AFRINIC · RIR Watchdog
Story
BTW reporting and context linked to this RIR. For the proposal-by-proposal history, the people involved and their changing positions, start with Policy.
Story
Latest stories
1,192Stories
Story
AFRINIC named six bylaw reviewers—but not the members they represent
AFRINIC says its Board, acting with the Receiver’s consent, selected one person from each of six sub-regions for a committee that would filter public input and draft bylaw changes. The invitation had been limited to representatives of Resource Members. Yet the 2 March appointment…
Story
The Mandate in the Margin: What AFRINIC-13 Actually Agreed on Soft Landing
On 25 November 2010, AFRINIC’s public-policy meeting did not approve a finished Soft Landing policy. It agreed to move an identifiable proposal to Last Call while assigning three changes to be incorporated afterward and deliberately leaving a disputed /27 minimum unchanged. That…
Story
The Notice Was Part of the Soft Landing Decision
The decisive entity in June 2010 was not only a proposal about scarce IPv4 space. It was the notice that told people which proposal they were being asked to examine. By carrying a complete draft into a dated review window, then allowing corrections and objections to change the…
Story
AFRINIC changed Soft Landing's reference and left the redline to readers
On 12 May 2010, a materially revised scarcity proposal acquired a new documentary identity in AFRINIC's later history, but the message that carried the text did not carry the identifier. That mismatch shows both the value of version numbers and their limit: metadata can locate a…
Story
The rulebook that audited itself: what GEN-004 admitted about AFRINIC’s 2008 PDP
AFRINIC’s 2010 replacement policy did more than propose new procedure. It recorded the faults of the procedure it was meant to replace—and a later implementation note revealed how much discretion survived the repair.
Story
The text that consensus had not yet finished: AFRINIC-12 and Soft Landing
In Kigali, the decisive word was not simply “consensus” but the qualification that followed it: the IPv4 Soft Landing proposal had consensus with modifications. That formulation moved the proposal forward while leaving consequential language to be settled after the room had…
Story
AFRINIC called the ASN amendment implemented before it became global policy
AFRINIC called the ASN amendment implemented before it became global policy intelligence summary explains the development, the public evidence available to readers, the organisations involved, the regional context, market exposure, and the infrastructure consequences that may…
Story
AFRINIC’s docket shows a live policy challenge—not a court-validated ratification
AFRINIC’s public case list separates three Skyconnect proceedings: a 9 March plaint challenging the Board’s ratification of the inter-RIR transfer policy, an interim-order application marked declined and not served, and an appeal filed on 7 April. All three entries are labelled…
Story
AFRINIC's 2009 accounts showed only USD 14,157 of surplus after a foreign-exchange loss
AFRINIC's registry services produced a positive operating result in 2009, yet almost nine tenths of it disappeared through the net effect of foreign exchange and interest. The arithmetic is unusually clear; the authority and treasury trail behind it is not.
Story
AFRINIC-11 sent Soft Landing back a second time
On 27 November 2009 in Dakar, a substantially revised IPv4 Soft Landing proposal failed to reach consensus for the second public meeting, leaving evidence consistent with a dispute that had moved beyond drafting detail to the limits of what a private registry should decide when…
Story
AFRINIC-11's ASN consensus met its real test in compatibility
AFRINIC-11's ASN consensus met its real test in compatibility intelligence summary explains the development, the public evidence available to readers, the organisations involved, the regional context, market exposure, and the infrastructure consequences that may follow. The Story…
Story
After the Withdrawal: AFRINIC-11 and the Missing Fiscal Handoff Ledger
In Dakar, a technical policy proposal was withdrawn and its affordability problem was handed to an author, staff and a private Board; the enduring question is not whether that boundary was sensible, but whether the alternative ever became visible enough to audit.
Story
AFRINIC-10's 59% mailing-list finding—and the participation it could not prove
At AFRINIC-10 in Cairo, a small survey finding exposed a large governance problem: opening a channel is not the same as carrying people across it. The meeting report said 59 percent were subscribed to an unspecified AFRINIC mailing list, but supplied neither the item count nor…
Story
AFRINIC published a 106-34 vote—but not the electorate behind the extra year
Both candidates won AFRINIC’s two community seats on the NRO NC / ASO AC without opposition. A separate vote then gave Musa Stephen Honlue a term through 2029 and Nitin Kelawon Sookun a term through 2028. AFRINIC’s meeting minutes disclose the 106-34 tally and a five-to-two…
Story
Seventeen Proxies and the Chain AFRINIC-10 Did Not Show
At Cairo’s AFRINIC-10 meeting, a called bundle of seventeen proxy votes plus one associated vote was counted, questioned and counted again. The surviving record confirms that signed proxies carried real ballot weight on 21 May 2009, but it does not let an outside reader…
Story
The AFRINIC-10 election committee promised a process-review report after ballot disputes
AFRINIC’s own account of its May 2009 meeting records a specific promise: gather the election criticisms, report them to the Board and return appropriate recommendations to the community. The enduring governance question is not whether later election work occurred, but whether…
Story
The AFRINIC-10 election used green, double-stamped ballots as its authenticity control
On 21 May 2009, the AFRINIC-10 election committee gave voters a test they could perform with their own eyes: a valid ballot was green and bore an AFRINIC stamp on both its front and its back. That modest paper rule matters because it reveals both the value and the limit of…
Story
The Rule AFRINIC Had Not Changed
At AFRINIC's 21 May 2009 meeting, a dispute over whether a candidate could vote became a precise test of institutional authority: a new bylaw could empower the Board to change an election regulation, counsel said, but neither expectation nor practice could perform the Board's…
Story
AFRINIC-10's useful survey—and the denominator that limits its claims
AFRINIC's post-meeting report preserved something more valuable than an uncomplicated satisfaction story: enough arithmetic to show both what 42 respondents could teach the registry and what they could never authorise on behalf of 135 event entities, a membership, or a continent.
Story
AFRINIC called for two policy chairs, appointed one and left the consensus record incomplete
AFRINIC’s Board-approved 2026 rules opened two staggered PDWG co-chair seats. The meeting record says two people applied, one was found eligible, one was accepted by a show of hands for a two-year term and the second seat was put off until November. The same public packet does…