Summary

  • Anne Butler resigned as a director of CIRA effective 8 May 2026; the board's 4 May minutes appointed Graeme Bunton Vice-Chair "to complete the unexpired term of Anne Butler" and left the director seat vacant until the annual general meeting.
  • The members filled that seat as a one-year Replacement Seat, Bunton 415 to Darren Gallop's 414, under a ranking rule that fills expired seats first, and no document read records the board filling the director vacancy under its own by-law power.

The 4 May 2026 minute holds a resignation, an appointment and a refusal, and the refusal is the part worth reading twice. It records that "Anne Butler provided context in respect of her resignation as a director, effective May 8, 2026, at the request of her employer." It records a motion, moved by Gwen Beauchemin and seconded by Butler, appointing Graeme Bunton Vice-Chair of CIRA effective 8 May 2026 "to complete the unexpired term of Anne Butler, who has resigned from the position, and to hold office until the next Board meeting after the expiry of such term at which time a successor is appointed, or until earlier resignation or removal." The motion passed unanimously, with Bunton abstaining. And then the board decided that "the position would remain vacant until the upcoming Annual General Meeting, at which time an additional Director would be elected to complete the balance of the unexpired Board term" — asking management to draft revisions to the election policy and the 2026 rules to match (CIRA board minutes, 4 May 2026).

Two sentences, two different routes to the same unexpired term. The office was filled by resolution of the directors. The seat was left for the members.

Canadian law gives a not-for-profit corporation exactly that choice. Subsection 132(1) of the Canada Not-for-profit Corporations Act lets a quorum of directors fill a vacancy among the directors, except where the vacancy comes from an article-based increase in the number of directors or from a failure to elect the required number. Subsection 132(5) then says the by-laws may provide that a vacancy shall be filled only by a vote of the members, and subsection 132(6) caps whoever fills it at the predecessor's unexpired term (Act, s. 132). Election is the members' act: subsection 128(3) requires them to elect directors by ordinary resolution at each annual meeting at which an election is required, and subsection 128(4) permits those directors to hold terms of different lengths (Act, s. 128). A staggered board is lawful. What the statute will not do is decide, on the corporation's behalf, which organ fills a mid-term seat — it hands that decision to the by-law.

CIRA's by-law kept both doors. Section 3.01 composes the board of nine directors elected from a Nomination Committee slate and three elected from a Members' slate. Section 3.06(a) runs a director's term from election to the end of the third Election Period following it, and section 3.06(b) bars an election that would take a director past nine consecutive years. Section 3.08(a) is the vacancy rule: subject to the Act, a vacancy on the board "may be filled for the remainder of the term by, a qualified individual by ordinary resolution of the Directors" (By-law No. 1). That is the board-fill power, intact and unused for this seat. One document-form note, because it matters for anyone checking the wording: the by-law is published in an HTML rendering and as a PDF of the 8 December 2025 text, the PDF's extractable text stops partway through the document, so section 3.08(a) is quoted from the PDF and sections 3.01 and 3.06 from the HTML of the same text (PDF text).

Corporations Canada reads the same statute as setting a ceiling: directors are elected at annual meetings for terms that cannot exceed four years, citing subsection 128(3) and subsection 28(1) of the regulations (Corporations Canada guidance). That is guidance, and the regulation itself was not read in primary form for this piece; it matters only because CIRA's three-year term sits comfortably under a four-year cap, which leaves no external pressure behind the one-year remainder.

The by-law text in force here was itself board-made. CIRA states that its amendments were approved by the directors on 8 December 2025, took effect on that approval, and remain in effect unless the members fail to confirm them at the annual general meeting (CIRA notice on the amendments). The substantive change that notice describes is the removal of the Government Representative as a Board Advisor and from the Nomination Committee. Classes, terms and vacancies were not touched.

What the members were voting under in September 2026 was therefore the ordinary machinery, and it is worth quoting precisely. Section 5.02(b) of the Policy on Nominations and Elections defines an "Expired Seat" as a vacancy to be filled because an elected director's term has ended, and a "Replacement Seat" as one to be filled because an elected director resigned or was removed before the end of the term. Section 5.02(c)(i) then orders the filling: each Expired Seat goes to the Nomination Committee Candidates who received the most votes, and only afterwards is each Replacement Seat — the one with the most years left first — filled by the candidate with the next highest plurality (Policy on Nominations and Elections).

The 2026 result is a table, and the table is the argument. 862 members voted. On the Nomination Committee slate, Nancy Carter took 498, Angela LeBreton 477, Rob Villeneuve 457, and Bunton 415, marked as elected to the replacement seat; Darren Gallop took 414 and Michael Zahra 267. On the Members' slate, Gwen Beauchemin was elected with 183 against Dana Sanderson's 182, Daria Batkin's 165, Caleb Ogundele's 164 and Graham Sucha's 99. The page states that every director elected serves a three-year term except the replacement seat, which carries one year (CIRA 2026 election results).

So the remainder was not contested for its own sake. Under the ranking rule the members were ordering a queue, and the queue's fourth name was handed the one-year term. The distance between the last elected candidate and the first unelected one on that slate was a single vote — a fact about how close the ordering was, not a verdict on the strength of anyone's mandate.

Now the part that should interest anyone who reads a registry as an institution rather than as a domain-name shop. The result page describes the seat it filled as "the remainder of a resigning board member's term" and does not name the director. The 4 May minutes name Butler and her office and say the annual general meeting would elect a director "to complete the balance of the unexpired Board term", but they do not print the term's end date. A letter to the Nomination Committee dated 5 May 2026 records the board accepting the resignation of "a Director elected from the Nomination Committee slate in 2024, with one year remaining in their current term" (letter to the Nomination Committee). Read together, those three documents identify the seat; none of them says it alone. The only 2026 director resignation in the record is Butler's, and the one-year term the members filled matches the year the letter describes — an inference from the documents, and one the documents support without stating.

The page a member is most likely to open is the one that says least. "Meet the Board" lists the directors with their officer and committee roles; as displayed on 18 November 2026 it carried no seat class and no term start or end date against any name (Meet the Board). The Annual General Meeting page still announces the 23 September 2026 meeting in the future tense (CIRA AGM). The operator's own directory entry tracks the entity; the governance record lives in the instruments above.

What the documents read on 18 November 2026 do not contain is just as clean: no board resolution, minute paragraph or consent item filling the director vacancy itself under section 3.08(a); no by-law provision or member resolution recorded under section 132(5) reserving vacancy-filling to a members' vote; no printed end date for the unexpired term; no recount request, candidate challenge or member objection to the Replacement Seat classification; and no record of whether the members confirmed the December 2025 by-law text at the September meeting.

Here is the finding, and it is about the shape of the record rather than anyone's conduct. CIRA held two instruments that could move one unexpired term and used both, on two different objects: a board resolution that carried the Vice-Chair office to Bunton, and a member ballot that carried the seat. Each is documented. The office's authority runs through the directors' vote; the seat's runs through the members'.

A member who wants to know which one put a given person in a given chair has to reconcile a minute, a results table, a committee letter and an officer list, and the one page that lists the board cannot tell them apart. That is a traceability gap, and traceability is the whole point of a membership registry that asks its members to elect a third of its board.

One consequence is already scheduled. A one-year term ends, the rotation resumes, and the seat returns to the ordinary machinery — the traceability question closes by itself in 2027. The durable item is the one the 4 May minutes set in motion: management was asked to propose revisions to the policy and the 2026 rules to reflect the decision to leave the vacancy open. Whether those revisions preserve the split between office and seat, or end it, is the next thing the record will show.