Summary

  • The 2024 edition prints 10,837 laporan/pengaduan masyarakat and its own components add to exactly 10,837; the 2025 launch release prints 23,596, and that figure adds up only because 9,607 consultations and 2,720 copies now sit inside the same noun (my arithmetic, on the printed components).
  • The office marks its 2022 internet-access study "Dilaksanakan Seluruhnya" — implemented in full — a status no outside document in the reviewed record verifies, while the office's own data portal names the software and a pull date but never defines what one laporan masyarakat is.

Start with the file date, because it is the only date on the document that a reader can check without opening it. The 2024 annual report sits at an address stamped 21 May 2025, and its pages tally 10,837 laporan/pengaduan masyarakat received at the head office and at provincial representatives. Underneath the total the same report lays out 9,271 Laporan Masyarakat reguler, 1,495 Respon Cepat Ombudsman and 71 Investigasi Atas Prakarsa Sendiri, and separately prints 9,975 consultations, of which 78 fall under Telekomunikasi dan Informatika (Laporan Tahunan 2024, provider-reported excerpt from search-indexed PDF text rendered 22 November 2026). My arithmetic: 9,271 + 1,495 + 71 = 10,837, exactly, with the consultations standing outside the total as their own column.

That is what a usable public count looks like. The headline, the components and the treatment of the adjacent consultation column are all visible on one page, so an outsider can disagree with the office's classification without having to guess at it.

Then the 2025 edition arrives and the noun moves. Siaran Pers No. 010/HM.01/II/2026, dated 20 February 2026, prints 23,596 laporan masyarakat across 2025 and lists its own components: 1,756 RCO, 148 IAPS, 9,365 Laporan Masyarakat Reguler, 9,607 consultations and 2,720 tembusan, the copies (launch release for the 2025 report). My arithmetic again, on those five printed parts: 1,756 + 148 + 9,365 + 9,607 + 2,720 = 23,596. It reconciles — but only if consultations and copies are pulled inside a phrase that, one edition earlier, did not contain them.

So the 2024 comparison is not 10,837 against 23,596 in the same unit. The consultation column that stood beside the total in 2024 is inside the total in 2025, and the 2,720 copies have joined it. More Indonesians may well have complained in 2025; nobody reading these two documents in sequence can say how many more, because the office did not print the sentence that would settle it.

This is not a two-edition slip. Across the four annual editions in the reviewed record, the same phrase has carried at least two different populations. The 2022 report prints 22,197 laporan masyarakat and states its composition outright: 88 own-motion investigations, 11,427 non-report consultations, 6,767 regular reports, 1,437 quick responses and 2,478 copies (Laporan Tahunan 2022). My arithmetic: those five parts sum to 22,197. So 2022 and 2025 share one convention — consultations and copies in — while 2023 and 2024 share the other, consultations out.

The 2023 edition is the awkward one, and I will not make it worse than it is. It prints 8,458 laporan masyarakat received "secara akumulatif", gives its own breakdown of 7,909 LM, 807 RCO and 66 IAPS, and states that 6,709 were closed; elsewhere the same report puts 7,392 laporan masyarakat inside 26,461 handled items (Laporan Tahunan 2023). My subtraction: 7,909 + 807 + 66 = 8,782 against a printed 8,458, a gap of 324. The reviewed text does not say which printed figure carries, so I do not assert an error. I record that a reader cannot rebuild that year's headline either, and that the gap is small enough to be a footnote and large enough to matter to anyone comparing years.

What the reviewed set never contains, in any edition, is a definition. Nothing here states what makes one laporan masyarakat, how a report touching two substances is classified, or whether a duplicate is one entry or two. The closest the office comes is its data portal, which describes substance-level counts as data drawn from SIMPeL 4, the Sistem Informasi Manajemen Penyelesaian Laporan, with an explicit pull date of 9 April 2025 for the Q1 2025 dataset (Portal Data Ombudsman RI). Naming the system and dating the extract is more provenance than most regulators publish. It is still a description of where rows come from, not of the unit in which rows are counted.

The asymmetry shows inside single pages too. The 2024 Indonesian edition prints Telekomunikasi dan Informatika at 99 in its substance table, alongside Agraria at 1,861 and Perhubungan dan Infrastruktur at 726, and prints 78 of the consultations under the same label (Laporan Tahunan 2024). The English abridged edition of the same year's report carries the identical 99 (Short Version 2024). Then the 2025 launch release gives its top five substances only — agraria 1,495, kepegawaian 1,452, hak sipil dan politik 717, kepolisian 713, perhubungan dan infrastruktur 622 — with BUMN/BUMD at 765 among the most-reported institutions, and no communications line at all (launch release). A communications caseload exists in the 2025 system, presumably; it does not exist on the page a journalist would quote.

The other years are no better for that sector. The 2023 substance chart lists Telekomunikasi dan Informatika but the label-number pairing is not readable in the extracted text, so no 2023 figure can honestly be asserted (Laporan Tahunan 2023). The 2022 report lists the same label without a readable figure (Laporan Tahunan 2022). The quarterly for the last three months of 2024 lists the classification and gives no readable count, beside a total of 2,621 reports received and 3,122 resolved in the quarter (Laporan Triwulan IV 2024). In the reviewed set, exactly one year lets a reader say how many communications complaints the office received: 2024, and 99.

There is a second asymmetry, smaller and harder to explain. The English abridged edition prints 10,837 received — matching the Indonesian edition — but resolves 10,383 where the Indonesian edition resolves 10,303 (Short Version 2024). The received figure agrees; the resolved figure does not. Whether that is a translation, a revision or an error, the reviewed text does not say. I note it because a reader assembling the year across both languages would produce a different completion number depending on which file they opened first.

Now the part that should worry an accountability institution more than any total. The 2022 annual report records, in its internet-access work, that the problem most complained about by users of the BAKTI programme was limited bandwidth and internet speed (Laporan Tahunan 2022). The office's press release on that study, No. 039/HM.01/VII/2022 dated 20 July 2022, prints four categories of potential maladministration in the programme — procedural deviation, protracted delay, abuse of authority, incompetence — and six corrective suggestions, from revising the PASTI standard operating procedure to planning additional capacity and speed (press release 039/HM.01/VII/2022). The wording is "potensi", potential, not a concluded finding, and the instrument is a press release about a study rather than the study itself.

Two years later the same office's performance report marks that telecommunications study, Layanan Program Penyediaan Akses Internet di Wilayah 3T oleh BAKTI Kementerian Komunikasi dan Informatika, with the status "Dilaksanakan Seluruhnya" — implemented in full (Laporan Kinerja Ombudsman RI). The same report prints 41 public-service policy improvement suggestions in 2024 by substance, telecommunications among them with two studies in Bali and DI Yogyakarta, and prints overall recommendation-implementation rates for 2021 to 2023 of 73.46%, 57.14% and 62.5%.

Read the status line for what it is: a statement by the recommending institution about its own recommendations. No counterparty document, no independent audit and no published verification method appears in the reviewed record. The record does contain the monitoring trail, which is why the gap is interesting rather than careless: the quarterly for April to June 2023 reports a monitoring meeting with BAKTI on 7 June 2023 at BAKTI's office in Gedung Centennial Tower, and a letter to the "Plt. Direktur Utama BAKTI" asking for documents on implementation of the recommendations, with no final completion status recorded for that quarter (Laporan Triwulan II 2023). The office was collecting implementation evidence. What the later performance report prints is the conclusion, not the evidence.

Put the two findings together and the shape of the record is the finding. An institution that exists to make other people's administration reconstructable publishes an aggregate whose population changes between editions without a printed rule, prints a sector line in one reviewed edition and not in the others, and certifies its own recommendations complete without a verified counterparty document. None of that establishes that any printed number is untrue, and nothing here suggests the totals are inflated.

It establishes something narrower and more useful: a reader cannot audit this office's own output the way this office audits everyone else's.

The remedy is unglamorous and entirely within the office's power. Print the counting rule at the first use of the noun in every edition. Keep consultations and copies either inside the total every year or outside it every year, and say which. Print the sector table in full in the launch release, not only the top five. And when a recommendation is marked implemented in full, publish the document that shows it. The office's own directory record will keep the totals; the rule is what would make them mean something.