AFRINIC · RIR Watchdog
Story
BTW reporting and context linked to this RIR. For the proposal-by-proposal history, the people involved and their changing positions, start with Policy.
Story
Latest stories
1,184Stories
Story
Five routes to one duty: AFRINIC’s 2022 Appeal Committee and the meaning of an independent seat
AFRINIC filled five Appeal Committee seats through five prescribed experience channels in April 2022. That architecture promised continuity and informed review, yet its real test lay elsewhere: whether each route ended in a person exercising independent judgment, rather than in…
Story
When the Ledger Opens the Ballot: AFRINIC’s 2022 Good-Standing Gate
On 3 June 2022, a quiet administrative output sat between an AFRINIC Resource Member and an internal vote: good standing. That output condensed contracts, membership formalities, fee dates, account age, contact authority and portal status into a practical yes or no. The…
Story
The rulebook under load: AFRINIC’s Draft 3 and the limits of private consensus
On 18 May 2022, a seventeen-page proposal sought to rebuild the procedure through which AFRINIC made policy, just as the registry was approaching a public meeting and facing a documented risk to ordinary Board quorum. The design promised firmer clocks, earlier evidence and…
Story
Three seats, five for quorum: AFRINIC’s succession circuit breaker
On 28 April 2022, AFRINIC’s Governance Committee offered a strikingly simple answer to a complicated succession problem: never open more than three Board seats at one Annual General Members’ Meeting. Its schedule placed Seats 1, 2 and 7 in 2022, Seats 3, 4 and 8 in 2023, and…
Story
The line an election cannot cross: AFRINIC’s three-year term boundary
In April 2022, AFRINIC’s Governance Committee confronted a deceptively simple succession problem: a temporary appointee could be required to leave at the next annual general members’ meeting, yet the director then elected would ordinarily receive a full three-year term inside a…
Story
The $15,000 constitutional maintenance question
AFRINIC authorised no more than US$15,000 for a requested two-day Governance Committee working session in Kenya on 23–24 April 2022, with one stated assignment: address the election-sequence problem already recorded in Resolution 202202.677. That modest-looking budget line offers…
Story
Who Could Select, Not Who Could Stand: AFRINIC’s 2022 Regional NomCom Rule
Northern and Western Africans were not barred from AFRINIC’s planned 2022 Board election. Residents of those two regions were required for the corresponding regional candidacies, but they were ineligible to sit on the four-person Nomination Committee that filtered nominations…
Story
The Confidential File and the Missing Receipt
On 9 March 2022, with a director’s personal deadline due to expire the following day, AFRINIC’s Board authorised the company to cover directors’ defence costs and opened an NDA-bounded channel between its Legal Department and their lawyers. The urgent protection can be justified…
Story
AFRINIC says outside sponsors funded 39 travel records in a no-budget year. Twenty-two name NRO
AFRINIC's newly published 2023 finance summary says it used none of its own funds for outreach or travel because no budget had been approved. Yet its travel register lists 39 third-party-sponsored records—37 for staff and two for others—and 22 sponsor fields mention NRO. The…
Story
The Trip That Turned a Board Into a Routing Queue
AFRINIC’s directors spent part of February 2022 deciding whether their chief executive could attend a two-day meeting. Their response on 2 March was to replace one approval gate with notification—but only for official international engagements already inside a Board-approved…
Story
The Application Ended; the Transfer-Policy Question Did Not
A one-page order from the Supreme Court of Mauritius records two letters received on the same day and one spare procedural act: the present application was set aside with costs. Its brevity is not an invitation to supply the missing story. It is the central institutional fact.…
Story
The Appeal That a Later Order Made Academic
Cloud Innovation’s appeal did not become useless because the Supreme Court of Mauritius endorsed the decision under challenge. It became useless because a newer, wider interim order was already doing the practical protective work the appeal sought to recover—a distinction that…
Story
When AFRINIC’s election rules reached the same date
On 2 March 2022, AFRINIC’s Board put an unusually precise institutional problem on the record: two seats filled after casual vacancies were due to return to election at the next annual meeting, yet giving their successors the ordinary three-year tenure would break the regional…
Story
The Consequential Verb Was Publish: AFRINIC’s Resolution 202201.673 and the Limits of an AS0 Mandate
In January 2022, AFRINIC’s Board ratified a policy that asked the registry to do something concrete with its own cryptographic machinery: identify IPv4 and IPv6 inventory recorded as unallocated or unassigned, create covering AS0 Route Origin Authorisations, and publish the…
Story
A Complete Ballot Cannot Repair the Wrong Seats
AFRINIC’s 2022 election rulebook answered almost every practical question about how a vote should run. The unresolved question was more fundamental: whether the seats placed into that machinery, and the terms attached to their winners, preserved a lawful and workable succession.…
Story
The Year Added Before the Rule Was Repaired
AFRINIC’s Board made Seat 6’s calendar add up by extending its incumbent for a year. The arithmetic was simple; the allocation of power was not. Resolution 202202.676 shows why a private institution should repair the rule before personalising the remedy—or make any temporary…
Story
The Judgment That Stopped Before the Merits
The Supreme Court of Mauritius Court of Civil Appeal said it did not propose to deal with the merits of the remaining grounds of appeal. That sentence is the boundary of *Cloud Innovation Ltd v African Network Information Centre (AFRINIC) Ltd*, 2022 SCJ 51—and the part…
Story
Eight applications in one annex: How to read a procedural map without inventing eight judgments
In 2022 SCJ 51, the Supreme Court of Mauritius placed eight related injunction applications into a single annex. That compact record shows why a filing count can reveal genuine procedural pressure while still saying almost nothing, by itself, about how many underlying rights were…
Story
The Succession Clock That Had to Beat the Quorum Line
AFRINIC’s January 2022 reconstitution of its Audit Committee shows why institutional continuity is decided by sequence, not by the mere existence of a replacement rule: the appointing Board must use its ordinary authority before vacancies make that authority unavailable.
Story
The Promise Behind AFRINIC’s Open-Ended Defence
At an urgent online meeting, AFRINIC’s directors had to consider a motion that named directors individually—and then decide whether the company would carry every legal cost arising from their defence. The protection could preserve independent judgment in a moment of personal…