Summary

  • CelcomDigi's "total gross synergies" of RM2,678 million is one addition: RM806 million of cumulative profit-and-loss savings plus RM1,872 million of avoided capital expenditure. On my arithmetic 69.9 per cent of the headline is a measure that never enters the income statement.
  • FY2025 statutory EBIT rose RM362 million while depreciation, amortisation and right-of-use impairment together fell RM633 million. EBIT before those three charges fell about RM271 million, so the reported profit gain is a charge-base effect — and the quarterly charge rose 24.2 per cent from the first quarter to the fourth.

The addition, printed in one sentence

The Performance Review states it without ornament: "Over the three-year integration period, the company delivered cumulative P&L savings of RM806 million and CAPEX avoidance of RM1,872 million, translating into total gross synergies of RM2,678 million as at FY2025." That sentence is the entire construction. Eight hundred and six plus one thousand eight hundred and seventy-two equals two thousand six hundred and seventy-eight, exactly (Performance Review, Integrated Annual Report 2025).

The Integrated Annual Report repeats the same three quantities in prose — RM806 million in cumulative synergy savings to date, RM1.87 billion in capital expenditure avoidance from integration efforts, RM2.68 billion in total gross synergy savings over the last three years — and, in the material read, does not perform the addition in one place (CelcomDigi Integrated Annual Report 2025). The earnings deck labels the two halves for what they are: a bar marked P&L SAVINGS, a bar marked CAPEX AVOIDANCE, and a total, with FY2025 alone contributing RM304 million and RM283 million (4Q 2025 investor presentation).

Seven tenths of the number is money not spent

Divide the halves: 1,872 over 2,678 is 69.9 per cent. My arithmetic on the company's own two figures. Of the headline the group reports as merger synergy, roughly seven tenths is capital expenditure it did not incur — and the cash numbers behind that are printed plainly. Capital expenditure fell to RM1,574 million from RM2,372 million, down 33.6 per cent, with capex intensity of 12.1 per cent against 18.7 per cent a year earlier (4Q 2025 results release).

Avoided capex is real. It is also invisible to an income statement, because it is a spend that never happens rather than a cost that stops. Its only trace in the accounts arrives later and in the opposite direction, as depreciation on the assets that were never bought. Which is why the interesting number is not the gross synergy figure but the charge lines sitting under it.

The three charge lines that did the work

The FY2025 interim report prints its own comparative column in ringgit thousands, unaudited: depreciation RM2,632,067 thousand against RM3,017,214 thousand, a fall of RM385,147 thousand; amortisation RM215,441 thousand against RM246,299 thousand, down RM30,858 thousand; impairment loss on right-of-use assets nil against RM217,200 thousand. The three together fell RM633,205 thousand, which is the same movement the presentation shows on its aggregate line, labelled depreciation, amortisation and impairment: RM2,848 million against RM3,481 million, down 18.2 per cent (4Q 2025 interim financial report).

Statutory EBIT rose RM362 million, to RM2,672 million from RM2,310 million. Put the two movements side by side and the direction inverts. EBIT before depreciation, amortisation and impairment was 2,310 plus 3,481, or 5,791; and 2,672 plus 2,848, or 5,520. A fall of about RM271 million. Using the FY2024 report's own full-year figure of RM2,328 million instead of RM2,310 million, the fall is about RM253 million. This is my arithmetic across two printed lines, not a company measure, and the group publishes neither.

The explanation is in the interim report and it is not a cost programme: "This is supported by lower depreciation, amortisation and impairment costs following the full decommissioning of Network and ROU assets that had been impaired as at December 2024." Assets retired stop being depreciated. The base year, in other words, was carrying assets that no longer existed by the end of FY2025.

Two EBITs in one deck, and the higher one barely moved

The presentation offers statutory EBIT of RM2,672 million, up 15.7 per cent, beside normalised EBIT of RM2,818 million, up 1.4 per cent from RM2,778 million. The footnote defines what normalisation removes: unusual, non-recurring and extraordinary items, in this case right-of-use impairment and the cost of a voluntary separation scheme. On the company's own non-GAAP basis the year grew 1.4 per cent. The double-digit statutory gain is chiefly the arithmetic of a RM217.2 million charge that did not recur.

The charge base turned back up inside the year

The quarterly path matters more than the annual comparison. The aggregate charge ran RM654 million, RM682 million, RM700 million and RM812 million across the four quarters of FY2025 — up RM158 million from the first to the fourth, or 24.2 per cent. Against the same quarters of FY2024 it is still far lower, because the fourth quarter of that year carried RM1,218 million.

But a charge line that rises every quarter of the year in which the synergy programme was completed is not a cost base in retreat, and the group says as much about its own fourth quarter: "EBIT declined by RM56 million, or 8.6%, due to higher depreciation and amortization charges."

What the base year was carrying

The FY2024 report explains that year's collapse in the same currency: "EBIT and PAT decreased by 57.5% and 63.4% or RM443million and RM279million respectively ... these decreases were mainly attributable to ROU impairment charges of RM217million and accelerated depreciation from the revision of the useful life of ROU asset of RM113million, following an impairment assessment of network sites." Note B14 puts the accelerated right-of-use depreciation at RM112,700 thousand, against nil in FY2023 (4Q 2024 interim financial report).

The same report's Note A4 states: "There were no material changes in estimates of amounts reported in the prior financial years that have a material effect for the financial period/year ended 31 December 2024." Both sentences sit in one document. The material read on 19 November 2026 does not explain how they fit together, and this article does not supply the reconciliation.

Where one year is printed twice

FY2024 EBIT appears as RM2,310 million in the FY2025 report's review table and in the presentation, and as RM2,328 million in the FY2024 report's full-year review. Both are printed, neither is reconciled by anything read. EBITDA is printed as RM5,475 million for FY2025 against RM5,802 million, while EBIT plus the presentation's aggregate charge gives 5,520 and 5,791 — the two subtractions do not tie, so no EBITDA figure here is derived from the lines above.

And several FY2024 cost lines in the FY2025 comparative column differ from the figures originally printed, with one retrieval returning two different values for comparative other expenses, RM1,578,576 thousand and RM1,418,040 thousand. That conflict sits inside the retrieval, so no reclassification figure is published in this piece.

The boundary, stated once

None of this alleges overstatement, misclassification or misreporting. No document read states how the RM304 million of FY2025 P&L savings is composed, which cost lines it is measured against, or whether it is gross or net of the cost of obtaining it. The audited financial statements section of the Integrated Annual Report 2025 was not opened on 19 November 2026 — the PDF returned too large for direct reading and only index-extracted text was available — so no audited-statement line, goodwill balance or purchase-price allocation figure enters this article.

The regulator's dated merger conditions were not obtained from the material read on 19 November 2026, so nothing is said here about what they require or whether they were met. Every figure above comes from a search-provider extraction of the named CelcomDigi PDF, not from a page-level read.

What BTW has already covered

A 16 October 2026 briefing read the RM381.75 million spectrum payment and the gap between an award notice and the instrument granting the rights. A 28 June 2026 company research read DiGi Telecommunications as an operating layer inside the merged group alongside the wholesale 5G model. A 2025 profile and a March 2025 payments item sit behind both. None of them reads the income statement, the depreciation path or the synergy arithmetic; that is the delta here. The company's directory entry is at https://btw.media/en/directory/celcomdigi-berhad.

What to ask for

A synergy claim that adds a balance-sheet avoidance to an income-statement saving produces a larger number than either measure alone and a figure no auditor will ever test, because there is no account in which both halves could appear. The RM806 million is the half that can be checked against expense lines. Ask for it on its own, ask which lines it was measured against, and watch the quarterly charge line rather than the annual one. On the evidence read, the half of the merger story the accounts can confirm is the smaller half — and it is being reported against a base the group has already cleared of impaired assets.