Summary
- Chorus's 2025 information disclosure prints $863,160,000 of FFLAS revenue against $939,489,000 of actual allowable revenue — a difference of $76,329,000, or 8.12 per cent of what the determination allowed for the year, carried forward as a wash-up.
- The market announcement for the same disclosure year describes the shortfall as $101 million, roughly $24.7 million more, and no document read on 19 November 2026 defines the comparison base that produces it.
The most useful number in Chorus's 2025 information disclosure is a subtraction. Total FFLAS revenue of $863,160,000, taken away from actual allowable revenue of $939,489,000, leaves $76,329,000 — and that residue is exactly the wash-up accrual the company reports on the same schedules (Chorus AID 2025, Schedules 1-13). The arithmetic foots to the dollar. Whatever else is uncertain about New Zealand's fibre regime, the company's own subtraction is not.
The figure is not small in the context of the year it describes. Against the revenue the determination permitted, the gap is 8.12 per cent. Chorus, in other words, billed roughly 92 per cent of what it was allowed to recover from the regulated fibre business in 2025, and carried the rest forward rather than collecting it.
A cap on revenue, not a price on fibre
The instrument behind that number is easy to misread, and the misreading is worth naming. The Fibre Price-Quality Path Determination 2024, dated 13 December 2024 and numbered [2024] NZCC 34, provides that the maximum revenue Chorus may recover in any regulatory year is the forecast allowable revenue for that year, and fixes the second regulatory period at 1 January 2025 to 31 December 2028 (NZLII reproduction of [2024] NZCC 34). That is a ceiling on a total, not a price list for a line.
The Commerce Commission's reasons paper for the same path prints the totals it built: $3,492.2 million of forecast allowable revenue across the four years in present-value terms, or $4,078.3 million nominal, made up of $3,254.9 million of building-block revenue, $70.3 million of pass-through costs and a $167.1 million present-value wash-up (PQP2 final decision reasons paper). The same paper sets the annual nominal path at $956.9 million for 2025, $1,001.0 million for 2026, $1,040.8 million for 2027 and $1,079.7 million for 2028, with a vanilla WACC of 7.68 per cent, a post-tax WACC of 7.17 per cent, base capex of $847.7 million, connection capex of $174.1 million and base opex of $700.4 million in real terms.
Run the annual figures against each other and the path still rises every year of the period, but at a decelerating rate: 4.61 per cent into 2026, 3.98 per cent into 2027, 3.74 per cent into 2028. A revenue cap with a flattening slope is a very different object from a price that gets cut.
The true-up is a deferral, not a write-off
Because the cap is aggregate and the years are smoothed, the difference between what was allowed and what was billed does not vanish. It becomes a balance. The determination fixes a nominal smoothed building-block revenue figure of $870,228,000 at the start of regulatory year 2025 and wash-up amounts of $45,762,000 for 2025, $47,882,000 for 2026, $49,798,000 for 2027 and $51,669,000 for 2028 (NZLII reproduction of [2024] NZCC 34). Those four smoothed amounts sum to $195,111,000 nominal. The reasons paper's $167.1 million wash-up is a present-value figure. The two totals rest on different bases and are not netted here; the point is simply that even the scheduled recovery is front-loaded in the record before a single year of actual billing is known.
What happens to the deferred balance is a question about the next period, not this one. The Commission's June 2026 decision sets Chorus's third regulatory period at five years, from 1 January 2029 to 31 December 2033 — a longer runway than the four years of the second path (Commission, 30 June 2026). The wash-up does not disappear at the boundary. The explanatory notes say as much: the rolled-forward PQ RAB becomes the opening RAB for the third period, subject to wash-ups (Chorus AID 2025, Schedule 14).
Two numbers for one year
Now the discrepancy that gives this brief its title. Chorus's market announcement accompanying the 2025 disclosure states that 2025 revenues were $101 million below its maximum allowable revenue, and that a wash-up balance of $76.3 million will be carried forward to the third period (NZX announcement, 29 May 2026). One sentence, two numbers, about $24.7 million apart.
The $76.3 million matches the schedules exactly. The $101 million does not follow from them. Take disclosed FFLAS revenue and add the announced shortfall: $863,160,000 plus $101,000,000 gives an implied comparison base of $964,160,000, against the $939,489,000 of actual allowable revenue in the disclosure — a difference of about $24.67 million. No document read on 19 November 2026 identifies that base, defines it, or reconciles the two measures. Both figures are printed. Each is attributed to its own document. Neither is described anywhere in the material read as wrong.
The announcement also states that all of Chorus's calculations are subject to Commerce Commission review (NZX announcement, 29 May 2026). That status applies to the schedules too: the information disclosure is company-calculated regulatory reporting, and no Commission review outcome for disclosure year 2025 appears in the material read.
The asset base is not the capex
The regulated asset base is where a revenue-cap regime hides its compounding, and Chorus's numbers show it cleanly. The Commission valued the initial RAB at $5.413 billion as at 1 January 2022, $12 million below the transitional value in its December 2021 decisions, with that difference to be washed up when the next path was set (Commission, 6 October 2022). The components as determined were unallocated core fibre of $4,596 million, core fibre in the price-quality RAB of $3,997 million, a financial loss asset of $1,416 million in both the price-quality and information-disclosure RABs, total fibre assets in the price-quality RAB of $5,413 million, information-disclosure-only core fibre of $24 million, an information-disclosure RAB of $5,437 million, and opening tax losses for disclosure year 2022 of minus $1,052 million (NZCC 33).
By the end of 2025 the disclosure reports an opening price-quality RAB of $5,913,119,000 and a closing price-quality RAB of $6,003,748,000 before the asset allocation adjustment, with price-quality operating revenue of $856,605,000 (Chorus AID 2025, Schedules 1-13). The notes round that close to $6,004 million and roll it forward as a $91 million increase: a $183 million revaluation, $343 million of commissioned assets, a $464 million depreciation deduction and a $30 million asset allocator adjustment (Chorus AID 2025, Schedule 14).
Read the direction of those components. Revaluation alone added roughly twice the net increase in the asset base. Commissioning added $343 million; depreciation deducted $464 million. The base grew while its physical content was being consumed faster than it was replaced in value terms, and the revaluation is what carried the number up. The notes put the actual CPI at 3.11 per cent against a forecast of 2.45 per cent — the indexation did the work that new construction did not. The announcement frames the same movement as the asset base rising from $5.9 billion in 2024 to approximately $6.0 billion, with core RAB at $5.1 billion, up $0.2 billion, and the financial loss asset reduced to $0.9 billion (NZX announcement, 29 May 2026).
What the newest rule actually governs
The Commission's Tranche 1 final decision of 25 August 2026 is the newest rule in this regime, and it is narrower than the headlines suggest. It introduces a defined investment test for network expansion capital expenditure above specified thresholds, requiring Chorus to demonstrate that a proposed expansion generates a positive net benefit for end-users of the regulated fibre services, and states that the test does not replace the existing capex approval framework but gives a structured analytical approach within it (Commission, Tranche 1 final decision).
Network expansion capex, as defined there, means capex to expand the network to a geographic area in which Chorus does not currently provide regulated fibre services and to connect end-users in that area — expressly excluding infill development and development adjacent to the existing communal fibre network. The threshold is $15 million for applying the test through the individual capex proposal mechanism and $5 million in aggregate for the base capex and connection capex mechanisms.
The test applies a 5 per cent pre-tax real discount rate to net present value calculations, allows Chorus to propose alternatives supported by evidence, and requires sensitivity analysis on the discount rate, uptake, willingness to pay and portfolio mix, plus forecasts of payback period, cost to connect, cost per premises passed and pricing implications.
The draft decision of 17 March 2026 had proposed raising the individual proposal threshold to at least $30 million; the final settled at half that. The whole instrument, in other words, governs the ground Chorus is not already on. It says nothing about the revenue cap on the footprint that already exists, and its threshold is set at an amount that fits inside the capex allowance the second path already carries.
Where the demand side actually sits
The regulated numbers describe a business whose customers are migrating and whose prices are under consultation. Chorus's audited annual report for the year ended 30 June 2026 reports operating revenue of $1,029 million, up $15 million, with 6 per cent growth in fibre revenues more than offsetting the decline in legacy services; fibre ARPU rising from $58.28 to $59.51; fibre connections growing by about 32,000 to 1,147,000, now 96 per cent of total connections; and total fixed-line connections falling to about 1,191,000 from 1,207,000 (Chorus FY26 annual report). Disclosed ARPU rose 2.11 per cent while connections rose by roughly 32,000, which tells you the fibre revenue line grew on volume plus a small price step on the measure the company prints.
The same annual report states that a utility-style regulatory framework — a revenue cap, a regulated asset base and quality standards — applies to the core fibre business, and that fibre uptake reached 75.9 per cent of addresses where fibre is available, from 74.3 per cent, after the total address base was adjusted in the fourth quarter to remove about 53,000 non-serviceable or vacant lots, with the prior year restated. That restatement matters when reading any uptake trend: the denominator moved, and the company says so.
The results presentation adds the profit picture — operating revenue of $1,029 million against $1,014 million, EBITDA of $726 million against $705 million, net profit of $37 million against $4 million, GPON fibre revenue of $792 million against $745 million, point-to-point fibre flat at $64 million, and copper connection revenue of $41 million against $75 million as copper connections fell 52 per cent to 44,000 (Chorus FY26 results presentation). It also lists proposed wholesale price changes from 1 January 2027 that were under consultation at publication, including Home Fibre 500Mbps moving from $58.73 to $61.08.
What the instrument can be held to
The regime's architecture has been remarkably stable while its parameters keep moving. The input methodologies for regulated fibre businesses were first determined in 2020 and have been amended since, with a consolidated determination as of 24 September 2026 (Commission, input methodologies for fibre). The original, [2020] NZCC 21, was made on 13 October 2020 under Part 6 of the Telecommunications Act 2001, with Part 2 applying to information disclosure and Part 3 to price-quality regulation, and set rules for cost allocation, asset valuation, tax, cost of capital and quality (NZLII reproduction of [2020] NZCC 21). The first review of those methodologies began on 27 March 2025, must be completed by 13 October 2027, and runs in two tranches, with the first tranche's final package delivered on 25 August 2026 (Commission project page).
What that structure promises a reader is narrower than a per-line guarantee and stronger than nothing. The cap is a total. Indexation is automatic. The true-up is deferred. Expansion outside the footprint now needs a net-benefit case and threshold clearance. Nothing in the documents read tells a household what its line will cost, because the instrument does not operate at that resolution.
So the honest instruction is procedural. When Chorus prints two measures of one shortfall, a reader should not pick the one that reads better, and should not average them into a third. Take $76,329,000 from the schedules, take $101 million from the announcement, attribute each, and wait for the document that explains the difference. The company's regulatory report is the ledger; the announcement is the narrative. They are not the same instrument, and on this record they do not agree.
The corporate and network context BTW holds on the entity sits at BTW directory: CHORUS NEW ZEALAND LIMITED.
Member Briefing
Read the full trend briefing
Members read the full briefing with the source notes behind every finding.
Strategic Circle
A daily briefing in your language, built from changes we have verified.
Join for USD 20/monthCancel anytime.
Members also get the full research library, a daily briefing on the networks they follow and the private forum.






