Summary

  • Nominet's Dispute Resolution Service presumes an Abusive Registration once a complainant proves three or more prior findings against the same respondent in two years, and the Experts' own guidance adds that a finding overturned on appeal does not count — a rule that runs on the register rather than on the sentence that states it.
  • Since 7 July 2026 WIPO administers new .UK cases under a new DUK2026 series while Nominet's Decision Search Tool still returns D-series rows dated October 2026, prints 'Only the first 200 are shown here', and shows neither the deciding expert nor the Policy paragraph in a result row. The rule survived the handover intact; the join that makes it usable did not.

The rule is really a query

The .UK Dispute Resolution Service Policy is one instrument that prints its own clock: 'Version 4 – October 2016 | Applies to all disputes filed on or after 1 October 2016', with Version 3 covering filings from 29 July 2008 to 30 September 2016, Version 2 before that, and §28.2 binding the parties to the Policy current when the dispute is commenced until it concludes (DRS Policy, Version 4). A complainant must prove Rights in a name or mark identical or similar to the domain at §2.1.1 and an Abusive Registration in the respondent's hands at §2.1.2, both on the balance of probabilities under §2.2.

Then comes the clause that makes an archive load-bearing. §5.3 reads: 'There shall be a presumption of Abusive Registration if the Complainant proves that the Respondent has been found to have made an Abusive Registration in three (3) or more DRS cases in the two (2) years before the complaint was filed.'

Read it again for what it does not say. There is no phrase 'which have not been overturned'. That qualification lives in the guidance: the Experts' Overview dated December 2016 states that a decision overturned on appeal will not count against a respondent for the presumption (Experts' Overview, December 2016). The same instrument notes there is no system of precedent under the Policy, though consistency is sought, and that later decisions, especially at appeal, are more likely to reflect current thinking. §20.12 obliges the registry to publish appeal decisions while stripping them of precedent value: 'Appeal decisions will not have precedent value, but will be of persuasive value to Experts in future decisions.'

Put the two together and the operative rule is not a sentence. It is a query: return every finding against this respondent inside a two-year window, with the appeal outcome attached to each.

One printed tension first. Nominet's .UK policy index lists 'DRS Policy October 2016 (applies on or after 1st October 2016)' and, for the earlier window, both a 'DRS Policy September 2016' and a 'DRS Procedure September 2016' applying up to and including 30 September 2016 (.UK policy index) — while the surviving consolidated Policy's own version table names Version 3 as the text for filings through that same date. Two pages, one window, two names. I print both and crown neither; the substance below is unaffected either way.

What one row prints, and what it will not

On 22 November 2026 the Decision Search Tool was still live and still returning results. Sorted by decision date, it printed a row reading 'D00029230 | 13/10/2026 | PoleKat Fitness | Mr Shaun Corness | polekat.co.uk | Full Decision | Transfer' (decision search, by decision date). Another view showed 'D00029083 | 17/08/2026 | Venture Up Inc. | Venture Up | venture-up.co.uk | Full Decision | Transfer', carrying both a 'View Decision' and a 'View Appeal' link (decision search, by decision), with the appeal surfacing as its own row dated 06/10/2026 and the outcome 'Appeal: Overturned - No Action'. And the listing says what it is: '200 or more decisions were found. Only the first 200 are shown here.'

So a row carries case number, decision date, complainant, respondent, domain, decision type and outcome. It carries no deciding expert and no Policy paragraph. Both of those fields exist in the interface — the search page offers full text, domain name, case number, respondent, complainant and expert (DRS decision search) — so anyone claiming you cannot search by respondent has not looked at the form. The gap is elsewhere, and it is narrower and worse: no reviewed page answers the query §5.3 depends on, because that query needs two case series and an appeal status that is published as a separate row rather than as a field.

Two publishers, two numbering systems

Nominet's own service update sets the date: from 7 July 2026 administration of DRS cases transfers to WIPO, the World Intellectual Property Organization (DRS service update). The list of what stays is long and material — the DRS Policy including the types of disputes that can be raised, mediation facilitated by Nominet, the composition of the Experts panel, decision review by the review group inside that panel, the availability of appeals, registrar engagement, and enforcement of decisions. The list of what changes is short: cases raised and managed in WIPO's system, WIPO case managers, and all decisions, existing and new, searchable on WIPO's website.

Then the sentence that does the damage to any reader trying to plan: 'Eventually, all decisions will also be available on nominet.uk and the Decision Search Tool will be retired.' No date for the archive. No date for the retirement.

WIPO's notice of 2 June 2026 confirms the mechanics and adds its own promise: submissions via WIPO from 7 July 2026, cases filed earlier staying with Nominet until completion, and 'The full searchable archive of historic DRS decisions will remain online' (WIPO notice, 2 June 2026). WIPO's .UK page repeats the split — pre-7-July disputes administered by Nominet through the entire proceeding — and carries a Decisions heading whose entries were not visible in the text retrieved (WIPO .UK page).

Both series exist in fact, not just in promise. A WIPO-hosted PDF headed 'DISPUTE RESOLUTION SERVICE DECISION The Vesey Partnership Limited v. Safa Hussain Case No. DUK2026-0023' records Nominet UK as the registry of the disputed domain, orders transfer of searchpoint.uk, and is dated 31 October 2026 (DUK2026-0023). A second, 'SUMMARY DECISION', names Apple Inc. v. Mohammed Siddike, Case No. DUK2026-0143, concerns icloudltd.co.uk, orders cancellation, and is dated 6 November 2026 (DUK2026-0143). Nominet's register, on the same day I looked, was still serving D-series decisions dated 13 October 2026. Fifteen weeks after the handover, one regime is publishing its reasons in two places under two numbering systems.

What the full document carries that the row does not

Everything the presumption needs, in principle. D00029204 names Especial Ltd and Behrendt Professional Corporation, the domains especial.co.uk and especial.uk, cites §§2.1.1 and 2.1.2, rejects the complaint, finds reverse domain name hijacking, and closes 'Dated 16 June 2026 Matthew Harris' (D00029204). D00007146 finds Rights and Abusive Registration on the balance of probabilities, directs transfer of arneg.co.uk, and records 'Signed: Andrew Clinton Dated: 22 September 2009' (D00007146). D00021793 reproduces §§2.1.1 and 2.1.2 and applies §5.1.1 in its reasoning (D00021793). The review step is described in the open: Nominet's Experts page states that each fully reasoned decision is reviewed by a member of the Expert Review Group before publication, and that Expert Review Group members form the panel that hears appeals (DRS Experts list). What that review concluded is not printed on the row, and no reviewed page prints it beside the decision. BAILII's DRS index goes further and shows the join working: an appeal for case D00020412 listed as 'Appeal: Upheld - No Action' dated 14 January 2019 beside the first-instance entry 'Full Decision _No Action' dated 08 October 2018 (BAILII DRS index). Appeals are keyed by case number. That is exactly the pair of keys §5.3 needs.

The boundary belongs beside that claim, not in a footnote. None of those full texts is a Nominet-originated document. The D00029204 copy is hosted by Domain Name Wire; D00007146 and D00021793 are BAILII mirrors; the DUK files sit on WIPO's CDN. The 'View Decision' targets behind Nominet's own rows were not obtained in this review, and nominet.uk's domain-disputes hub returned HTTP 403. So the finding is precise and limited: full decision documents do carry parties, domain, date, expert and the paragraphs applied — established from copies, not from the originating publisher.

The count surface closes, and one sum does not

Nominet's release of 4 February 2025 reports 608 complaints resolved in 2024, 276 of them ending in transfer, a 45% transfer rate, an estimated £8,150,000 saved in court costs and legal fees, complainants from 30 countries and respondents from 44, and 506 .co.uk, 73 .uk and 27 .org.uk among the disputed domains (2024 DRS release). The same release states a change of method: cases are now counted in the year they are closed, which 'slightly increased numbers against historical data'.

Two sums of mine, kept apart from theirs. First, the headline ratio rebuilds: 276 of 608 is 45.4%, consistent with the printed 45%. Second, the suffix breakdown does not close: 506 + 73 + 27 = 606, two short of 608. The release counts disputed domain names in that sentence and complaints in the other, does not declare the suffix list exhaustive, and I stop where the document stops. No cause named, no ratio computed across the two units.

And the series that would let anyone watch a transition is not a series: the reports index lists annual DRS infographics for 2024, 2023, 2021, 2019, 2018, 2017, 2016, 2015, 2014 and 2013 (reports and statistics index). Ten years out of twelve.

What a respondent can still do, and who pays for it

Standing behind §5.3 today means doing the work the two publishers have not published. Search the Nominet series by respondent. Search WIPO's series by respondent. Open each candidate document to find the paragraph the expert applied, because the row will not tell you. Then hunt the appeal row that may or may not exist in either series, because the presumption discounts findings that were overturned and no field marks them. The browse listing stops at the first 200 results, and nothing I reviewed certifies that either series is complete for the period after 7 July 2026.

That is the shape of the finding. Nominet did not weaken its own rule, and the handover is not illegitimate for being split — the Policy, the panellists, the review, the appeals, the fees and the enforcement all survived the move. What did not survive is a reader's ability to join them in one place. The cost of that move has been transferred to the people who must recompute a presumption: respondents facing a third strike, and the counsel who advise them.

The fix is small and entirely within either publisher's gift. A retirement date. A statement that a named series is complete. An appeal status carried in the result row instead of a separate entry. A respondent-level export. Any one of those turns two registers back into one record. Until then, a rule written to be automatic operates only for those who can afford to read both archives by hand.