AFPUB-2012-GEN-001-DRAFT-02

AFPUB-2012-V4-001-DRAFT-01

Assessment: Insufficient evidence to assess consistency · The submitted text advocates extending the existing anycast policy to IPv6 and AS Numbers. This one submission establishes that proposal, but cannot by itself establish persistence or reversal over time.

Conditions: Authorship and proposed text are distinguished from adoption or community consensus. · The stated geographic rationale concerns legitimate members supporting their networks; it is not unlimited permission for every applicant.

Oct 9, 2014

The proposal modifies AFPUB-2012-V4-001 to include the option to request IPv6 space and AS Numbers for anycast purposes from AFRINIC and for AFRINIC to issue these resources to the requestors.

Anycast resource assignments in the AFRINIC region

Assessment: Consistent · The proposed addition of BCP169 and subsequent support for Alan's successor-reference wording are compatible steps toward clearer technical references. The later response endorses an update rather than withdrawing the earlier anycast-use objective.

Conditions: The exact text of Alan's intervening suggestion is not reproduced in these two messages. · The expectation that the change satisfies everyone is the author's expectation, not a formal consensus decision.

Dec 8, 2014

These resources must be used for the sole purposes of providing anycast services or GRX (GPRS Roaming Exchanges) as recommended in BCP126 and BCP169.

Dec 12, 2014

Thanks Alan. I like that. Ernest - can you please update the current online wording to reflect what Alan says.

Out-Of-Region Use of AFRINIC Internet Number Resources

Assessment: Insufficient evidence to assess consistency · The question challenges a possible exclusion of foreign companies that operate in Africa. It does not supply an explicit position on the full out-of-region proposal or a second position to compare.

Conditions: A question about company origin must not be converted into support for unrestricted use outside Africa.

Oct 22, 2014

If a non African company moves into Africa - why would the policy not allow them IPv4 address space?

AFPUB-2012-V4-001-DRAFT-01 · Anycast resource assignments in the AFRINIC region

Assessment: Consistent · The extension submitted in October and the December reference edits share the same purpose: make IPv6 and AS Numbers available for specified anycast or GRX uses. Refining the technical references does not contradict that purpose.

Conditions: This comparison concerns the author's submitted and proposed wording, not whether either proposal was adopted.

Oct 9, 2014

This proposal allows an organization to receive an IPv4/IPv6 allocation or assignment and an AS Number purely for anycast or GPRS Roaming Exchange (GRX) usage.

Dec 8, 2014

This proposal allows an organization to receive an IPv4/IPv6 allocation or assignment and/or an AS Number purely for anycast or GPRS Roaming Exchange (GRX) usage in line with the provisions of BCP126 and BCP169.

AFPUB-2012-V4-001-DRAFT-01 · Out-Of-Region Use of AFRINIC Internet Number Resources

Assessment: Insufficient evidence to assess consistency · The anycast text discusses regional members' operations regardless of physical location, while the out-of-region question asks about foreign companies operating inside Africa. Those are different eligibility dimensions; these messages do not establish contradictory rules or a complete shared position.

Conditions: Distinguish a company's origin, membership eligibility and the physical use of its resources.

Oct 9, 2014

number resources allocated/assigned by AFRINIC are used by legitimate members from the service region to support their network operations, regardless of physical location.

Oct 22, 2014

If a non African company moves into Africa - why would the policy not allow them IPv4 address space?