Summary

  • 47 U.S.C. 34 requires a written licence to land or operate a submarine cable in the United States and describes it as issued by the President. Executive Order 10530, Sec. 5(a), moves that function to the Federal Communications Commission "without the approval, ratification, or other action of the President", and forbids any grant or revocation until the Secretary of State has approved.
  • The licensee test is written around the shore end. 47 CFR 1.767(h) reaches any entity that "owns or controls" a US cable landing station; the current Subpart FF text at 1.70003(a) reaches any entity that "controls" one, keeping the five-percent limb in identical words.
  • The Commission has said in terms that "distribution of a cable's capacity among providers is not required to be reported under our current submarine cable licensing rules". The licensing record answers a question about a building and a hand on it, not about throughput or who bought it.

Start with the sentence the whole apparatus rests on. "No person shall land or operate in the United States any submarine cable directly or indirectly connecting the United States with any foreign country, or connecting one portion of the United States with any other portion thereof, unless a written license to land or operate such cable has been issued by the President of the United States" (47 U.S.C. 34). One sentence, one condition, one addressee. Whatever the Commission has done since 1954, the statute has not moved its own pen.

What moved is the hand. Executive Order 10530, dated 10 May 1954, does not merely hand a chore across town; it removes the President from the transaction and then locks the door behind him (Executive Order 10530, Sec. 5(a)):

The Federal Communications Commission is hereby designated and empowered to exercise, without the approval, ratification, or other action of the President, all authority vested in the President by the act of May 27, 1921, ch. 12, 42 Stat. 8 (47 U.S.C. 34 to 39, inclusive), including the authority to issue, withhold, or revoke licenses to land or operate submarine cables in the United States: Provided, That no such license shall be granted or revoked by the Commission except after obtaining approval of the Secretary of State and such advice from any executive department or establishment of the Government as the Commission may deem necessary.

The Commission is authorized and directed to receive all applications for the said licenses.

Read that as a control surface rather than as a chain of command, because it is not one hand. The Commission issues, withholds and revokes. It does so without asking the President, and the order says so three ways — approval, ratification, other action — as if anticipating an argument. And then the same sentence refuses it the last move: no grant, no revocation, not until the Secretary of State approves. One agency decides; another must consent before the decision takes effect. A licensee who wants to know who can take the licence away is looking at two buildings, not one.

The Office of the Federal Register's codification of the order carries no supersession note on Part IV, though the absence of a note is not a search of later amendments.

The codified rule restates the condition and changes a word doing it. "Cable landing licenses shall be granted or revoked by the Commission after obtaining the approval of the Secretary of State and such assistance from any executive department or establishment of the Government as the Commission may deem necessary," (47 CFR 1.70002(d)), citing the order by date. The order says the Commission may take such advice; the rule says such assistance. Both sentences impose the identical State approval, so the swap sits in the second, softer limb. I report it as each text prints it: no drafting history was read, the difference is not characterised as an error, and its legal significance is not established here.

Now the question that actually decides who is regulated. Two texts sit side by side and disagree by two words (47 CFR 1.767(h), corroborated on the government-hosted point-in-time text):

Except as otherwise required by the Commission, the following entities, at a minimum, shall be applicants for, and licensees on, a cable landing license: (1) Any entity that owns or controls a cable landing station in the United States; and (2) All other entities owning or controlling a five percent (5%) or greater interest in the cable system and using the U.S. points of the cable system.

The current Subpart FF text states the same population with the first limb narrowed: "(a) Any entity that controls a cable landing station in the United States; and (b) All other entities owning or controlling a five percent (5%) or greater interest in the cable system and using the U.S. points of the cable system" (47 CFR Part 1, Subpart FF). The second limb is word for word identical. Only the first changed: owns or controls became controls. The amending instruction that produced the change was not read, and no effective date is asserted here beyond the subpart's own source note, so treat the direction of travel as printed and the reasoning as unestablished.

That single edit is the article. Under the older wording, an owner of a landing station who controlled nothing operational was still inside the licensee set. Under the current text, the obligation tracks control of the building where the cable comes ashore. Not the wet plant. Not the segment shares. Not the capacity. A supplier that manufactures and lays cable is not a licensee for having built it; a fund that owns a share of the system is not a licensee unless it also controls the landing station or holds the five-percent interest and uses the US points.

Accountability has been attached to a physical place and to the hand on it, which is a far more inspectable test than ownership — and a far narrower one.

Now the second separation, which is why no licence file will ever answer a capacity question. The routine conditions require that "the licensee shall file annual international circuit capacity reports as required by § 43.82 of this chapter" — a cross-reference, not a standalone duty (47 CFR 1.767(g)(13)). And the Commission has said plainly what that cross-reference is not. "Although the Commission obtains the ownership and location of individual cables through the licensing process, distribution of a cable's capacity among providers is not required to be reported under our current submarine cable licensing rules and is provided only annually through the Circuit Capacity Reports. Further, the Commission's licensing rules do not require an applicant to include the entities that have acquired capacity on the cable through an Indefeasible Right of Use (IRU) or Inter-Carrier Lease (ICL)" (FCC 17-136).

Put the two halves together and the shape of the record appears. The licensing process collects the ownership and location of individual cables. It does not collect who holds the capacity, who bought an indefeasible right of use, or who sits behind an inter-carrier lease. So the licence is not a capacity roster, and a name's absence from a licence is not evidence about its traffic, its customers or its share of anything.

Anyone reading a landing licence to find out who holds capacity is holding the wrong document, and the Commission said as much in 2017 — though § 43.82 as it stands today and the current Filing Manual were not read here, so the separation is asserted of the licensing rules as that order and the retrieved provisions describe them.

Which brings us to the name on the directory card. On 18 November 2026 the only retained federal document naming STC Submarine Systems, Inc. is a 1993 order in the Columbus II proceeding, and it places the company at the table as a commenter, not on the licence: "STC Submarine Systems, Inc. (STC) filed comments requesting the Commission to condition the requested Section 214 authorization and accompanying cable landing license on the Joint Applicants' competitive procurement of equipment and services for COLUMBUS II. ... IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that STC's request to condition the Section 214 authorization of COLUMBUS II is hereby denied" (Columbus II, DA 93-910). The ellipsis is in the retained excerpt, not inserted by me.

That is the posture of a supplier asking the state to open someone else's procurement, and being told no. It is not the posture of an applicant, a joint applicant or a co-licensee. What I did not obtain, and am naming precisely: no pre-2016 licence file, IBFS or ICFS docket, public notice series or grant list was searched, so no statement is made here about how many licences exist or which of them touch any landing station. The Columbus II landing-licence grant itself was a companion order that I did not read, and its number appears only in a provider summary rather than in a returned sentence, so it is named nowhere above.

The 1993 text is a third-party reproduction of the FCC/Westlaw record with OCR artefacts and elided paragraphs, and the official 8 FCC Rcd 5263 volume was not opened.

Three earlier articles of mine read registers around this name: a UK company number keeping STC SUBMARINE SYSTEMS LIMITED as a former name, a US number registry keeping STC Submarine Systems, Inc. under a handle, and a Portland pier whose cable works were judged infeasible while its lease moved to a metals distributor and a federal directory went on naming the pier for another decade. All three read naming registries. None read the instrument that grants permission to land a cable. That gap is the reason this article exists, and it does not close by assertion: a name that persists in registries of names is not thereby on a licence, and a licence is not a registry. The directory record holds the name and the prior reporting; the permission documents, read on 18 November 2026, hold something else — a company asking for a condition on someone else's grant.

The interval between the order and this dateline is my own restatement of two printed dates, not a finding in any document: 10 May 1954 to 18 November 2026 is 72 years, 6 months and 8 days. The delegation sentence has been doing its work for that long without a Presidential signature, and the State approval has sat inside it the whole time.

What the record read here does not establish, dated to this reading: the 1.767 text consulted is a point-in-time version dated 4 December 2025, its current-version address returned an access-block page, and paragraphs (d)–(f) and (i)–(l) were elided by the retrieval provider, so the absence of any other disclosure duty is an argument from silence inside a partly visible set. Subpart FF and 1.70002 were read through a search index after the eCFR addresses returned a block page, and paragraph numbering may have moved after the 2026 amendments recorded in the subpart note.

47 U.S.C. 34 is a Cornell reproduction; the official US Code was not inspected, and the section's second sentence — exempting cables lying wholly within the continental United States — is known here only from a retained summary, not from a returned sentence. A Commission compilation page returned HTTP 403 and a current grant public notice yielded no extractable text; nothing is quoted from either and nothing is said about what such a notice contains. No licence application, grant, condition, transfer of control, revocation or renewal was read for any system in any year.

And nothing here describes STC's corporate status, revenue, customers, traffic, equipment or intent beyond the 1993 commenting posture.

The licence, then, is a document about a place and a permission. It names the President in the statute, the Commission in practice, the Secretary of State in the condition, and the controller of the landing station in the rule. It does not name the cable's capacity, who bought it, or what it carries. If you want to know who is accountable at the shore, read the licence. If you want to know who holds the capacity, the licence will not tell you, and it was never built to.