Summary
- ARIN's Bylaws, marked Version 32 – 16 May 2022, allow a trustee to serve as two officers only if elected to do so by the affirmative two-thirds vote of the Trustees then in office.
- The Board's minutes elect Nancy Carter Treasurer on 14 January 2025 and Chair by acclamation on 29 October 2025; the 10 November 2025 attendance list prints her as "Chair and Treasurer", and no document read for this article records the two-thirds vote behind that label.
The count the instrument asks for
ARIN publishes its Bylaws twice over: as a page on its own site (ARIN Bylaws) and as a PDF marked "Version 32 – 16 May 2022" (PDF edition). Article VII, Section 1 lists the officers — "a Chair of the Board, a President, a Treasurer, a Secretary, and such inferior Officers, including a Vice Chair, as the Board of Trustees may determine." Section 2 gives the choice to the trustees themselves: the Chair is elected by the Board from among its members, every other officer except the President is elected by the Board, and the Chair, Secretary and Treasurer are elected "during the first meeting of the Board after January 1". A majority of trustees in office is enough.
Then comes the sentence that matters here:
No Trustee shall simultaneously serve the position of two officers unless elected to do so by the affirmative two-thirds vote of the Trustees then in office; this restriction does not apply to the ability of officers to serve as such other inferior officers that may have been determined by the Board of Trustees.
Two-thirds of the trustees then in office is a higher bar than the majority the same section sets for an ordinary officer election, and it is a bar that produces a number. ARIN's separate Meeting Procedures supplies a term the Bylaws leave implicit — "Each officer shall be elected for a one-year renewable term by the affirmative vote of at least a majority of the members of the Board of Trustees then in office."
The instrument even contemplates a chair carrying a treasurer's work. Article VII, Section 5 provides that when the office of Treasurer is vacated, the Chair "shall assume the duties of Treasurer until such time as the Board of Trustees shall elect a new Treasurer." Duties, not the office. Whether that distinction explains a printed office title is my reading of the two sections, not a rule ARIN states.
The interval, in the Board's own pages
On 14 January 2025 the Board held its organizational meeting (minutes): Bill Sandiford was elected Chair by acclamation, Tina Morris Vice Chair, and Nancy Carter Treasurer. Chris Tacit was elected Secretary at the same meeting, after the Chair asked to hold that nomination over.
On 29 October 2025, under the heading "13. Any Other Business", the minutes record the change:
The Chair stated that he just sent an email officially resigning from the office of Chairman of the Board as his term as trustee is ending this year. A call for nominations to serve as Chair was made. Mr. Tacit nominated Nancy Carter and Ms. Carter accepted the nomination.
As there were no further nominations, Nancy Carter was elected ARIN Board Chair via acclamation.
The attendee list at the top of that same page still prints "Bill Sandiford, Chair" and "Nancy Carter, Treasurer": it describes the room as the meeting opened. ARIN's own recap blog the next day (ARIN 56 Day 1) describes Sandiford's resignation as tendered "yesterday" and calls Carter "the new Chair", adding that she is the first female Chair of the ARIN Board. It prints no tally either.
Ten days later, the attendance list of the 10 November 2025 meeting (minutes) prints: "Nancy Carter, Chair and Treasurer." Nothing else in those minutes elects, appoints or records an officer, an officer vacancy or a resignation. The nearest governance item is a draft: "The Board prepared an initial draft of the 2026 Board Leadership Plan during executive session; no formal action was taken."
The offices come apart again on 13 January 2026 (minutes). The attendance list prints "Nancy Carter, 2025 Chair and Treasurer", and the same meeting elects Carter Chair, Morris Vice Chair, Tacit Secretary and Hank Kilmer Treasurer, each by acclamation.
ARIN's current Board roster prints ten trustees, with Carter as Chair, Kilmer as Treasurer, Morris as Vice Chair, Tacit as Secretary and John Curran as President and CEO. Her biography reads: "Nancy held the roles of Treasurer and Chair of the Finance Committee from 2018 through 2025 and currently serves as Chair of the ARIN Board of Trustees. Her present term is scheduled to conclude on 31 December 2026." That biography is consistent with a treasurer's role running through 2025; it does not settle whether she held the office, carried its duties, or was labelled both ways.
The tally that is printed, and the one that is not
Later in the same 29 October minutes, the same document counts a vote: a motion to appoint Bill Sandiford to an Office of Past Chair failed, "(3 in favor, 6 oppose, 1 in abstention). The motion did not carry."
So ARIN's minutes can count. The officer election recorded beside that failed motion carries no figure at all. An acclamation can be unanimous consent by a board in which two-thirds also happens to be satisfied — nothing in the record rules that out. What the record does not do is show the number that the Bylaws make the condition of the second office.
What this record does not say
No document ARIN publishes that was read for this article on 18 November 2026 records the two-thirds vote on Carter's simultaneous service in two offices. None explains when or why the dual title appeared. None records a Treasurer vacancy or resignation between 29 October 2025 and 13 January 2026. None prints a tally for any of the acclamations in the three sets of minutes examined.
The absence described here is an absence in the record, not a finding about the boardroom. A unanimous board can satisfy a two-thirds threshold without a ballot, and this article does not claim otherwise.
One authority must be kept apart from another. ARIN's 2025 member election result — Lee Howard elected, incumbents Hank Kilmer and Rob Seastrom re-elected, three-year terms starting 1 January 2026 — is a member ballot seating trustees. It has nothing to do with a Board officer vote.
Why a printed label carries the weight
Board officers are the people who sign for the registry between member meetings. The Treasurer has custody of ARIN's funds, property and securities; the Chair is "the principal point of contact between the Board of Trustees and the President between meetings." Two of those in one trustee concentrates signature and contact in a single person. ARIN did not forbid that. Its Bylaws made it a decision the trustees have to take by a named margin, in the same instrument that counts everything else.
Where the margin never reaches the page, accountability shifts to whoever decides what the minutes print. The entry sits in ARIN's directory record as an institution whose own instrument states the test and whose own record stops short of showing it being met.
Member Briefing
Read the full trend briefing
Members read the full briefing with the source notes behind every finding.
Strategic Circle
A daily briefing in your language, built from changes we have verified.
Join for USD 20/monthCancel anytime.
Members also get the full research library, a daily briefing on the networks they follow and the private forum.






