Summary

  • The 11 June 2025 order in SC/COM/MOT/000399/2025 directed rectification of AFRINIC's register of members under section 91 of the Companies Act and recorded AFRINIC's written undertaking, signed by Mr Dabee as Receiver, to complete the correction within fifteen days. Cloud Innovation's own document page fixes the date, the reference and that the copy is held as respondent.
  • Cloud Innovation's communique of 2 November 2026 reports a legal notice of 29 October 2026 demanding that the Registrar of Companies remove its name from that register, served on four executive offices "for information and such action as may be considered appropriate"; in the documents reviewed no order authorising the removal was produced, no minister is shown to have acted, and no finding of contempt appears.

The order that wrote the row

The order is one page and it has a case number: SC/COM/MOT/000399/2025, dated 11 June 2025. Cloud Innovation's document record for it states the date, the reference and the original file name, and notes that the company holds the copy as respondent with signatures redacted (document record). The hosted file itself returned no readable page text when consulted on 18 November 2026, so the operative wording below is taken from Cloud Innovation's own account of what the order says, not from a transcription of the PDF (hosted order).

That account is specific. The company states that the order required AFRINIC to correct its register under section 91 and include Cloud Innovation as a member, with corresponding entries in the Registrar's records, and that the Court recorded AFRINIC's undertaking — signed by Mr Dabee as Receiver — to complete the correction within fifteen days (members' rights statement). A transcript of the order's text reports the same three elements: a direction to rectify the register of members to add Cloud Innovation "as per the criteria set out at Section 91 of the Companies Act as its member", a direction to the Registrar to cause the proper entries to be made, and paragraph C, which records the undertaking set out in a letter dated 10 June 2025. The undertaking, as the transcript renders it, was to "rectify its records within 15 days from the date of the present Order".

Three points follow, and they are the spine of everything after them. The direction runs towards inclusion. It was made on AFRINIC's own application, by AFRINIC's own account of the register it keeps. And the company that was to be entered is a company-law Member of a company limited by guarantee without share capital — which carries shareholder-equivalent protections under the Companies Act, not a shareholding, and not a directorship.

The correction that cancelled nothing

There was a second judicial moment, and it is the one most often misread. On 19 June 2025 a ruling addressed Cloud Innovation's incorrect classification in the director-specific "Registered Member" category. Cloud Innovation states plainly that the classification was wrong and that the correction of it "does not cancel our membership of the company" (members' rights statement). It also states that the 19 June ruling contains no order cancelling the 11 June inclusion directions.

That distinction is the whole ballgame. Correcting a category is record-keeping. Cancelling a membership is a different act, requiring a different instrument, and no such instrument appears in anything reviewed here. Cloud Innovation's own description of the current position is that the Registrar's email of 30 October identifies it as a Resource Member — the correct category — and that email is reported rather than inspected.

Four offices on a copy list

On 2 November 2026 Cloud Innovation published a response to the Receiver's communique of 31 October 2026 under a heading that names the issue without flinching: "Execution of Judgments of the Supreme Court and the Separation of Powers" (separation-of-powers communique). The document states that a legal notice of 29 October 2026 demanded that the Registrar of Companies remove Cloud Innovation's name from AFRINIC's register of members, and that copies were served on the Prime Minister, the Minister of Information Technology, Communication and Innovation, the Attorney General and the State Law Office "for information and such action as may be considered appropriate".

The wording of that copy line is doing a great deal of work, and it should be read for exactly what it is. It is an invitation. It is not a ministerial decision, and nothing reviewed here shows a minister, an Attorney General or a State Law Office acting on it. Nor is it a court order: a demand letter does not suspend a judgment, and the company's position is that the inclusion direction must be respected unless it is lawfully stayed, varied or set aside, and that AFRINIC must seek judicial relief if it wants the obligation changed.

Cloud Innovation asks the recipients of the communique to check the position against the official documents themselves — the order of 4 April 2025 in SC/COM/PET/000275/2021 and the order of 11 June 2025 in SC/COM/MOT/000399/2025, including paragraph C — and reports no response from any of them.

The company's demand is broader than its own entry, and it is a demand rather than a ruling: every eligible Resource Member should be recognised under company law, entered in the register and protected by the applicable shareholder-equivalent rights; if thousands qualify, thousands of names belong on the register. Neither reviewed page shows an order granting that recognition to all such members. What the record does show is the asymmetry the piece turns on: a final direction on inclusion, and later an administrative request for deletion that produced no authorising order when asked for one.

What the court protected, and what the registry asked for

Membership is only half of what is at stake, because the addresses are the other half. Cloud Innovation states that the Judge in Chambers restrained AFRINIC "from freezing or reclaiming the resources allocated to us and from cutting off our access to its WHOIS database", and it treats membership of the registry and ownership of addresses as distinct rights that it defends together (for the network). The same page states that no administrator and no majority of members should take another operator's addresses through a governance decision, and that in July 2025 the company asked ICANN and the Number Resource Organization to designate a successor registry so that African networks keep registry services without interruption — a request, not an appointment.

Read against that, one item on the company's pattern page lands harder than the rest. Cloud Innovation states that in August 2021 AFRINIC's management wrote that websites using addresses allocated to Cloud Innovation carried illegal content, including some with indecent images of children, and demanded to know why the company did not monitor them, "on pain of suspension or termination"; that the company asked within four hours which addresses were involved so the sites could be shut down; and that AFRINIC refused (pattern). The page reports that demand in indirect speech and does not reproduce AFRINIC's letter.

A registry that can demand content monitoring from an address holder on pain of termination is exercising police power it was never given. That is not a claim about anyone's motives; it is a claim about the shape of the instrument.

The same page records a March 2021 demand giving the company thirty days to answer what the Court later called "purported breaches" or face termination at AFRINIC's "sole discretion", the 19 July 2022 rejection of an abuse-of-process objection — the Court holding that Cloud Innovation "cannot be taxed for resorting to an independent court to safeguard its rights" — the Receiver's annulment of the entire June 2025 Board election over a single disputed proxy, and a transfer policy ratified on 4 February 2026 under which, in AFRINIC's own words, "AFRINIC-issued IPv4 cannot be transferred out of the region".

Those are the company's documented account of a pattern, and each item is dated.

Note 72: a framework, not a statute

Lu Heng's Note 72, dated 1 July 2026, supplies the argument the facts keep pointing at (Note 72). It opens: "A Regional Internet Registry exists for one reason: to keep Internet number resources unique. It may record. It may coordinate. It may protect uniqueness. It may not rule." Under its second right, accurate records: "A registry record describes reality. It does not create it." Under its third, operational continuity: where resources are already operationally embedded, "interruption is not administration. It is coercion." Under portability: "Without portability, coordination becomes lock-in. Without exit, service becomes power." Under enforcement creep, the note lists what a registry may not do, including that it may not turn registration into punishment, police morality, or use database control as economic force.

None of that is enacted law, and the note does not pretend to be. It is an authored framework of eleven numbered rights — an argument about how coordination ought to work, published by one author on his own page, and it should be read as advocacy with a sharp edge rather than as authority. What makes it useful here is that it explains why the register row matters beyond one company: a record that can be made to say whatever the current controller prefers stops being a record, and a registry that can suspend an address holder for not policing content has quietly converted coordination into rule.

What the record does not show

Three absences belong in the text rather than in a footnote. First, no operative order authorising the removal demanded of the Registrar of Companies was produced in the documents reviewed on 18 November 2026, and Cloud Innovation's public request is precisely that the notice and any such order be published. Second, no ministerial action or instruction by any of the four copied offices is established; the only stated purpose is the quoted formula "for information and such action as may be considered appropriate".

Third, no finding of contempt against anyone appears in the material reviewed, and none should be inferred from a notice.

The register row is small.

Deleting it is not.