Summary
- Article 7(5) gives a competent authority four months from a complete permit application to grant or refuse, and Article 8(1) makes a missed deadline grant the permit anyway — "shall be deemed to be granted", expressly not for rights of way.
- Article 8(2) lets a Member State derogate from that rule wherever compensation or a court or supervising-authority referral is available; in the provisions read, the derogation carries no publication duty comparable to the one Article 7(5) imposes on extension grounds, and the permit side's only public output is a Member State report every three years.
Three clocks, and only two of them leave paper
The Gigabit Infrastructure Act applies from 12 November 2025, with Article 10(1)-(3) from 12 February 2026 and the electronic-submission duties of Articles 4(3), 6(1), 7(2)-(3) and 12(1)-(3) from 12 May 2026 (consolidated text, EPRS procedure file). It runs three clocks a network builder can actually use: access to somebody else's duct under Article 3, a permit decision under Articles 7 and 8, and access to the wiring inside a building under Article 11.
They are not three versions of the same instrument. Two are addressed to whoever holds the physical thing, and if the answer is no they end in a written artefact. The third is addressed to the authority that grants, and its most valuable outcome for a builder is not a document at all. It is the authority's failure to produce one.
Four months, and the day the clock starts
Article 7(5) packs three rules into one paragraph. Competent authorities shall grant or refuse permits, other than rights of way, within four months of the date of receipt of a complete permit application. Completeness is determined within 20 working days. And that determination does not suspend or interrupt the four-month examination period (consolidated text).
That third rule is the one to read twice. An authority cannot stop the clock by asking the applicant questions: the 20 working days for deciding whether the file is complete sit inside the four months, not ahead of them. An extension exists, but it is fenced — on grounds set out and published in advance through the single information point, in exceptional and duly substantiated cases, the shortest possible, not exceeding four months save to meet other specific procedural deadlines, and never to obtain missing information the authority failed to request. A refusal must be substantiated on objective, transparent, non-discriminatory and proportionate conditions, which recital 43 states in the same terms (Official Journal text).
Rights of way have their own clock under Article 7(6): four months or the national deadline, whichever is shorter, except in expropriation. They also carry an exclusion from the next paragraph, which is the whole story.
The sentence that grants a permit without a signature
"In the absence of a decision from the competent authority within the applicable deadline referred to in Article 7(5), the permit shall be deemed to be granted upon expiry of that deadline" (consolidated text).
Read what that does to a builder's balance sheet. Four months after a complete application, the permit exists because nobody wrote a refusal. The regulation then tidies the paperwork: the rule applies only where the procedure does not concern rights of way; on request the operator or any affected party is entitled to written confirmation that the permit has been implicitly granted; and affected third parties may intervene in the administrative procedure and challenge the grant.
So the most valuable permit in the file is the one with no reasoning attached, obtained by a written request confirming that the silence did its work. And the trench in the road — the rights of way — is precisely where that mechanism is switched off.
The switch
Article 8(2) is one sentence long and it reshapes the previous paragraph. Member States may derogate from deemed granting where at least one remedy is available: the operator that suffered damage from the authority's non-compliance with the deadline may claim compensation under national law, or it may refer the case to a court or to a supervising authority. Where a Member State derogates, Article 8(3) substitutes a procedure for the silence — a conciliation meeting convened no later than two months after the request, a written account, and an indicated date for the permit decision (consolidated text).
That is not a drafting accident, and the legislative file says so. The European Parliamentary Research Service records that the Council position of December 2023 deleted the Commission's tacit-approval notion, and that the February 2024 agreement instead fixed the four-month deadline and left Member States three ways to enforce it: tacit approval, compensation, or a right to take the case to a court or a supervisory authority (EPRS procedure file). The silence is the compromise. The switch is what made the compromise signable.
Now the asymmetry this article exists to point at. Article 7(5) requires the grounds for an extension to be published in advance through the single information point, so a builder can know before filing which excuses an authority has reserved. Nothing in the provisions I read attaches a comparable publication duty to the Article 8(2) derogation. The permit side's only public output in that set is Article 7(10): Member States report to the Commission every three years (consolidated text).
Stated precisely, as a finding about a named set of provisions rather than about Europe: the permit chapter publishes the excuse for delay and does not publish the switch that removes the permit. The builder that most needs to know which regime it is operating under — silence grants, or silence triggers a conciliation and a compensation claim — has no printed place in the text to look. That is an argument from silence. It is not proof that no duty exists elsewhere, and I read no national implementing measure.
Where the access side does leave paper
The contrast is sharpest against Article 3. Network operators and public sector bodies owning or controlling physical infrastructure must meet all reasonable written requests for access on fair and reasonable terms and conditions, including price, and public bodies must do so non-discriminatorily. Refusal is confined to six grounds: technical unsuitability, lack of space, safety, national security or public health, network integrity and security, a duly justified risk of serious interference, and the availability of a viable alternative means of passive wholesale access. The refusal itself has a clock — specific and detailed written reasons no later than one month from receipt of the complete request, with an exception for national critical infrastructure (Article 3).
On that route the negative decision is the artefact. It arrives in writing, within a month, and it has to survive six enumerated grounds.
If it does not satisfy the asker, Article 13(1) refers the dispute to the national dispute settlement body where access is refused or where terms including price are not agreed within one month of the request, and again where no in-building agreement is reached within one month. Article 13(2) fixes the decision clocks: four months for access disputes, one month for information, civil-works and in-building disputes, extendable only in duly justified exceptional circumstances (Article 13).
Then Article 13(4), the sentence that makes the access side checkable: "The dispute settlement bodies shall publish their decisions, while respecting the principles of confidentiality and protection of business secrets." The single information point must ensure access to those decisions, and recital 65 of the Official Journal states the same two-part duty (Article 13, Official Journal text).
So the access side produces a case record a stranger can read, subject to that confidentiality carve-out. The permit side produces an aggregate report every three years. Article 15 completes the picture in one direction only: Member States must lay down penalties for infringements of the regulation and of binding decisions adopted under it, appropriate, effective, proportionate and dissuasive (Article 15). A penalty regime needs a decision to attach to, and on the permit side the helpful outcome is the absence of one.
The building, and the price inside it
Article 11 is where the Act touches the part of the network most people never see. Any provider of public electronic communications networks has the right to access existing in-building physical infrastructure "if duplication is technically impossible or economically inefficient". Any holder of a right to use the access point and that infrastructure must meet all reasonable written requests on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms and conditions, "including price, where appropriate" (Article 11).
Two strings on one right. The first is a technical test that in most buildings is settled by arithmetic — one set of risers, one set of ducts. The second is a price formula that says FRAND and stops.
BEREC, which Article 11(6) required to publish guidelines by 12 November 2025, reads it much further. Its October 2025 guidelines recommend that use of in-building physical infrastructure should in general remain free of charge where the building owner owns it, permit cost recovery only in specific circumstances a Member State allows, and ask for documented costs, benchmark-based pricing and depreciation typically not exceeding 30 years. The same document states that it does not take precedence over the regulation and does not bind courts (BEREC BoR (25) 142).
That is a real tension and it deserves naming as one: the enacted text prices access, softly, through FRAND; the regulator's reading prefers the number zero. Where the line falls in a particular case is not decided by BEREC. It is decided by the Article 13(2) dispute body, which must issue a binding decision on an in-building dispute within one month.
My own line, offered as judgement rather than as law: documented, non-discriminatory, benchmark-verifiable cost recovery is a legitimate charge for an asset somebody paid for; a price that captures the value of the impossibility of duplication is not, because it rebuilds at the riser the bottleneck the access right exists to remove. The test is whether the access right still works after the invoice.
One date sits above all of this. Article 10 requires fibre-ready in-building physical infrastructure and an access point for buildings whose building-permit applications are submitted after 12 February 2026 (full text). The next generation of buildings is supposed to arrive wired. Article 11 is what happens in the ones that already exist.
What this reading establishes, and what it does not
The grading travels with the finding.
Articles 7, 8 and 19 were read in the EUR-Lex consolidated text, which states on its own cover that it is a documentation tool with no legal effect and that the Official Journal version is authentic; I did not open the Official Journal PDF. Articles 3, 11, 13 and 15 were read in a third-party mirror and were not checked against the Official Journal — of those, Article 13(4) is corroborated by recital 65 of the Official Journal text, and Articles 3, 11 and 15 are not. Recitals 43 and 65 are the only recitals I read.
No national implementing measure was read. No notification of an Article 8(2) derogation, no single information point, no national dispute settlement decision and no permit register was inspected on 18 November 2026. Nothing here says that any Member State has used Article 8(2), that any decision went unpublished, or that any authority missed a deadline.
Whether an Article 8(2) derogation must be published under some other instrument is unresolved in the provisions I read. That is a boundary of this reading, not a finding that no such duty exists.
Article 5 on civil works and coordination, Article 12 on the single information point, Article 14 on competent bodies and Articles 16 to 18 were not read; Articles 4 and 6 are known to me here only through summarised claims.
Two EUR-Lex addresses in the eli/reg/2024/1309 form returned no readable text to my retrieval route on 18 November 2026, and the operative text came from other renderings of the same act. That is a reading-mode limitation, not a fact about the regulation.
An unverified banner on a mirror page asserts that one provision was amended on 2 November 2026. Nothing in the retained set confirms it, and this article asserts it nowhere.
No operator, authority, building, project, route or price is named. Article 8(3)'s conciliation mechanics are described as written; whether any Member State has convened such a meeting is unknown and is not suggested.
And the delta. This desk's archive holds one item on this regulation: a German-language announcement of its presentation, published 14 November 2025, which reads no provision of it. The two permit clocks, the deemed grant, the derogation and the publication duty are unclaimed ground here, and no figure, deadline or quotation above is carried over from an earlier BTW article.
What a builder should do with this
The practical consequence is not that Europe has sped up permitting. It is that a builder's calendar is set by which of the three routes its project uses, and only two of those routes produce a document it can hold.
On a duct, the instrument is the written request, because the answer must be written within a month and must fit one of six grounds. In a building, the instrument is the same request plus a dispute body that must decide within one month. On a permit, the instrument is the four-month clock, and the outcome most worth having is the one nobody signs — unless the Member State has taken that outcome away, in which case the remedy is a meeting within two months, a written account, an indicated decision date, and a claim at home.
Which means the question to put to a Member State is not how long permits take. It is whether it has derogated, under which of the two remedies, and where in the public record that choice is written down. On the text I read, the regulation does not require an answer to the last part. That is a design feature, not a gap to be filled by assumption — and it decides what the silence is worth.
Member Briefing
Read the full trend briefing
Members read the full briefing with the source notes behind every finding.
Strategic Circle
A daily briefing in your language, built from changes we have verified.
Join for USD 20/monthCancel anytime.
Members also get the full research library, a daily briefing on the networks they follow and the private forum.






