Summary
- APNIC's proposal page for prop-167 prints one status line,
Implemented, and two history dates: endorsed by the Executive Council on 4 December 2025, implementation complete on 30 June 2026. It prints no scope and no commencement date. - The Executive Council's own minutes for 2 to 4 December 2025 endorse prop-167-v002 “with respect to” publishing directory-service statistics and record that the MyAPNIC per-resource feature was not considered feasible at this time. The single word carries neither half of that.
APNIC's proposal page for prop-167, Published Statistics on Directory Service Usage, carries one status line: | Current status | Implemented |. Below it sit two dated entries in the proposal history — 4 December 2025, “Endorsed by the EC”, and 30 June 2026, “Implementation Complete” (prop-167).
Now read the deciding body's own record. The Executive Council met from 2 to 4 December 2025, and item 19 of the minutes, adopted by Resolution 2026-01 on 13 January 2026, records Resolution 2025-32. The Council “resolves to endorse the adoption of Prop-167-v002 with respect to publishing real-time or near-real-time statistics about its directory services usage as set out in the proposal text.” It then quotes what the proposal actually asked for: a MyAPNIC portal feature letting resource holders see how many times their allocated resources — IP addresses, ASNs — had been queried in WHOIS and RDAP, broken down by query type and source ASN if possible. And it tells the community what it thinks of that part: “the cost, resourcing, and potential privacy concerns outweigh the immediate benefit of such functionality and as such does not consider it feasible at this time.” The resolution passed unanimously (minutes).
Set the two documents side by side and the word is doing heavy lifting. It covers a scoped endorsement and an express refusal of a named component. It prints neither the scope nor the refusal. The prop-167 page even carries the v002 amendment describing the MyAPNIC per-resource statistics feature — the feature the Council declined — so a reader can meet the declined component on the status page and never learn its fate there.
Nothing on the page defines what “Implemented” means. APNIC's proposals index describes itself as listing proposals, their status in the policy development process and the Secretariat impact assessment, and it sorts entries under headings that include “In Implementation”, “Implemented” and “Did not reach consensus” (index). No page reviewed for this piece supplies a glossary. APNIC's own guidance for proposal authors says what these pages are meant to be: “A status page is created for each proposal. These pages form a public record and archive of all proposals that are discussed and decided by the APNIC Community under the PDP” (guidelines). A public record and archive that prints one word for a two-part decision has a gap in it. The gap is documented elsewhere, which is precisely what makes it a filing choice rather than a mystery.
The process page prints a sequence and exactly one duration. If consensus holds through the comment period, the SIG Chair asks the Council to endorse. After endorsement, “the APNIC Secretariat implements the policy. This usually occurs a minimum of three months after EC endorsement” (process). A minimum, no maximum, no consequence for running long, and no sentence naming the event that starts the clock for anyone outside the Secretariat.
Run the arithmetic, mine and labelled as mine: 4 December 2025 to 30 June 2026 is 208 days. Three months from endorsement lands on 4 March 2026, so the completion date sits 118 days past the floor the process page prints. APNIC prints neither interval. Both are subtraction from two dates the page prints, and neither proves anything beyond how wide the gap was.
Here is what a resource holder holds after reading the page. Implementation finished on 30 June 2026. Not stated: when the policy took effect, which members it binds, or what changed on the day. The circulated Secretariat notice says only that the Secretariat “will begin the implementation process and inform the community as soon as it is completed” (notice, a Policy SIG list reproduction; the announcement on APNIC's own site was not opened for this piece). Completed, not commenced. Those are two different facts, and only one of them is on the page.
One boundary, stated where it bites: the December 2025 minutes reached this piece through an extraction of the exact PDF URL rather than a direct read of the document, and that extraction may be truncated. A commencement clause elsewhere in the full minutes is not something this review establishes. What it does establish is what the proposal page prints, what the resolution's recorded text says, and that the page carries no such date.
For a bounded comparison, one publisher other than APNIC prints the distinction the page omits. RIPE NCC's policy implementation status page records that updated Certification Service Terms and Conditions “have been published on 6 May 2026 and will come into effect on 8 June 2026”, with monitoring beginning after that date (RIPE NCC status). Its terms page draws the same line inside a single document, saying the updated terms “will come into effect on 08.06.2026” while other changes “will be implemented at a later stage” (RIPE NCC terms). That is a difference between two document classes — one that prints an effect date, one that prints a completion date — not a finding about registries in general. Two pages from one publisher cannot carry a comparative rate, and this piece does not compute one.
What would make prop-167's entry mean something different is small and specific: a scope line that says which half of the proposal was adopted, a glossary that says what “Implemented” covers, and a commencement date printed where the completion date now sits. Until then the accurate reading of “Implemented” is “open item 19 of the December minutes”, which is an odd thing for a public record and archive to require of the people it is written for.
Member Briefing
Read the full trend briefing
Members read the full briefing with the source notes behind every finding.
Strategic Circle
A daily briefing in your language, built from changes we have verified.
Join for USD 20/monthCancel anytime.
Members also get the full research library, a daily briefing on the networks they follow and the private forum.






