, with its document, in BTW’s guide to the AFRINIC court cases.

“The dispute is not with AFRINIC, which belongs to its members,” the company says, “but with those who control it.”

Did Lu Heng take Africa’s IP addresses?

No. AFRINIC registered every address Cloud Innovation holds, through its own process, to a member it has had since 2013. The complaint of AFRINIC’s management was never theft. It was about how AFRINIC’s own rules should be read.

Addresses were taken without justification, but inside AFRINIC. Its own audit found 2,371,584 IPv4 addresses “misappropriated from AFRINIC’s pool of resources and attributed to organisations without justification”. BTW has set out what that audit found.

Lu Heng’s answer is in Note 78. “An IP address is a number.” “It has no soil, no flag and no passport.” Of the registrations themselves he writes: “Nothing was taken from Africa by the networks that registered there.” And of the audit: “What went missing went missing in the registry.”

What does he actually argue about IP addresses?

Those he took to court prefer a label for him to an answer to him. His argument is in writing, and it is about who owns an address: the network that runs on it owns it, and the registry only records it.

“An address book helps you find a house,” he writes in Note 2. “It does not give its keeper ownership of the city.”

His Bill of Rights, Note 72, allows a registry four sentences: “It may record. It may coordinate. It may protect uniqueness. It may not rule.”

He takes the slogan “IP for Africa” at its word. “IP for Africa means that a network in Lagos, Bujumbura or Maseru owns the addresses it runs on,” he writes. “The deed belongs to the network, not to the registry.” And: “A monopoly is not a mandate.”

That is his view, and it is Cloud Innovation’s: secure ownership of lawfully held addresses, continuity of use, transferability and the freedom to change registry. What a registry records, and what it claims the power to take back, is the subject of BTW’s guide to AFRINIC IPv4 addresses.

Is Lu Heng trying to destroy AFRINIC?

No. He depends on a registry that works. “My actions are not aimed at undermining the system,” he writes in Note 21. “I depend on a stable registry system more than most participants.”

The record agrees with him. In 2023, on Cloud Innovation’s application, the Supreme Court restrained AFRINIC from relocating, merging, restructuring or submitting to a takeover, and appointed a Receiver to see that elections are held under its constitution. The company sought that to restore good governance at AFRINIC, never to disrupt its work.

When AFRINIC’s Receiver annulled an entire election over what the company calls “one disputed proxy”, Cloud Innovation asked the Court for an orderly wind-up under its supervision and proposed a successor registry, so that African networks keep their registry services without interruption. BTW answers the questions about the AFRINIC wind up separately. “What has to survive,” the company says, “is the record the networks depend on, not the people who misused it.”

Lu Heng puts it in two sentences: “Stopping institutional abuse is therefore not disruption. It is system defense.”

Why does he keep going to court?

Because that is where a member’s rights are decided, and each application answered a new move against his company.

AFRINIC’s management asked the Supreme Court to treat those applications as an abuse of its process. On 19 July 2022 the Court refused. Cloud Innovation, the judgment says, “cannot be taxed for resorting to an independent court to safeguard its rights”.

The courtroom was not the company’s only offer. In June 2022 it offered mediation without conditions. AFRINIC’s management did not even acknowledge the offer.

Lu Heng’s explanation is one sentence long: “When discretionary authority threatens economic continuity, survival demands legal clarity.”

Why is he the one fighting this?

Because most members who are wronged by a registry cannot. “I am certainly not the first victim of this system,” he writes in Note 55. Of those who came before him: “Most never had the resources, incentives, or endurance to fight.”

He describes his own place in it this way: “In that sense, I am likely the first survivor. Not the first person harmed, but the first person who remained standing long enough to prove that the harm was never singular.”

The orders his company has obtained since 2021 are on the public record, for every member to read and to use. Cloud Innovation asks the same recognition for all of them: every eligible Resource Member entered in AFRINIC’s register of members, with the rights that come with it.

The seven questions are answered at greater length, with the documents, on Cloud Innovation’s page Lu Heng and AFRINIC.

Sources