APNIC · RIR Watchdog
Story
BTW reporting and context linked to this RIR. For the proposal-by-proposal history, the people involved and their changing positions, start with Policy.
Story
Latest stories
296Stories
Story
APNIC’s Orbit Email Queue Was Delayed for 32 Hours. Its Release Needs a Receipt.
APNIC has recorded the service window and the stuck email processor. That is a useful notice. It is not yet a public account of the transition from a delayed mailing-list queue to a reconciled delivery record.
Story
APNIC’s Five-Year Audit Rule Needs a Public Exception Record
The interesting sentence on APNIC’s transparency page is not the comforting one about a financial audit. It is the operational one: the audit firm is rotated at least every five years. That is a rule a reader can hold in mind. The December 2025 Executive Council minutes then…
Story
APNIC Reissued Four Expired ASPAs. Its Repair Needs a State Receipt.
APNIC has reported a bounded correction: automatic renewal did not run, four ASPA entities expired, and the entities were reissued and published at 11:03. That is useful operational disclosure. It is not yet a measurement of what every repository, validator, router or customer…
Story
APNIC's EC Adopted Topic Shepherds. No Public Charter Says What a Shepherd Can Do
APNIC's Executive Council has chosen a sensible answer to a familiar board problem: give individual members continuing responsibility for important subjects. Its May minutes call them topic “Shepherds” and say they will lead discussions on allocated areas. The missing part is not…
Story
APNIC Called RPKI Mirroring Marginal. Its NNIX Pilot Tests a Different Benefit
In October 2025, APNIC assessed a repository mirror as a short-lived aid during a long outage and called the benefit very marginal. Seven months later, its agreement with NNIX proposed a Hangzhou mirror pilot around latency, validation speed and data availability. The…
Story
APNIC Counted 2,974 IDNIC Allocations. Its Three Completed NIR Reviews Have No Public Denominator
APNIC can show, with unusual precision, how one preliminary review began: 2,974 IDNIC allocations, a fixed date window and 1,216 records requiring more investigation. It can also say that three other NIR reviews are complete. What the public record cannot do is connect those…
Story
APNIC Signed a 2026 SANOG MoU. Its Public Link Still Shows “xxx” in the 2003 Text
APNIC says its Director General and the SANOG Chair formalized a Memorandum of Understanding at SANOG 44 in 2026. Yet APNIC's current partnership table still links readers to a three-page document whose operative date says `xxx day of August, 2003` and whose APNIC signature…
Story
APNIC Deferred Its Singapore Subsidiary. Its Public Record Still Lacks a Payment Baseline
APNIC did something institutions often find difficult: it investigated a proposed remedy and stopped when the assessed costs and risks exceeded the likely benefit. The unresolved question is not why Singapore was rejected. It is how the Member payment problems that started the…
Story
APNIC's Firewall Reboot Put Registry Writes and Repository Reads Under One Clock
APNIC says a network firewall detected a hardware fault and rebooted on 28 August, interrupting six named service surfaces for an incident window of eight minutes. The short duration is reassuring. The single clock is not a complete recovery statement, because the list stretches…
Story
APNIC Sold 6 Cordelia. Its RPKI CPS Still Says APNIC Owns the Building
Five days after APNIC announced that it had sold its South Brisbane office, two prominent registry contacts acquired fresh modification times and the unchanged post-office-box address. Yet the RPKI practice statement served from APNIC’s long-lived URL still says the registry owns…
Story
APNIC Told Malaysia It Could Not Process a New NIR. The Rules for Saying Yes Do Not Yet Exist
APNIC has given Malaysia a reasoned answer without giving it an application path. That distinction protects equal treatment today, but it also leaves every future decision behind a sequence whose owners, completion evidence and treatment of earlier interest are not yet joined in…
Story
APNIC’s Nine-Year EC Limit Is a Threshold, Not a Ceiling
APNIC’s new Executive Council rule is usually summarized as three terms or nine years. The adopted text is more exact—and more consequential. For future entrants it counts consecutive terms; for Council members in office on 1 January 2027 it counts years already served at a…
Story
APNIC Renamed an Election as an Appointment. The Selector Did Not Change.
APNIC's 2026 By-law amendment replaced one verb: the Executive Council would no longer “elect” the Director General but “appoint” that officer. Read alone, the change sounds like a transfer of power. APNIC's own supporting paper says the opposite. The selector was already the…
Story
One Source IP Accounted for 38.76% of APNIC's WHOIS Queries in an Hour
One Source IP Accounted for 38.76% of APNIC's WHOIS Queries in an Hour intelligence summary explains the development, the public evidence available to readers, the organisations involved, the regional context, market exposure, and the infrastructure consequences that may follow.…
Story
APNIC’s NRO Ballot Has Two Electorates. Its Result Needs the Mix
At 14:00 in Brisbane on 27 August, APNIC opened one electronic ballot for one regional seat on the NRO Number Council. It did not open that ballot to one electorate. Member organizations and qualified conference regulars enter through different doors, vote on different clocks and…
Story
APNIC's Leadership Consultation Needs a Participation Receipt
APNIC has designed a careful consultation on barriers to community leadership: three online listening sessions, a mailing list, a hybrid conference session and de-identified reporting. That protects candour, but it also removes the visible trail by which readers could judge…
Story
APNIC's First EC Preview Needs a Decision Crosswalk
APNIC's Executive Council Chair has opened a useful new window before the Council meets. The first preview names what the EC expects to examine in September and promises a companion account afterwards. That is better than learning every priority from minutes a month later. But…
Story
APNIC Prop-173 Would Put Copyright in Every Query. It Still Needs a Rights Ledger
An RDAP answer can carry a copyright notice in the same envelope as an address range, a registration date and a holder-supplied contact. That does not make every element the same kind of legal entity. APNIC’s prop-173 correctly identifies that ordinary directory queries lack the…
Story
The 27 August Redline: Reading APNIC’s prop-165 Through Its Assessment Delta
APNIC’s canonical `prop-165` record now points to `prop-165-v004`, published on 27 August 2026, while the Secretariat analysis displayed on that record is expressly introduced as applying to version 3. With the APNIC 62 Open Policy Meeting scheduled for 10 September 2026, the…
Story
APNIC’s Service-Term Delegation Has No Public Classification Receipt
APNIC’s Executive Council gave the Secretariat room to change service terms without turning routine administration into policy making. The delegation is sensible and expressly bounded. What the public record lacks is the small entity that would let a later reader test the…