Summary

  • Consorzio Namex's Articles of Association make admission a decision of the President alone, or the Vice-President in his absence, with the Board of Directors holding nothing more than a later ratification.
  • The office-holder is named: Renato Brunetti, printed as President since April 2019 and as "Presidente (Unidata)" in the consortium's own 2026 report, with no end date for that power anywhere in the statute.
  • The consortium announces arriving companies in dated greetings that name no deciding organ, no ratification, no decision date and no signatory — so a personal act reaches the public record only as an institutional welcome.

The clause that hands one person the gate

An internet exchange is an unusual company. Its members interconnect with each other and compete with each other, and the decision that a new network may join is therefore not a customer sign-up but a boundary drawn around a room full of rivals. Namex, the Rome exchange whose registry object is AS24796 and whose directory entry sits at Namex IXP, publishes the rule that governs that boundary. It is worth reading closely, because it does not do what institutions usually do with a decision of this weight.

Article 6 of the Articles of Association is headed "MODALITÀ DI AMMISSIONE. QUOTE". An applicant files a written request with the Consiglio Direttivo, declaring that it holds the admission requirements and accepts the founding deed, the statute, any internal regulation and the Technical Regulations without reservation. Then the article hands the decision to a single office: "Il Presidente o, in sua assenza, il Vice-Presidente del Consorzio delibera sull'ammissione" — the President, or the Vice-President in his absence, deliberates on admission, having weighed the interest of the consortium, the applicant's possession of the requirements, and the opinion of the Technical Committee.

Only afterwards does the board appear. "L'ammissione sarà portata all'attenzione del Consiglio Direttivo, alla prima riunione dello stesso, per la ratifica dell'ammissione": the admission is brought to the Board of Directors at that board's first meeting for ratification. Ratification follows the decision; it does not make it. The same article then attaches money to the act — new members must subscribe a quota of entry into the fondo consortile, at an amount the board fixes, and admission with the delivery of services is conditional on paying it.

The rest of the statute closes every escape route. Article 17 lists the organs of the consortium as the Assemblea, the Consiglio Direttivo, the President and Vice-President, the Comitato Tecnico, and the Collegio sindacale if one is appointed; no direttore and no direttore generale appears among them, and the statute's board is a Consiglio Direttivo, not a Consiglio di Amministrazione.

Article 22 gives the board the power "ratificare l'ammissione di nuovi consorziati" — to ratify — alongside excluding members, constituting the Technical Committee and appointing its Direttore Tecnico, and approving technical and internal regulations. Article 24 gives the Comitato Tecnico exactly one function in the chain: it issues an opinion to the President on applications. An opinion addressed to the decider is not a decision.

The consortium's own Technical Regulations restate the sequence in English in section 2.3: applications are evaluated by the Technical Committee, which issues an opinion on compliance with the stated requirements; admission "is approved by the President of the Consortium, after consulting the Technical Committee, and is subject to ratification by the Board of Directors." Sections 2.2.1 to 2.2.5 set what an applicant must actually show — legal authority over and ownership of the resources and infrastructure used, at least one public ASN and public IP addresses from a recognised RIR, public IP connectivity and BGP capability, the required documentation, and compliance with technical, operational and security rules. Those are the tests. The judgment on them belongs to one person.

What the clause never limits

Article 23 is where the design becomes explicit. The President "dura in carica tre anni ed è rieleggibile" — holds office three years and is re-eligible — and the list of presidential duties includes the sentence that matters here: "delibera sull'ammissione di nuovi Consorziati e ne riferisce al Consiglio per la ratifica". He deliberates and reports. The board receives.

Read the article for what it declines to say and the silence is the finding. It sets no ceiling on how many admissions one presidency may decide. It imposes no interval between a decision and its announcement. It requires no written reasons, no record of which requirements were weighed, and no publication of the ratification that follows. The only limit on the admission power is the President's own tenure, which is three years and renewable indefinitely. Article 28 completes the picture by permitting the board — in permissive terms, "può approvare" — to adopt an internal regulation for applying the statute.

No standalone membership regulation governing admission turned up in the material read on 18 November 2026; the rule sits in Article 6 itself, where it has sat since the text was filed.

That filing has a form worth naming. The bilingual statute published as a PDF identifies itself as Annex B to deed no. 71.115, racc. no. 15.454, and closes with the signatures of Riccardo De Sanctis as President and Raniero Varzi as notary. The text inspected carries no adoption clause and no last-amendment clause giving a date; the only date attached to the file appears in its name, not in its contents. The consolidated HTML reproduction prints Articles 6, 17, 22, 23, 24 and 28 as used here and prints no version date at all — its "© 2024 NAMEX" footer is a site copyright notice, not a statute date. So the rule is quotable article by article, and its own effective date is not printed anywhere a reader can check. The PDF could not be rendered as continuous page text when it was read, so the statute wording above comes from indexed excerpt text rather than a clean page image.

The person the clause points to

The statute's chosen decider is not an abstraction. The consortium's governance page names Renato Brunetti as President and states that he has been President of the Namex Consortium since April 2019; the same page, undated, records that in 1985 he founded Unidata with two partners, and names Maurizio Goretti as Executive Director (CEO), at Namex since 1996. A post dated 1 March 2022 states that "Renato Brunetti (Unidata) has been confirmed as President, holding the position since 2019", and reports a board elected for a three-year term. The 2026 Namex Report lists "Renato Brunetti — Presidente (Unidata)" and a twelve-person Consiglio Direttivo including Rosario Pingaro as Vice-President.

The dated record has one hole, and it is the interesting one. A report of 25 March 2025 covers the board election held on 27 February 2025 during the assembly of the consorziati: twelve members, a three-year mandate, 66 votes cast of 180 eligible voters. The report does not say whether Brunetti was re-elected President at that assembly. So the office is documented by an undated page, a 2022 post and a 2026 listing, with no printed end date and no dated presidential vote in the material read. Take Brunetti's name out and the argument has no subject: substitute the CEO, the Vice-President or any director and there is no named holder of the Article 23 power, no person through whom admissions trace, and no printed affiliation standing beside the office. That is the test that decides whether a person carries an institutional story or merely decorates it.

Beside the office sits a printed affiliation. The 2022 post and the 2026 report both place "(Unidata)" after his name, and the biography says he founded the company. Yet no page read states that Unidata is a consorziata. What the connected-networks table does show, undated and dynamically maintained, is Unidata with AS5394 in a column headed "Member" — the site's operational word, not the statute's term, and not a register of members. Unidata's statutory membership is therefore unestablished here, and the two printed facts are left where the record leaves them: an affiliation printed beside an office, and an operational table listing a network. Nothing follows from the pairing that a document states.

What the record prints instead

The consortium does publish its arrivals. It publishes them as greetings. On 30 April 2024 it announced that "Namex is pleased to welcome Dimensione among its members" in the welcome to Dimensione. On 5 March 2024 it welcomed Enel Energia, referring to "just over a year since Enel Energia joined Namex" and to a welcome "among our members". On 19 February 2024 it announced that EI Towers is one of the latest additions, again "among its members".

Three dated announcements, three arriving companies, and not one of them names a deliberating organ, a ratification, a date of decision or a signatory. None uses the statutory word consorziato. They are what a marketing page looks like when the underlying act has no published form: warm, dated and institutional in tone, with the only accountable human being in the chain absent from the page.

Two names, two instruments

Namex also exists in the registry, and the registry says something subtly different from the website. In the RIPE-format record for AS24796, read through a whois mirror rather than the registry's own interface, the aut-num object carries as-name NAMEX-IXP and sits under organisation ORG-NC29-RIPE, whose org-name is NAMEX CONSORZIO, with country IT, org-type LIR, the description "Rome Internet eXchange point", an address at Via dei Tizi 6/b, 00185 Rome, creation on 2 April 2002 and last modification on 12 February 2026. The record keeps those two names in two fields. It does not merge them, and the merged string sometimes used to describe this exchange appears nowhere in it.

The exchange's name also appears inside its own operational table as a listed network, with AS24796. So the organisation is simultaneously the consortium, the holder of the address space, and one of the networks in the room. That is normal for an exchange. It is also why the admission rule matters more here than it would at a registry: the body that admits a member is the body that competes with it, and the body that ratifies is the same twelve people who run the fabric.

Where the record stops

What the pages read on 18 November 2026 do not contain is an act. No avviso di convocazione, no verbatim verbale assemblea, no board resolution and no signed admission decision naming a company admitted as a consorziato. No statutory elenco consorziati or register of soci was located. The member-labelled lists that were found are operational tables and a customer portal, neither of which is a register. Whether any welcomed company was actually deliberated on by the President, ratified by the board, or paid its quota is simply not shown; what is shown is that no such act is printed.

That is a claim about a document set and a date, not about the world. The HTML reproduction may reproduce a later amended text than the bilingual PDF and prints no version date by which to tell. The consolidated page and the filed annex both give a chain a reader can follow from application to ratification, and neither gives a reader a single instance of the chain being used.

Why the greeting is the finding

The temptation is to read this as a story about one man holding a gate. The statute does not support the outrage: it openly assigns admission to the President, in writing, under a numbered article, and a consortium of competitors is entitled to make entry a judgment call rather than a queue. The personalisation is the design, not the scandal.

The scandal is smaller and harder to dismiss. A decision that the statute vests in one person, with money attached and a ratification behind it, reaches the public record only as a dated compliment. A company joins a room full of its competitors and the world learns it from a welcome post that names no decider. The check exists on paper — requirements, a technical opinion, a board ratification, a quota — and every link of it is unobservable from outside. Anyone who wants to know how membership in this consortium is actually constituted has one instrument to read and no record of that instrument being used.

This is where the January 2025 coverage of Namex stops being sufficient. That piece measured traffic: a terabit crossing the fabric during a streamed football match. Volume tells you the exchange is busy. It tells you nothing about who decides that a network may enter it — and for an institution made of competitors, the second question is the one that shapes the room.