Summary

  • The federal ceiling on a pole attachment is a band with two limbs: not less than the additional costs of providing the attachment, and not more than a space factor multiplied by the owner's operating expenses and actual capital costs attributable to the whole pole.
  • That space factor is the attachment's share of total usable space, which makes the only ceiling in the text a fraction divided by the owner's own declaration about its own asset.
  • The federal price leaves the pole wherever a State regulates: the section gives the Commission no jurisdiction over rates, terms, conditions or access in that case, and what a State files describes its own authority and its own practice of weighing subscribers and utility consumers, not any rate it will set.

Two pages, read on 17 November 2026, carry this whole story: the Commission's pole attachment rules in Part 1, Subpart J of Title 47, and the codified text of 47 U.S.C. §224 at Cornell's Legal Information Institute. Neither is a certified copy. Both are enough to see the shape of the thing, which is a price built out of a measurement the seller makes.

A ceiling with two limbs

The rules state the standard in one sentence, and the sentence rewards slow reading:

"For the purposes of this paragraph, a rate is just and reasonable if it assures a utility the recovery of not less than the additional costs of providing pole attachments, nor more than an amount determined by multiplying the percentage of the total usable space, or the percentage of the total duct or conduit capacity, which is occupied by the pole attachment by the sum of the operating expenses and actual capital costs of the utility attributable to the entire pole, duct, conduit, or right-of-way." (electronic Code of Federal Regulations, 47 CFR Part 1, Subpart J)

Read that as arithmetic and it is two limbs, not one. The floor is what the attachment costs the utility to provide. The ceiling is a product: a fraction multiplied by a cost base. The cost base is the owner's operating expenses and actual capital costs attributable to the entire pole — the whole asset, not the attachment's slice of it. The fraction is the slice: the percentage of total usable space the attachment occupies.

The page then adds: "The Commission will apply the following formulas for determining a maximum just and reasonable rate: . . . Rate = Space Factor × Cost". The formulas themselves are elided there. What survives is the form of the maximum: one factor times one cost.

Here is the part that decides money. A fraction has a denominator, and this one is total usable space. My own restatement, not a rate: a space factor of 0.10 applied to a cost base of 100 returns 10. Hold the occupied space fixed and declare a smaller usable space, and the factor rises — and the ceiling with it. Nothing in that is an accusation against any owner. It is what a ratio does when its denominator is a declaration about the thing being sold.

The switch, and what it certifies

Now the second document. The statute's carve-out is written as a limit on the section itself:

"Nothing in this section shall be construed to apply to, or to give the Commission jurisdiction with respect to rates, terms, and conditions, or access to poles, ducts, conduits, and rights-of-way as provided in subsection (f), for pole attachments in any case where such matters are regulated by a State." (47 U.S.C. §224, Cornell Legal Information Institute)

That is not a standard of review and it is not a finding about a state's rates. It is a jurisdiction switch, and the condition on it is that such matters are regulated by a State. The same passage says what a regulating State must file:

"Each State which regulates the rates, terms, and conditions for pole attachments shall certify to the Commission that— (A) it regulates such rates, terms, and conditions; and (B) in so regulating such rates, terms, and conditions, the State has the authority to consider and does consider the interests of the subscribers of the services offered via such attachments, as well as the interests of the consumers of the utility services."

Look at what the certificate is about. Limb (A) is a statement that the State regulates. Limb (B) is a statement that the State may consider, and does consider, two sets of interests — the subscribers of the services carried over the attachments, and the consumers of the utility's own service. Both limbs describe the regulator: its authority and its practice. Neither limb describes a rate, a method, a formula, a ceiling, a cost base or a measurement of any pole.

So the switch is thrown by a document that does not contain the thing it switches. A State certifies its own competence and its own habit of weighing subscribers against utility consumers, and the federal ceiling stops applying. What replaces it is whatever that State's law provides, and on that subject these two pages say nothing at all.

What I could not read

The boundaries matter more than usual here, because the subject invites filling them in.

Only these two pages were read. Only the sentences quoted above are verbatim text I hold. Behind "Rate = Space Factor × Cost" sits a set of formulas the retained passage elides; I have not reproduced them and will not reconstruct them. The separate statutory treatment of a telecommunications carrier's attachment and a cable operator's was sought this week and not obtained — neither page I read shows such a split, and this article describes none. The make-ready sequence, whatever it requires and whoever pays for it, is named in neither passage, so no obligation, no clock and no cost allocation appears here.

No complaint route was read either, so nothing is said about the remedy available to an attacher who disputes the owner's numbers. The term usable space is used in the formula and defined in nothing I read, including the question of whether it counts the space the utility itself occupies.

No state certification filing was read: not one letter, not a list, not a count, not a date. No pole owner, attaching provider or state commission is named in this article, and no dollar rate appears in it. Every absence above is an absence from two pages read on 17 November 2026. None of it is a claim that any provision, formula or filing is unpublished or withheld.

Why a builder should care about a denominator

Strip the law to its mechanics and the position of a competitive fibre provider is this. The price of occupying a pole is capped by a product whose second term is the owner's cost of the whole pole and whose first term is a share of the pole's usable space. Both terms originate with the party selling the access. The attacher brings a cable, a lashing and a survey — and no authority to declare how much of the pole is usable.

Then comes the forum question, which arrives before the price question and can dispose of it. On the same pole, the applicable ceiling may be a federal formula or a state regime, and which one it is turns on whether a state regulator has filed a certificate about its own authority. A certificate is cheap to describe and expensive to argue with, because it is not a rate decision that can be attacked as too high or too low. It is a statement of who decides.

That is the whole instrument in two moves. The seller supplies the denominator. The State supplies the switch.

I have written before about price lists that print a number and hide the hand that set it, and about a per-unit metric whose denominator the publisher never prints. This is the same family of problem with a harder edge: here the denominator is printed, inside the formula, and it is a quantity the party charging the rate declares about its own asset. The Commission's own page says so in one sentence, then declines to show the formulas.

The directory entry for the Federal Communications Commission holds earlier pieces from this desk — handset unlocking, satellite constellations, submarine cable security, equipment bans, commissioner turnover, robocalls. Not one of them reads this subpart as a price instrument, which is why the fraction is worth printing.