Summary

  • ARIN's 2026 fee schedule prints eleven annual Registration Services Plan prices, from $275 to $282,240, under a note capping annual increases at 5 per cent; the schedule adopted 19 April 2026 and effective 1 January 2027 prints every one of those eleven categories exactly 5 per cent higher.
  • The balanced-budget-by-2030 target appears in ARIN's ARIN 57 and ARIN 58 financial reports, its 2025 annual report and its board minutes, but no document reviewed here prints the Registration Services Plan revenue base, the mix of customers across those eleven categories, or a revenue projection for 2027 through 2030.

The one part of the promise an invoice can settle

Start with the price list, because it is the only piece of this arithmetic ARIN publishes in full. The 2026 fee schedule prints eleven annual Registration Services Plan fees under the heading "RSP Service Categories and Fees", from 3X-Small at $275 to 5X-Large at $282,240, and attaches a note that each annual fee "is subject to an annual increase (as approved by the ARIN Board of Trustees) of no greater than 5%." A member who knows their own category can therefore settle one question without help: what a full five per cent would add to their own bill.

The 2027 schedule answers the next question mechanically. The schedule effective 1 January 2027 states that the Board adopted it on 19 April 2026, and every category sits exactly five per cent above the 2026 column: $275 becomes $288.75, $1,100 becomes $1,155, and $282,240 becomes $296,352. That multiplication is mine, not ARIN's — the 2027 page prints the prices and never prints the percentage. Neither page attaches "5%" to a year by itself. The year attached to 5% is in ARIN's 12 May 2025 announcement, which records that at its 27 April 2025 meeting the Board "approved a 5 percent increase to RSP fees for 2026."

So the ceiling has been used at the ceiling, twice, in the two years ARIN has priced in public. That is not a scandal. It is the part of the plan a member can check to the cent, and it deserves to be said plainly before the part that cannot be checked.

Three printed numbers, none of them the base

Five per cent of what? ARIN prints several revenue measures and none of them is the quantity the sentence in Kilmer's report acts on.

The 2026 approved budget carries a "Registration maintenance fees" line of 29,950 thousand dollars against total revenue and support of 32,627 thousand, with U.S. GAAP columns of 29,640 and 32,702 thousand. The audited statements for the year ended 31 December 2024 print "Renewal Registration Fees" of $25,828,477 against total revenue and support of $28,873,210, and the accompanying note defines registration maintenance fees as revenue from Resource Services Plan customers and End User customers. The 2025 annual report adds a third measure in a third unit: 33,200 invoices prepared in 2025, with "total billings at US$31.8 million."

Budget, audited result and billings are three different things for three different periods, and the audited line openly spans two customer classes. None is labelled Registration Services Plan revenue. None can be multiplied by 1.05 to produce a dollar answer that means anything, because the yield of a uniform percentage depends on how many customers stand in each of the eleven categories — and that distribution is not printed either. The spread is not decorative: in 2026 the largest category is $282,240 and the smallest is $275, about 1,026 times apart. A registry whose fees ran on a single flat rate would make five per cent a single number.

ARIN's does not.

What the boardroom was shown, and in whose voice

ARIN does state the destination, and it states it in more places than one deck. The ARIN 57 financial report prints a page headed "Long-term Financial Plan" with the line "Achieve a balanced budget by year 2030" and the mechanism spelled out: "By exercising annual Registration Services Plan price increases of up to 5%, and managing year-over-year spending, ARIN anticipates achieving a balanced budget in year 2030."

The minutes of 19 April 2026 are where the model gets numbers and a voice. The CFO presented the long-term model, "which has spending increasing annually at 4% and with an RSP fee increase of 5% each year until 2030", with the gap drawn from reserves until balance. The same minutes record the only fee motion quoted in the documents reviewed here, and it is narrower than the plan: "The ARIN Board of Trustees approves an increase in the registry services fee by 5% for 2027 as recommended by the ARIN Finance Committee." That motion passed, 10-0 by roll call.

Read the two paragraphs together and the shape of the disclosure appears. The arithmetic that reaches 2030 is a staff model, described by the CFO and routed through the Finance Committee. The vote that exists is a single year's increase. The minutes of 21 October 2026 add a status rather than a table: a deficit still being filled from investments, and a statement that ARIN "is on track to reach our goal of a balanced budget by 2030" — in a passage that does not name the person speaking. The 2025 annual report calls the same thing "the Board of Trustees strategy". Four ARIN documents describe the destination. A standalone long-term financial plan, a multi-year projection outside board exhibits, and a resolution expressly adopting the 2030 target were each not obtained in this review.

Which brings the Treasurer back in. The ARIN 58 financial report is attributed on its face to "Hank Kilmer, Treasurer, ARIN Board of Trustees", and the deck's slide text was not available in readable form for this review, so the plan wording quoted above comes from the ARIN 57 deck, which prints the same page. What ARIN does put in readable prose is its own recap of 23 October 2026: "Hank also outlined ARIN's long-term financial plan, which aims to achieve a balanced budget by 2030 through annual Registration Services Plan price increases of up to 5 percent and careful management of year-over-year spending." That is the institution describing its treasurer's presentation, not a transcript of his words, and it is the strongest first-party link between the man, the date and the mechanism.

What a member can still check

A finance officer who tells members the plan is a rate plus a year has told them the truth and left them the hard part. On your own invoice you can verify the lever tonight: multiply your category fee by 1.05, compare it with the 2027 schedule, and you have your own dollar increase to the cent. That is real accountability, and it is more than most fee schedules offer.

The destination is a different document class, and it does not exist in public. To check whether five per cent a year reaches balance in 2030, a reader needs the aggregate Registration Services Plan revenue, the customer count in each category, the expense path behind that 4 per cent assumption, and the reserve draw that fills the gap in the meantime. ARIN prints the first three nowhere in the documents reviewed here, and prints the reserve draw as a phrase.

Compounding the published ceiling on the published prices — my arithmetic again — would lift the smallest fee from $275 to about $334.26 and the largest from $282,240 to about $343,064.48 by 2030, which tells you what the lever does to a price and nothing about whether it closes the gap.

ARIN publishes the policy and votes the years. The arithmetic that connects them stays in the room.