Summary

  • In the dispute over the AFRINIC election of September 2025, members have sworn to the Supreme Court of Mauritius that their names appear on the official voters’ register although they never registered and never voted.
  • AFRINIC announced eight names and no vote count, then called the turnout “unprecedentedly high”. A commentator who welcomed the result put participation at slightly over 500 of 2430 members.
  • The rerun was held under rules AFRINIC’s Receiver wrote himself, banning the proxy voting AFRINIC’s constitution allows. The Court has not yet ruled on whether the Board was validly appointed.

What have AFRINIC members sworn about the 2025 election?

AFRINIC members have sworn affidavits stating that their names appear on the official voters’ register of the September 2025 Board election although they did not register to vote and did not vote. One member states that it did not vote in that election and authorised no proxy and no third party to vote on its behalf.

The affidavits are before the Supreme Court of Mauritius, in the very case in which AFRINIC and its Receiver ask the Court to declare the September 2025 appointments valid. As filed, they are backed by evidence that includes emails and recordings of telephone calls.

The official record and what these members confirm about themselves do not match. Who put those names on the register? And was any vote cast in their names?

Which court case is this, and where does it stand?

The case is SC/COM/MOT/000757/2025 before the Supreme Court of Mauritius, and it has been heard: judgment is awaited. In it, AFRINIC’s Receiver and AFRINIC apply for the Receiver’s discharge, for an end to the receivership and for a declaration that the candidates of September 2025 were validly appointed.

AFRINIC’s own member update of 12 March 2026 said that “the receiver’s application for discharge has been heard, and judgment is now awaited.”

Cloud Innovation opposes the application. Its case is that the Receiver’s departures from AFRINIC’s constitution exceeded his mandate, breached the Court’s orders and failed to produce valid appointments. Cloud Innovation does not recognise this Board as lawfully constituted. As it puts it: “An application for validation is not an order granting it.”

We have reported on what the Court asked of AFRINIC’s Receiver, and what he did.

What do the AFRINIC election results of 2025 actually show?

Eight names and no numbers. AFRINIC’s announcement of 15 September 2025 says the results “have been announced by the Chair of the 2025 Nomination Committee” and lists one name for each of the eight seats. It gives no vote count, no turnout and no percentage. AFRINIC has published no count or turnout since.

Six months later, AFRINIC’s member update of 12 March 2026 spoke of “the successful and unprecedentedly high member turnout at the Board elections in September 2025”. It did not say how high.

The only figure on the public record comes from a commentator who welcomed the result. Writing on CircleID on 12 September 2025, the commentator reported that “out of a total of 2430 members, slightly over 500 participated in the process”. That is about one member in five.

For one seat there was no vote at all. AFRINIC’s communiqué of 10 September 2025 said that “there will be no election for Board Seat 1 (Northern Africa region), as only one suitable candidate has been retained”.

The eight seats are set out in our report on AFRINIC’s Board and an election still in court.

Who drew up the AFRINIC voter register, and under what rules?

AFRINIC’s Receiver, under election rules he wrote himself. For the rerun, those rules banned proxies and powers of attorney and allowed online voting only. Article 12.12 of AFRINIC’s constitution says a member votes “either by e-voting, by being present in person or by proxy”. The Receiver took the third of those three ways away.

The vote the rerun replaced, in June 2025, had been annulled by the Receiver over, in Cloud Innovation’s words, “one disputed proxy”, “silencing hundreds of valid votes”.

On Cloud Innovation’s information, more than 2,000 resource members, the networks that are supposed to elect the Board, have been left off the register.

So the same register leaves eligible networks off, by Cloud Innovation’s account, and lists members who say they never registered, by their own sworn account.

That register did not stay in 2025. AFRINIC’s 2026 elections took as their starting point the list of voters drawn up for the rerun, as Cloud Innovation’s page on the election shows from AFRINIC’s own election guidelines.

What has NRS said about the AFRINIC voter register?

The Number Resource Society (NRS) has told members what to do if this happens to them. On 15 December 2025, in “Protect your vote”, NRS wrote: “A vote recorded in your name should reflect your participation.” It asked: “If you find your name on the voter register but did not register or vote, or if you observe any election irregularities, please contact NRS”.

On 13 March 2026, in a notice to members, NRS said: “NRS has gathered evidence indicating that some members whose names appear in the voter register have stated that they did not vote at all.” It added: “If individuals appear in the official voting record while denying participation, the integrity of the election process must be examined carefully.”

Its request still stands: a member whose name is on the register but who did not register or vote can say so.

What has AFRINIC still not answered?

AFRINIC’s own record leaves these questions open:

  • Who entered on the register the names of members who say they never registered?
  • Was any vote cast in their names, and if so, by whom?
  • How many members voted, seat by seat, and why has AFRINIC never published the count it calls “unprecedentedly high”?
  • How many eligible resource members were left off the register?

An organisation that boasts of record turnout should be able to answer all four on a single page.

What happens next in the AFRINIC election case?

The Supreme Court’s judgment in SC/COM/MOT/000757/2025 is awaited, and the affidavits are before it. Until the Court rules, the September 2025 result is not settled. An application for validation is not an order granting it.

Who chose this Board is a wider question, examined in AFRINIC and Smart Africa: who chose the Board.

A fair election is one held under the constitution as it is written: the proxy voting Article 12.12 allows, every eligible resource member on the register and able to vote, and no organiser who sets aside the rules that bind him. And an election whose count is never published cannot be checked by the members who elect. The full record, and Cloud Innovation’s case against the Receiver’s rerun, is on its page on the AFRINIC election.

Sources