Summary

  • Anatel publishes the rule that converts a measurement into a 0–10 score and the thresholds at each end of it, including a 1.99-percentage-point band for availability that runs from 98% to 99.99%.
  • The binding annex that carries the numbers, the per-operator result rows and the provenance of any single published figure were not readable in the thirteen documents reviewed on 21 November 2026.

Start with the arithmetic the agency gives away. On its quality-regulation page, Anatel states the mechanic in its own words: 'O VRsup representa o limiar em que os indicadores recebem a maior pontuação (dez), enquanto o VRinf representa o limiar em que os indicadores recebem a menor pontuação (zero)' — the upper reference value earns the ten, the lower reference value earns the zero, and results between the two are converted by a linear transformation under item I of art. 12 of the Documento de Valores de Referência. Both ends of every indicator's score are therefore published. The score itself is a computation.

Take availability, IND8. The reference values printed for the 2025 and 2026 cycles are 98% and 99.99%. The whole ten-point scale is earned across 1.99 percentage points, which means a service measured at 99% — a figure most readers would call excellent — lands at roughly 5.03 out of ten on my arithmetic. That number is not a published Anatel result; the endpoints are the agency's, the division is mine, and it is the only way to see how narrow the top of the scale is.

Resolution is not the same for every indicator, and the scale hides it. One point of the ten costs 0.199 percentage points on IND8, but 4.5 percentage points on IND9, the fixed-broadband indicator printed with a 40% to 85% band. Two indicators, one announced scale, a factor of about 22.6 between them. IND2, dropped calls, reverses the direction: 3% is the zero threshold and 1% the ten threshold, so a printed 2% scores five. Quoting any band without its direction inverts the meaning of the indicator.

Now ask where the numbers live. The Regulamento de Qualidade dos Serviços de Telecomunicações was approved by Resolução nº 717/2019, and its annex lists the indicators, not the values. The values sit in a separate document, and Anatel dates four internal acts on it: Resolução Interna nº 71/2021 approved it, and nº 132/2022, nº 397/2024 and nº 444/2025 revised it, according to the same page. The currently binding version is an internal act. Its entry on the agency's legislation index records that Resolução Interna nº 444, of 23 June 2025, approves the Documento de Valores de Referência and was published in the Boletim de Serviço Eletrônico of 30 June 2025. The annex itself was not readable in this review.

Its predecessor is still standing on the legislation portal, flagged REVOGADA with the words that revoked it. From that page the architecture is visible even where the cells are not: art. 12 normalises each indicator on a scale of zero to ten, art. 15 refers the reference values to a table, a separate heading carries cut-off values, and art. 19 §3º derives the municipal seal from the municipal index. The numeric contents of those tables did not render in the text read. So the shape of the instrument is public and its numbers, for a reader working from these pages, are not.

A date interval is worth putting on its own line. Resolução Interna nº 397/2024 said it would enter into force on 1 January 2025. It was revoked by the act published on 30 June 2025 — 180 days later on my count. The document that carries the thresholds a subscriber is scored against was replaced six months after those thresholds took effect.

Where the results live is a second question with a similar answer. Anatel describes an open-data set of monthly quality results for fixed telephony, mobile, fixed broadband and pay TV measured under the regulation, names its quality-obligations unit as responsible, and shows a last file change of 19 November 2026. A second set covers the indices and the A–E seals by operator, service and geography, defined in the same reference document, last changed 20 November 2026. Both were readable as descriptions. Neither displayed a row. The Anatel Qualidade app publishes each operator's seal and index by service, for every municipality, state and the country.

Then comes the question that decides what any of those numbers can prove. Anatel's own definition page says the index shows how well a service actually works, 'medindo o desempenho diretamente na rede das operadoras'. That is a description of the index, not a statement about a particular result. In the thirteen documents reviewed, no page states whether a given published value is the operator's own reported measurement or a measurement the agency made. A number can be exact and still leave a reader unable to say whose observation it is.

The consequence is cleaner than the measurement. The app page sets out a cancellation check: where an operator's seal drops to D or E, the subscriber may cancel without paying the fidelity penalty. That is a real price attached to a published grade, and it is the only published consequence of a seal downgrade readable here. A secondary technical analysis reproduces seal bands built from the sum of the index, perception and complaint bands — three or four for A, fourteen or fifteen for E — attributing them to the reference document, and dates the current version to a board meeting of 12 June 2025. That table is the analysis's, not the agency's own text, and it is labelled as such here.

One more act, two registers, one article surviving. Resolução nº 792/2026, published in the Diário Oficial da União on 15 October 2026, revoked arts. 2º, 3º, 4º, 6º, 7º, 8º, 9º, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16 and 17 of Resolução nº 717/2019, with effect thirty days after publication, which is 14 November 2026 — seven days before this review. A commercial legal database reproduces the same list and the same thirty-day rule. Art. 1º of Resolução nº 717/2019, the article that approves the regulation's annex, appears on neither list. The regulation survives by the single article the revocation left out.

Meanwhile the site's own surface lags its acts. The indicators page, published 20 December 2022, still presents the reference document as revised in 2022. The fixed-broadband reports page still leads with a historical series from a superseded quality regime running from November 2012 to February 2022. And the regulation has been amended once: Resolução nº 761/2023 changed the deadline for sending indicator-calculation data to the agency's quality system, in force 3 April 2023.

BTW has met this agency before, through its procedures rather than its ruler: the association litigation at the Supreme Court, the complaint channel that works at zero balance, the proposed committee for auction-funded commitments, the mobile concentration index that met a plan goal nationally while the municipal picture did not, the reasoning duty in public consultations, and the call-centre inspection regime. None of those reads a reference value, the annex that carries one, a per-operator measured result, or the exit right attached to a seal. The agency's directory footprint is on Anatel's BTW entry.

A subscriber can read the ruler and decide nothing. The mark needs three things this review did not find together on any page: annex cells a reader can inspect, a row that says whose measurement produced the value, and a published line from a miss to what happened next. Publish those and the index becomes checkable from outside. Until then the ruler is public, the marks are not, and the separation is the finding.