Summary

  • In July 2025 Cloud Innovation petitioned the Supreme Court of Mauritius to wind AFRINIC up under the Court’s supervision, with its registry services carried on without interruption. The petition is before the Court, and the Court will decide it. The company sets it out on its wind-up page.
  • The company asked that Africa’s IP addresses stay with the networks that run on them and that the record pass to a successor registry: “A wind-up ends a company. It does not end the record that company keeps, and it does not touch the networks.”
  • It asked ICANN and the Number Resource Organization to designate that successor on objective criteria. It did not say which registry, and it did not ask for the role itself.

What was asked, and of whom

Two requests went to two places.

On 11 July 2025 Cloud Innovation called for an orderly wind-up of AFRINIC, and that month it petitioned the Supreme Court of Mauritius to wind the company up under the Court’s supervision, with AFRINIC’s registry services carried on without interruption. “This decision is not taken lightly,” it said.

On 14 July 2025 it wrote to the leaders of ICANN and the Number Resource Organization asking them to designate a successor registry under ICP-2, the policy under which regional registries are recognised, so that African networks keep their registry services without interruption.

The petition is before the Court. “We did not ask anyone to switch anything off,” the company says.

Elections first, then this

Cloud Innovation did not start by asking for a wind-up. It started by asking for elections.

In 2023, on its application, the Supreme Court placed AFRINIC in receivership. The judgment of 12 September 2023 appointed a receiver “for the purpose of holding the ring and ensuring that the status quo of the assets of AfriNIC Ltd is preserved and that the value of the business is maintained”, and “to see to it that the election process as per the constitution of AfriNIC Ltd be carried out so that a proper board could be constituted”. In 2024, on the company’s motion, the Court set the deadline for those elections.

The election came in June 2025, and AFRINIC’s Receiver annulled all of it. In Cloud Innovation’s words, an entire Board election was thrown out over “one disputed proxy”, “silencing hundreds of valid votes”. Its conclusion about that election is one sentence long: “If one disputed vote can cancel an election, no election is safe.”

A second election, in September 2025, was held under rules that banned the proxy voting AFRINIC’s constitution allows. Cloud Innovation does not recognise the Board it seated, and the validity of those appointments is before the Court.

The orderly way and the other way

By the summer of 2025 the warning was coming from outside as well. ICANN, no ally of Cloud Innovation, itself warned that June that AFRINIC’s ability to function as a regional internet registry was in jeopardy and that it could withdraw recognition.

A registry that loses recognition overnight, with no plan for its record, is the outcome every operator should fear. Cloud Innovation’s answer was to go to the Court before that could happen. A disorderly collapse, it said on 11 July 2025, “would be chaotic”, while a “court-managed winding-up” can be conducted “with safeguards”. “We did not wait for that,” the company says. “We chose the orderly way.”

What would happen to the addresses

Here the petition is at its plainest. “They stay with the networks that run on them,” the company says. “That is what we asked for.”

The reasoning takes three sentences, all Cloud Innovation’s. “A wind-up ends a company. It does not end the record that company keeps, and it does not touch the networks.” “An IP address is a number in a record, and a network keeps running on its numbers whoever keeps the book.” And: “What has to survive is the record the networks depend on, not the people who misused it.”

So the company asked for two things together: that AFRINIC’s registry services be carried on without interruption, and that the record pass to a registry able to keep it.

What a successor registry is

Cloud Innovation’s definition: “A registry that takes over the record when another can no longer keep it.”

Under its proposal the successor would be an established registry, chosen on objective criteria and with the support of Africa’s networks. The company did not say which. “Whoever keeps the book,” it says, “the networks and the addresses they run on stay where they are, with the people who built them.”

The idea behind it fits in a line: “A registry is a service, and a service can change hands without its customers losing what is theirs.”

Not a takeover

The obvious accusation is that a member asking for a wind-up wants the registry for itself. The record answers it twice.

First, Cloud Innovation asked that ICANN and the NRO choose the successor, on objective criteria. It did not ask for the role.

Second, it was on Cloud Innovation’s application in 2023 that the Supreme Court restrained AFRINIC “from relocating and/or subject itself to a takeover or merger, or restructuring or management control in any manner whatsoever”. “We made sure no one could move it, merge it or take it over before its members elected a Board,” the company says. “Our dispute is not with AFRINIC, which belongs to its members, but with those who control it.”

What the company wants in the end

“A registry that is only a registry.” Whoever keeps the record should keep it accurately, answer to its members and to the courts, and let a network leave with the addresses it runs on.

Lu Heng’s Note 72 says the same of any registry in four short sentences: “It may record. It may coordinate. It may protect uniqueness. It may not rule.”

“Those are the things we have gone to court for since 2021,” Cloud Innovation says, “and we ask them for every member.” What is still before the Court is listed on the company’s site.

Sources