Summary

  • Two LACNIC proposals authored by Jordi Palet Martinez carry the same three APNIC figures — 7,342,080 records updated, 4,826,880 "confirmed", 2,515,200 "recovered" — and both attach them to an April 2024 update.
  • APNIC's own slide, headed "As of 31 March 2024", prints those numbers under other words: "Retained by custodians" and "Total Recycled/Reserved", the latter split into 666,112 recycled and 1,849,088 reserved pending quarantine.
  • APNIC's 2023 annual report reaches the same 7,342,080 through four more labels. Each account adds up exactly; a 97,792-address movement between the two is printed by neither document, and that arithmetic is mine.

What the two proposal pages print

The 2026 page is the tighter one to read. LACNIC's policy system lists Jordi Palet Martinez as its sole author for version 1, records a discussion window from 16 September to 11 November 2026 and a first consensus assessment running to 25 November, and notes that it did not reach consensus on 11 November; the page also says it was presented at LACNIC 46 on 21 October 2026. Its additional information reads, in full: "Data from the most recent update (April 2024), recently confirmed. As a result of the resolution and the policy, APNIC has updated the records for 7,342,080 IPv4 addresses. Of these, 4,826,880 have been confirmed, while the remaining 2,515,200 have been recovered. No legal claims have been filed because the parties claiming the resources have not provided proof of ownership." (LAC-2026-5)

The earlier proposal, LAC-2023-4, carries the same paragraph one tense apart — "were recovered" rather than "have been recovered" — and lists Palet as author of versions 1 through 4, with a presentation at LACNIC 41 on 8 May 2024 (LAC-2023-4). That page displays more than one version block, and one of them cites APNIC's executive council resolution with no figures at all, so the three numbers belong to one displayed version rather than to every draft. The page's own fields sit awkwardly together — a last-modified date of 22 June 2026 beside an "in discussion" date of 30 June 2026 and a consensus failure on 29 August — which is why nothing here treats those strings as publication dates.

What survives that care is four things a reader can hold still: 7,342,080, 4,826,880, 2,515,200, and the April 2024 stamp.

What the deck prints beside the same figures

The APNIC update deck in the ARIN 53 meeting materials has a slide headed "Historical Resource Project Outcome As of 31 March 2024". As extracted from that PDF, it reads: "Total Legacy space 7,342,080; Retained by custodians: 4,826,880 IPs; Total Recycled/Reserved : 2,515,200 IPs; Recycled: 666,112 IPs; Reserved/Pending: 1,849,088 Ips", with a parenthetical glossary: "(Recycled = available in pool Reserved = awaiting 12-month quarantine)" (APNIC update, ARIN 53). That text came out of the file as machine extraction; slide layout and typography were not inspected, so the capital in "Ips" is the extractor's, not necessarily the designer's.

Put the two side by side and the digits match while the categories do not. APNIC does not say 4,826,880 "have been confirmed"; it says they are retained by custodians. It does not say 2,515,200 "were recovered"; it says they are recycled or reserved — and those are two different conditions of an address, because the slide itself defines one as available in the pool and the other as waiting out a twelve-month quarantine. Under that split, only 666,112 of the second figure was in the pool at all. The other 1,849,088 was waiting, not gone.

That distinction has an edge for a proposal whose purpose is to condition continued registry service on formalisation. "Recovered" reads like a closed account. "Reserved/Pending" says the holder still had a claim window. Same number, opposite implication.

A second APNIC account, and where my arithmetic stops

APNIC publishes the same denominator again and splits it four ways instead. The "Historical Resource Case Outcomes" table in the 2023 annual report records 2,123 cases and 1,751,296 addresses under "Registration removed / to be removed", 181 cases and 666,112 under "Recycled", 878 cases and 4,591,104 under "Claimed by holder", and 120 cases and 333,568 under "To be finalized", for a total of 3,302 cases and 7,342,080 addresses (APNIC Annual Report 2023). The table reached this reading as extracted text with column separators inserted; cell order was reconstructed from the header and checked by arithmetic rather than by eye.

Now my sums, and only mine. The slide's two splits hold: 4,826,880 plus 2,515,200 is 7,342,080, and 666,112 plus 1,849,088 is 2,515,200. The report's four rows hold too. And between the two accounts, 97,792 addresses cross the line while the denominator never moves: the report's claimed-by-holder plus to-be-finalised, 4,924,672, exceeds the slide's retained-by-custodians by 97,792, and the slide's recycled-plus-reserved, 2,515,200, exceeds the report's removed-plus-recycled, 2,417,408, by the same 97,792. No reviewed document allocates that movement, dates it or names a cause.

The report does reconcile where it chooses to. Its narrative names 15,872 addresses routed without authority that "will be removed in 2024", and 333,568 addresses whose custodians "are yet to open an account" (same report). It is not shy about explaining. It simply never explains the 97,792.

What "most recent" had to survive

Two APNIC publications after April 2024 report the project moving again. The 2024 annual report, released on 23 February 2025, is indexed as stating that available IPv4 space "increased by 1.5 million addresses that moved out of reserved status, as the final act of the historical resource transition project", and separately that it "increased by 1,526,016 addresses (5,961 x /24s) that were reserved in 2023" (APNIC Annual Report 2024). Both lines are publisher-indexed extracts: the file exceeded the retrieval size limit and was not opened, so they are reported as indexed extracts rather than as passages read on the page. No occurrence of 7,342,080 was visible in what came back, which does not establish its absence.

The APNIC deck in the ARIN 55 materials, presented in that meeting's RIR updates session on 29 April 2025, is indexed with a slide headed "Historical Resource Transition - wrap up" and the same 1,526,016 addresses moving into the available pool (APNIC update, ARIN 55). That file returned no readable text to extraction, so it too is an indexed extract, not an inspected page.

Beside those two, a 2026 proposal describing April 2024 as "the most recent update, recently confirmed" is citing a snapshot APNIC had already moved past in its own reporting — twice, and by name, with one deck calling the work a wrap-up. I am not saying the author knew. I am saying the sentence is checkable by anyone, and it does not survive the check.

A third ledger settles what kind of number this is. APNIC's blog post of 9 October 2023 reports the APNIC 56 results as 3,705,344 addresses retained by custodians, 658,944 recycled and 2,113,536 reserved, plus roughly 200 cases representing a balance of 864,512 addresses — and prints no grand total at all (APNIC Blog, 9 October 2023). Read as full page text, that page is the cleanest evidence that this ledger is a series of dated snapshots rather than a constant: the labels persist while the values move.

The one sentence APNIC never wrote

Both proposals also state that "no legal claims have been filed because the parties claiming the resources have not provided proof of ownership." That sentence appears neither on the March 2024 slide nor in the 2023 annual report's table or the narrative beside it. It is the proposer's own drafting, and it does real work: it is the reassurance that a recovery regime has been tested and left uncontested. A reader can source the three numbers to APNIC. They cannot source that sentence to APNIC, and the proposals offer them no document that would let them.

What a reader can check, and where it stops

Three of the four things a policy argument needs are present: an exact denominator, an exact split, and two APNIC documents that each add up to it. What is missing is the fourth — a cited instrument. Both proposals describe their source only as an April 2024 update, with no document title, no venue, no table name. That omission is why the labels could drift unnoticed: there was nothing to check the words against, only the digits.

No figure reviewed here is wrong. Both APNIC accounts sum exactly to 7,342,080, and the annual report reconciles its own gaps where it states one. Nothing in these documents shows a legacy holder's service ending because of either proposal, and neither proposal reached consensus. The finding is narrower and harder to shrug off: an argument spanning two proposals and multiple versions rests on three numbers reproduced exactly and four category names replaced silently — plus a claim of no legal challenges that no reviewed registry document makes.