AFRINIC · RIR Watchdog
Story
BTW reporting and context linked to this RIR. For the proposal-by-proposal history, the people involved and their changing positions, start with Policy.
Story
Latest stories
1,191Stories
Story
AFRINIC’s litigation story needs an incentive timeline
The dispute with Cloud Innovation became a continental governance crisis, but labels such as aggressor or defender obscure the control question: who could prolong each case, who authorised that action and who was paid when it continued?
Story
ICANN and Mauritius must separate their AFRINIC powers
ICANN can question whether AFRINIC still satisfies recognition criteria, while Mauritius’ courts determine the receiver’s legal authority. Treating those two powers as interchangeable would deepen the registry’s legitimacy crisis.
Story
AFRINIC’s legal-spend debate needs an audited ledger
An October 2021 engagement letter set a US$1,000 hourly rate and left disbursements uncapped. The document raises serious oversight questions, but only a complete invoice and approval record can establish what AFRINIC actually paid and who authorised it.
Story
A stronger complaint gate cannot carry the whole weight of due process
Draft 3 made an evidence-free complaint less able to trigger an AFRINIC resource review, but left the far more consequential stages after entry substantially where Draft 2 had put them. That asymmetry matters because procedural legitimacy is not secured at the threshold alone: it…
Story
AFRINIC contained a million-address routing incident. Its safeguard record is still incomplete
AFRINIC says it removed IRR entries that helped unauthorised routes from the reserved block 102.224.0.0/12 spread, contacted transit providers and intensified monitoring. Public route history supports much of that account and shows the routes are no longer visible to RIPE RIS…
Story
The Eightfold Cut That Still Had No Mandate: Soft Landing BIS Draft 3 at AFRINIC-25
On 22 July 2016, Soft Landing BIS Draft 3 reduced its proposed Phase 1 ceiling from a `/15` to a `/18`, cutting the maximum request from 131,072 IPv4 addresses to 16,384. The proposal kept the rest of its scarcity machinery substantially in place and went to AFRINIC-25 on 29…
Story
The Unwritten Rule at AFRINIC’s Review Gate
In August 2016, the second draft of an AFRINIC resource-review proposal altered a single verb in the clause governing community complaints. That small edit matters because a private technical registry does not need to reach a final finding before a review begins to impose costs.…
Story
An Invitation to Every Meeting: What Resolution 201608.298 Changed at AFRINIC
On 10 August 2016, AFRINIC’s Board moved from noting legal advice on one agenda item to creating a standing invitation for its Legal Adviser at every Board meeting. That modest-looking change could bring legal discipline closer to decisions, but it also raised a lasting…
Story
From One Sentence to One Morning: What AFRINIC Resolution 201608.297 Actually Made Possible
An August resolution offered one short bridge from a postponed Governance Committee election to a special members’ meeting; by 30 November, that bridge had become a morning of twenty bylaw propositions, a tea break and a tightly timed election for a non-binding advisory body. The…
Story
AFRINIC’s 2016 Strategy Vote and the Two-Year Publication Gap
On 8 July 2016, AFRINIC’s Board unanimously authorised publication of a strategy for 2016–2020. Yet the organisation later said that only an extract appeared that September because the full plan was considered internal; approval to publish the complete document came in May 2018…
Story
Inside the Unseen Table: What AFRINIC Delegated in July 2016—and What It Did Not
On 8 July 2016, AFRINIC’s Board unanimously approved an internal delegation-of-authority document intended to distinguish decisions for the Board, the chief executive and other roles. The table itself is not in the public record. That absence matters because delegation is the…
Story
Four committees, twelve seats, and the mandate record AFRINIC members could not see in one place
On 8 July 2016, AFRINIC’s Board considered a committee composition table already discussed informally at its retreat, reconstituted four temporary bodies with twelve seats between them, and adopted the resolution with one proxy-represented director abstaining. The act looks like…
Story
Three Smaller Rooms: AFRINIC’s 2016 Standing-Committee Control Map
Two committee chairs crossed the boundary between finance and audit, but they did not cross on equal terms. That small asymmetry in AFRINIC’s July 2016 committee roster reveals what the resolution really was: a private-company arrangement for moving information, framing…
Story
From Ballot to Ledger: What AFRINIC Resolution 201607.287 Actually Did
Five days after new Board terms began, AFRINIC recorded a precise piece of corporate housekeeping: remove Aminata Amadou Garba and add Seun Ojedeji on the List of Directors and Members at the Registrar of Companies of Mauritius, effective 1 July 2016. Resolution 201607.287…
Story
The Signature After the Vote: What AFRINIC’s 2015 Accounts Approval Really Carried
On 6 June 2016, AFRINIC’s Board approved financial statements that the record described as already prepared and audited, while the auditor’s signature was still expected to follow. That sequence can support accountability—but only if every handoff, omission and unresolved control…
Story
The auditor’s return: what AFRINIC’s 2016 reappointment record can — and cannot — show
AFRINIC’s decision to retain PwC for the 2016 financial year looks simple only from a distance. Read closely, the public record describes a sequence of distinct acts: committee review, Board recommendation and member approval. That sequence created a route for accountability, but…
Story
When an audit becomes a claim to power: AFRINIC’s first resource-review draft
On 18 May 2016, four authors published a proposal for AFRINIC to audit the number-resource records of its members. The administrative premise was serious: a registry cannot keep a dependable ledger if it cannot test stale, contradictory or false information. But…
Story
The Boundary in the Room: What AFRINIC’s 2016 Conduct Code Could—and Could Not—Do
AFRINIC’s Board adopted Resolution 201605.283 to govern behaviour in meetings and mailing lists, where a well-aimed intervention can protect participation but an overextended one can redistribute institutional power. The enduring significance of the code lies in that boundary. A…
Story
Seven Days, a Different Instrument: How Soft Landing BIS Draft 2 Turned a Patch into a Replacement
The most consequential change between the first two Soft Landing BIS drafts was not a newly tightened address threshold. It was a change in form: within seven days, a selective amendment became a self-contained replacement, altering how readers would identify, interpret and audit…
Story
The Final Pool Was a Ledger, Not a Realm
Soft Landing BIS Draft 1 offered a concrete bargain for the dwindling IPv4 pool: cut the largest Phase 1 award, move to the next phase at a declared pool threshold, and preserve separate routes for shared infrastructure, first-time applicants and needs not yet foreseen. The…