AFRINIC · RIR Watchdog
Story
BTW reporting and context linked to this RIR. For the proposal-by-proposal history, the people involved and their changing positions, start with Policy.
Story
Latest stories
1,191Stories
Story
The committee that did not yet exist: AFRINIC’s five-to-six-month accountability gap
AFRINIC’s Resolution 201602.270 altered a calendar, not a constitution. Yet by moving the first Governance Committee election and appointment from the May/June 2016 meeting window to November/December, the Board also postponed the arrival of a new place for structured advice…
Story
The USD 10,000 Decision: Tracing AFRINIC’s IETF Endowment Commitment
On 26 June 2015, AFRINIC’s Board turned an online resolution into a narrow corporate commitment: USD 10,000, once only, for the IETF Endowment. The amount was modest and the recipient’s work was closely connected to the technical standards on which address coordination depends.…
Story
Who Watches the Pay Committee? The Governance Test Inside AFRINIC Resolution 201411.221
In November 2014, AFRINIC’s Board approved the charter of a Remuneration & Compensation Committee. The public entry is only a sentence, and the charter itself is absent from the record examined here. Yet that small act exposes a large design problem: how can directors create a…
Story
The chair before the socket: Resolution 201411.218 and AFRINIC’s bylaw gap
AFRINIC’s November 2014 election-guideline decision joined a sensible procedural redesign to a constitutional change that still lay in the future. The central issue is not whether preparation was permissible, but whether a proposed Election Committee Chair could be kept dormant…
Story
A seat is not a mandate: what AFRINIC Resolution 201411.216 actually authorised
AFRINIC’s Board put three named people on a technical coordination team in November 2014. The surviving record is precise about that corporate act and strikingly quiet about any larger constituency behind it. That distinction matters: useful participation can be fast, expert and…
Story
The Boardroom Gate: AFRINIC Resolution 201411.211 and the Members’ Right to Know
On 23 November 2014, AFRINIC’s Board adopted a confidentiality rule by six votes, with none against and one abstention. Resolution 201411.211 protected a real institutional need: directors require space for candid discussion of personnel, legal advice, security and negotiation.…
Story
A Clock at the Service Desk: AFRINIC Draft 1 Without Sovereignty
On 26 October 2014, a proposal marked `Under Discussion` tried to turn delay, shifting evidence demands and intrusive questions into measurable service problems. Its importance lies not in making AFRINIC a regulator, but in showing how firm private obligations could constrain a…
Story
The Authority Map Missing from AFRINIC’s Collated Policy Manual
In October 2014, AFRINIC’s Board approved an already collated Policy Manual. The short public act records consolidation and approval, but not the manual’s identity, sources, hierarchy or operative history. That gap matters because a corporate manual is most useful when it makes…
Story
The Seven-Day Ledger: AFRINIC’s 2014 Registration Proposal and the Line It Could Not Cross
An assignment of eight IPv4 addresses could have started a seven-business-day countdown: under a 2014 proposal, an AFRINIC member would have had to turn that customer or infrastructure allocation into a documented WHOIS record. The discipline was practical and potentially…
Story
The Two-Page Threshold: What Resolution 201401.200 Put in Public View
AFRINIC chose speed with an explicit promise of completion: two headline statements would appear while signatures were pending, then a signed 31-page package would take their place. The surviving files show the disclosure boundary clearly. What they do not show is the dated…
Story
The Rotation Test: What AFRINIC’s 2014 Auditor Change Actually Controlled
AFRINIC’s move from Ernst & Young to KPMG mattered not because one global accounting name replaced another, but because the change exposed a chain of private-company accountability in which selection, recommendation, appointment, assurance and review belonged to different hands.
Story
Before the Ballot: Resolution 201404.196 and the Discipline of Rules Fixed in Advance
AFRINIC’s brief April 2014 resolution did something institutionally important before the next Board ballot: it approved a revised election rulebook. The enduring question is not whether that act made AFRINIC a public authority—it did not—but whether a private registry coordinator…
Story
The Charter at the Centre of AFRINIC’s 2014 CEO Search
AFRINIC’s approval of a CEO search charter looks like a procedural moment, but it carries a larger institutional question: can a private infrastructure coordinator show where confidential search work ends and accountable Board authority begins when the governing instrument itself…
Story
AFRINIC called transfer-policy criticism “mischievous.” The authority case is still open
AFRINIC answered outside criticism of its transfer policy by declaring its Board properly constituted, defending a bottom-up process and directing members to official channels. Its own litigation page now records the challenge to that Board’s ratification as ongoing. The gap is…
Story
The Check Before the Allocation: What AFRINIC Resolution 201411.214 Did—and Did Not—Authorise
On 25 November 2014, AFRINIC's Board recorded a unanimous decision giving its chief executive discretion to use available methods to authenticate resource-allocation applications. Yet the institution left two materially different public traces of that act. Its Board register…
Story
The Search Before the Succession: What AFRINIC’s 2014 CEO Committee Actually Controlled
AFRINIC’s October 2014 decision to name a five-person CEO Search Committee was a small entry in a Board register and a consequential act of institutional design. Read alongside the Board’s immediate November actions and the bylaws then in force, it reveals both the beginning of…
Story
The Ten-Name Slate and the Unseen Gate in AFRINIC's 2013 Board Election
In May 2013, AFRINIC's Board approved a list of candidates for the following month's Board election, but the surviving public record says almost nothing about what that approval involved. Resolution 201305.176 therefore matters less as a clue to any individual candidacy than as a…
Story
The Deputy’s Boundary: What AFRINIC’s 2013 Vice-Chair Appointment Did—and Did Not—Authorize
Resolution 201308.179 gave AFRINIC a named vice-chair and a fixed date on which that appointment ended. Its significance lies less in personal succession than in institutional continuity: a deputy could keep a meeting moving when the chair could not preside, while the Board’s…
Story
The Chair’s One-Year Clock: What Resolution 201308.178 Did—and Did Not Do
In August 2013, AFRINIC’s Board recorded a narrow but consequential act: Resolution 201308.178 appointed Badru Ntege as Chairman of the Board for one year, ending on 30 June 2014. The fixed term offered continuity without permanence. Read alongside the archived Bylaws, the…
Story
Four Names Before the Ballot: What AFRINIC’s 2013 NomCom Appointment Controlled
In April 2013, AFRINIC’s Board put Douglas Onyango, Pierre Dandjinou, Tim McGuiness and Mark Elkins on NomCom 2013. The resolution was only a sentence long, but the committee defined by the bylaws stood at a consequential gate: it could seek candidates, set eligibility criteria…