Summary
- By-law 24 entitles every Member to "the number of votes allotted to that Member according to that Member's tier of membership" and leaves the number itself to a separate, undated election procedure page that runs from 1 for Associate to 64 for Extra Large.
- By-law 25 counts an Executive Council election by "a plurality of the votes cast" but the removal of a councillor, or a review of a council decision, by two-thirds "of the votes of the entire membership as paid-up 48 hours before the meeting" — a total APNIC computes and the record reviewed here does not print.
- Candidate totals are a prescribed disclosure and appear in the AGM transcripts. The aggregate is thinner: the 2024 read-out announced a total of 9,604 against five candidate counts adding to 9,595. That nine-vote gap is my arithmetic, and the transcript offers no reconciliation.
The provision that hands over the number and withholds it
By-law 24 is one sentence long. "Every Member shall be entitled to cast the number of votes allotted to that Member according to that Member's tier of membership." The provision grants a quantity and does not name it. The page that returns the sentence carries its own identity block — Version 004, date of this version 12 February 2026, Status: DRAFT — and, in the same block, the note that the document was amended by resolution of the Members on 12 February 2026. A resolution and a draft label on one page, with nothing on the page reconciling them. See the By-laws of APNIC.
The number by-law 24 withholds is printed somewhere else. APNIC's EC election procedure page sets out the scale: Associate 1 vote, Very Small 2, Small 4, Medium 8, Large 16, Very Large 32, Extra Large 64. The same table maps each tier to IPv4 and IPv6 holdings — Associate holds no prefix, Extra Large sits above /10 and /23 — so weight rises with address stock. The page displays no publication or last-updated date, which means nobody reading it can tell whether the scale in front of them is the scale that belongs to version 004 of the by-laws.
That is the first oddity in the arithmetic of APNIC governance: a Member who wants to know how many votes it holds cannot find out from the instrument that grants them. It has to find the procedure page, undated, which is not the by-laws and is not referenced by by-law 24.
The PDF copy APNIC publishes at its own upload path did not yield readable text in this review, so the by-law wording above is reported from the HTML page as returned and not checked against the PDF. The PDF may contain matter the page does not display.
Three rules, two denominators
By-law 25 does more work in one paragraph than most constitutions do in a section. As returned from the by-laws page:
All matters other than election or removal of Executive Council members or the amendment or repeal of these by-laws or the review or amendment of any decision of the Executive Council, shall be determined by a majority of the votes cast. All elections of Executive Council members shall be determined by a plurality of the votes cast, and in the event of a tie, a re-casting of votes is to take place. The removal of an Executive Council member or the review or amendment of any decision of the Executive Council shall each require the affirmative vote of two-thirds (2/3) of the votes of the entire membership as paid-up 48 hours before the meeting.
Three counting rules, and two different things being counted.
A majority of the votes cast, for ordinary matters. A plurality of the votes cast, for the election that constitutes the Executive Council, with a re-cast if the tie will not break. Both of those are denominated in votes cast — a quantity the meeting itself produces, and which the election result can in principle display.
Then the third. Removing a councillor, or reviewing or amending a decision the council has taken, needs two-thirds of "the votes of the entire membership as paid-up 48 hours before the meeting". That is not a share of the votes cast. It is a share of every vote the membership holds, assessed at a point in time, held by the organisation. A member can count the first two numbers off the result sheet. Nobody outside APNIC's own records can count the third.
The default sentence also carves out amendment or repeal of the by-laws and then declines to say what threshold applies to it. The exclusion is printed; the substitute is not. That gap is in the passage as returned, and this review does not fill it from inference.
One more collision worth naming precisely. The procedure page closes acceptance of proxy appointments "48 hours before the opening of the AGM". By-law 25 fixes its paid-up cut-off at 48 hours before the meeting. Two provisions, two rights, one clock reading — the first decides who may still appoint a proxy, the second decides whose votes form the base of a two-thirds test. Reading them as one deadline would be a mistake; they are two rules that happen to expire at the same hour.
What the tally actually prints
The election side is comparatively generous, and it is generous by requirement. The EC election procedure page obliges the Election Chair's declaration to include "The name and total vote count received by each candidate in the election". Candidate totals are not a courtesy; they are prescribed.
They duly appear. The 2024 AGM transcript reads out five counts — Sumon Ahmed Sabir 3020, Vincent Achie Atienza 3008, Kam Sze Yeung 2030, Rob Thomas 1355, and a fifth candidate 182 — and then states: "So total votes is 9604." Add those five printed figures and you get 9,595. The announced total is nine higher. The transcript's own front matter describes it as live transcription rather than a verbatim record, and it offers no reconciliation of the difference. The arithmetic is mine; the two published numbers are APNIC's.
The 2026 AGM transcript prints four counts — Sumon Ahmed Sabir 3,665; Vincent Achie Atienza 3,394; Kam Sze Yeung 2,756; Karla Stokes 2,031 — and in the passage inspected for this review carries no total at all. Only an excerpt was inspected, so the honest statement is that no aggregate appears in that excerpt, not that the document lacks one.
The 2022 Annual Report prints three candidate totals — 4,084, 3,238 and 3,057 — and a sentence about the election platform supporting "a record 1,270 Members voting in the 2022 EC election". That figure is a count of member organisations, not of votes. Converting it would need each voter's tier, and a member holding 64 votes and a member holding 1 both count once in 1,270. No reviewed document prints the tier distribution that would let the conversion be made.
The Annual Report 2025 presentation does print a membership total: 10,330 APNIC Members, a net rise of 160, beside 15,737 NIR sub-accounts. It prints no votes-cast figure, no candidate counts and no tier breakdown. So the organisation publishes how many members it has and not how many votes they hold between them.
For 2025 the trail thins further. The EC minutes of 27 February 2025 note the results and congratulate Kenny Huang, Roopinder Singh Perhar, Yoshinobu Matsuzaki and Anlei Hu on re-election: four names, no counts, no total. The Secretariat's results announcement does the same and points readers to a BigPulse poll-results page for the figures. That page was not obtained in this review, so nothing here is claimed about what it holds.
This is not a body that never decided to disclose aggregates. The EC minutes of 7 September 2015 record an agreement that the Election Chair would announce, in both EC and NRO NC elections, total paper ballots counted, valid and invalid ballots, the vote count for each candidate, and total aggregate counts for online and on-site votes. That is a policy minute from the paper-ballot era, not a result, and it binds nobody to a number today. It does show that the shape of the disclosure — parts and aggregate — was once specified in writing.
The other franchise that answers to the same word
Search for the APNIC constitution and the franchise you find may not be the one you wanted. APNIC's Transparency page explains that "APNIC EC Limited is a public company limited by guarantee with the Executive Council serving as both the Members and Directors of the company", and that one share in APNIC Pty Ltd is held on trust for the Executive Council by that company.
The Constitution of APNIC EC Limited, dated 11 July 2023, settles the point at rule 18.6.2: "A Member (whether present at the meeting in person or by proxy, attorney or Representative) has one vote." Rule 6.3 requires a person to be a member of the APNIC EC to be, and to remain, a Member of the Company. In that instrument the Members are the councillors, and each of them has exactly one vote.
So the word Member does two jobs in the same corporate family. In the by-laws it means a member organisation with somewhere between 1 and 64 votes at an APNIC member meeting. In the trustee company's constitution it means a councillor with one vote at that company's meetings. The two rules are not in contradiction: different bodies, different meetings, different purposes. But a reader who goes looking for how APNIC counts its votes and lands on the flat rule has found the trustee company, not the registry's franchise.
The constitution is reported here from a search-index extraction of the PDF rather than the file itself, and no later amendment was seen.
What would make the fraction checkable
None of the observations above require a threshold to move. Three publications would close the gap on their own.
First, the paid-up membership total that by-law 25's two-thirds test is measured against — one figure, dated, at the time of any removal or review. Second, the tier scale inside the by-laws themselves, carrying a version and a date rather than sitting undated on a procedure page. Third, the distribution of members across tiers, which is the only way a count of organisations becomes a count of votes.
With those three in hand, every number in by-law 25 becomes recomputable by a member with a calculator: the plurality from the candidate totals that are already required, the two-thirds from a published base. The rule would not be looser or tighter. It would simply be arithmetic a member could check — which is the difference between a threshold that binds a council and a threshold that a council reports.
Member Briefing
Read the full trend briefing
Members read the full briefing with the source notes behind every finding.
Strategic Circle
A daily briefing in your language, built from changes we have verified.
Join for USD 20/monthCancel anytime.
Members also get the full research library, a daily briefing on the networks they follow and the private forum.






