Summary
- In ARIN's 2024 and 2025 annual reports the message headed "From the President and Board", signed by John Curran and that year's board chair, states no billings total and no member count; both quantities are printed by staff departments elsewhere in the same documents.
- The instrument carrying his personal attestation as signing officer is the IRS Form 990, which ARIN does not publish and supplies only on request, while board minutes record the forms being accepted and "the President" directed to file them.
A letter that commits to a characterisation, not a figure
The 2024 message opens "To our valued community," and begins: "2024 was a year of growth, engagement, and steady progress for ARIN." It closes "Together, we look forward to advancing our mission-driven journey in 2025 and beyond." Under "Warm regards" sit two names: John Curran, President and CEO, ARIN; Bill Sandiford, Chair, ARIN Board of Trustees (2024 annual report).
The next year's message opens "To the ARIN community," calls 2025 "a year of technical evolution and community engagement," and sorts its milestones under four headings: Advancing Technical Excellence; Governance and Community Engagement; Expanded Education and Outreach; Our Commitment to You. It is signed John Curran, President and CEO, ARIN, and Nancy E. Carter, Chair, ARIN Board of Trustees (2025 annual report).
Both quotations are provider-reported excerpts of extracted text, read on 21 November 2026. Neither page was inspected as a typeset page.
Two chairs, two years, one unchanged presidential signature, and not one dollar figure or member count inside either letter. The billings line lives in a staff section instead: "The Financial Services Department (FSD) prepared 32,200 invoices in 2024, with total billings at US$29.5 million." For 2025 the same section reports 33,200 invoices and total billings of US$31.8 million. The membership counts sit on their own page, dated "All statistics are as of 31 December 2024" for 24,356 Service Members and 1,663 General Members, and as of 31 December 2025 for 25,085 Service and 1,472 General.
Some arithmetic of my own, from printed figures in matching units, labelled as mine and not ARIN's: Service Members rise by 729 between the two year-end counts, General Members fall by 191, and the two categories summed give 26,019 and then 26,557, a difference of 538. ARIN prints the two category totals separately and, on the pages read, no combined total, so 26,019 and 26,557 are my sums and not an ARIN membership figure. No reviewed document attributes a cause to the shift between categories.
The audited page is signed by somebody else
The FY2024 financial statements carry an independent auditor's report from CliftonLarsonAllen LLP of Arlington, Virginia, dated 13 August 2025 and addressed to the Board of Trustees. The opinion reads, in part: the statements "present fairly, in all material respects, the financial position of ARIN as of December 31, 2024, and the changes in their net assets and their cash flows for the years then ended in accordance with accounting principles generally accepted in the United States of America" (audited statements).
The same document prints total revenue and support of $28,873,210, total operating expenses of $30,296,651, a change in net assets of $955,311 and year-end net assets of $26,270,583, against total assets of $45,236,043 and total liabilities of $18,965,460. That is the audit firm's signature, not the president's.
Set the two vocabularies side by side. The report says "total billings" of US$29.5 million for 2024. The audit says "total revenue and support" of $28,873,210 for the year ended 31 December 2024. They are different printed labels, and no page in the documents reviewed reconciles them. Naming that gap is not an accusation; it is the reason a reader cannot check the year from the letter alone.
The return is a request away
ARIN's own 990 page states the filing obligation and then does something a disclosure page rarely does: it asks you to write in for a PDF or hardcopy. The page does not post the return and does not display a signature page (ARIN's IRS 990 page).
What the board record shows is authority, not attestation. On 13-14 August 2025 the trustees, on the Finance Committee's recommendation and having reviewed the 2024 IRS Form 990 and 990T, accepted the forms and directed the President to file them (2025 minutes). On 18 August 2026 the same body accepted the 2025 return and 990T "as amended" and directed the President to file them, and accepted the 2025 auditors report and 2025 audited financial statement (2026 minutes). John Curran is listed as President & CEO on both pages.
A third-party extraction of IRS e-file data lists him as signing officer of the FY2024 return, filed 21 August 2025, with Form 990 revenue of $29,435,380 and gross receipts of $39,420,598 (extracted return data). That page describes the return. It is not the return, and the signed signature page was not obtained for either year — so the strongest claim available here is that the filing record names him, and that the attestation itself stayed out of reach.
An aggregator's display of FY2025 extracted data — revenue $31,661,623, expenses $31,941,906, net income -$280,283, net assets $27,907,553 — is not the return either, and its revenue line is not the annual report's "total billings" (aggregated filing data). Neither number may be substituted for the other.
Four dates, four instruments, no merging
7 April 2026: ARIN announced the 2025 report as available and said the 2025 Auditor's Report would be posted once it became available (announcement). 13 August 2025: the auditor's report on FY2024. 21 August 2025: the FY2024 return's filing date, as extracted. 18 August 2026: board acceptance of the FY2025 audit and the amended FY2025 return. Stacked in that order, the report describing 2025 reached the public before the board accepted the audit of 2025 — a sequence a member can check in four clicks.
The index page frames the genre plainly: after each fiscal year, ARIN staff compiles and publishes an annual report, with auditor's reports sometimes published separately (annual reports index). Staff compile; the president signs the covering letter; the board accepts the return; the return goes out on request.
The stop, stated once
These PDFs were not opened as typeset pages. They were read as extracted text on 21 November 2026, because direct opening was blocked as oversized. One further observation about the 2025 file, offered as an observation and nothing more: its search metadata and one extracted heading read "ANNUAL REPORT 2024", while the cover and running line read 2025. That is an inconsistency inside the file, not evidence of intent and not a verified typographic error.
Not obtained: the signed return for either fiscal year, the FY2025 audited statements in readable form, and any printed page reconciling billings with revenue. Those three absences bound every claim above. The figures themselves are not in dispute anywhere in this piece.
What an officer's signature can and cannot do
The signature is real, joint, and it survived a change of board chair. It binds the signatories to a characterisation of the year: growth and steady progress, technical evolution and community engagement. It does not bind them to a number, and the number a member can actually test is printed by staff on a later page under a different label.
So the accountability question is not whether ARIN's figures are right. It is which instrument a member must hold to check them: the narrative report that carries the officer's name, the audit that carries the firm's name, and the return that carries the officer's attestation. Two of the three are one click away. The one that most directly attaches a person to a fiscal year is the one you have to ask for.
Member Briefing
Read the full trend briefing
Members read the full briefing with the source notes behind every finding.
Strategic Circle
A daily briefing in your language, built from changes we have verified.
Join for USD 20/monthCancel anytime.
Members also get the full research library, a daily briefing on the networks they follow and the private forum.






