Summary
- ICANN's Bylaws give the Address Supporting Organization the nomination of Board Seats 9 and 10, and give the Empowered Community the designation. In August 2026 those were two separately signed letters three days apart.
- The regular Seat 9 cycle now open closes nominations on 15 December 2026 at 23:59 UTC, and the charter's own diversity rule already bars candidates from the RIPE NCC region while the Seat 10 director comes from Europe.
Two verbs, two bodies, one seat
The consolidated Bylaws page on ICANN's site carries the line "As amended 3 July 2026", and its contents list runs Article 6 Empowered Community, Article 7 Board of Directors, Article 8 Nominating Committee, Article 9 Address Supporting Organization (ICANN Bylaws). Start there and you will not get far: the page as retrieved on 20 November 2026 stops inside Article 1. Nothing from Article 7 or Article 9 was read off that page in this review. That matters up front, because who fills Seats 9 and 10 turns on sentences inside those two articles.
What the review did obtain is narrower and sharper. ICANN's own hosted text of the proposed Article 7 and Article 8 amendments from April 2023 prints Section 7.2(a)(ii): "Two Directors nominated by the ASO to be designated as Directors by the EC. These seats on the Board are referred to in these Bylaws as Seat 9 and Seat 10" (proposed Bylaws amendments, April 2023). The same subsection calls the Empowered Community "the sole designator of ICANN". ASO Address Council minutes of 15 May 2019 quote the operative sentence of Section 9.2(b): "The Address Council shall nominate individuals to fill Seats 9 and 10 on the Board" (ASO AC minutes, 15 May 2019).
Nominate. Designate. Two verbs, two bodies, one seat.
The rest of the charter uses the pair consistently. An ICANN/ccNSO call for nominations published 22 July 2026 reproduces Section 7.2(c), which speaks of Supporting Organizations and the At-Large Community "carrying out their responsibilities to nominate Directors for Seats 9 through 15 for designation by the EC", and then sets a limit nobody in the address community enjoys: "The Supporting Organizations shall ensure that, at any given time, no two Directors nominated by a Supporting Organization are citizens from the same country or of countries located in the same Geographic Region" (Seat 12 call, 22 July 2026).
For an ordinary term, Section 7.8(d) sets the clock and names the signatory: at least six months before the term begins, the nominating Supporting Organization gives the EC Administration written notice of its nomination, with copies to the Secretary and the Decisional Participants, and "the EC Administration shall promptly provide the Secretary (with a copy to the Decisional Participants) with written notice of the designation of those Directors", with all notices posted promptly (EC Administration notice, 12 May 2025).
August 2026, in three documents and two dates
The vacancy began with a death. ICANN's Secretary recorded on 29 May 2026 that Alan Barrett had served in Seat 9 since October 2021 and was reappointed to a second term in 2024, that he died on 28 May 2026, and that the vacancy "shall be filled by the Empowered Community, after nomination by the Address Supporting Organization"; the same notice quotes Section 7.12(a), under which vacancies in Seats 1 through 15 "shall be filled by the EC after nomination" (Secretary's notice, 29 May 2026).
Then the two halves arrived separately. On 18 August 2026 the ASO Address Council Chair wrote to the Empowered Community Administration: "Pursuant to Sections 7.12(a) and 9.2(b) of the ICANN Bylaws, the ASO AC hereby formally nominates Mr. Oscar Robles (LAC Region) to fill the vacancy in Seat 9 of the ICANN Board", asking the Empowered Community to act under Sections 7.2(e) and 7.25 (ASO nomination letter, 18 August 2026). Three days later, on 21 August 2026, the Empowered Community Administration wrote to General Counsel and Secretary John Jeffrey that, "pursuant to Section 7.12 of the ICANN Bylaws, and in accordance with a notice received from the Address Supporting Organization (ASO) Address Council under Section 7.12(a)", it "hereby designates Oscar Robles to sit on Seat 9 of the ICANN Board for the remainder of the unexpired term of his predecessor through the conclusion of the ICANN90 Annual General Meeting on 4 November 2027" (ECA designation letter, 21 August 2026). The designation is signed for all five Decisional Participants: the ASO, ALAC, the ccNSO, the GNSO and the GAC.
That is the mechanism in miniature. The body the community calls the appointer builds a slate and votes. Its chair signs a nomination. A five-signatory administration, on which the ASO holds one voice, signs the appointment.
The paperwork does not line up perfectly, and the mismatch is worth printing rather than tidying. The ASO's own account of the vacancy attaches the formal designation to 18 August 2026 — the date of its own nomination letter — while the designation letter itself is dated 21 August (ASO chronology of the 2026 vacancy). The two letters also cite different provisions for the same step: the ASO asks the Empowered Community to act under Sections 7.2(e) and 7.25; the Administration designates under Sections 7.12 and 7.12(a). Neither letter reproduces the text of Section 7.2(e).
What the vacancy route left out
The ASO Address Council did not run a general selection. Its chronology records that at a 1 July 2026 teleconference it decided by majority vote to use the extraordinary procedure in Section 9.5.3, titled "Selection from Address Council Nominations"; that the extraordinary process included no public call for nominations and no public comment period; that the slate was confirmed on 24 July, electronic voting opened on 8 August, selection and due diligence were completed on 15 August, and the result was announced on 25 August 2026 — the same page that attaches the designation to 18 August. It also notes Section 7.8(e): service from filling a vacancy is not counted as a term against the three-consecutive-term limit (ASO chronology).
Whether the Address Council had any discretion over that omission turns on Section 9.5, which this review did not obtain; the absence is a record of the route taken, not a finding about the result.
The Address Council's own procedures explain both routes. "Under Sections 7.2 and 9.2 of the ICANN Bylaws," they state, "the ASO is responsible for selecting persons to fill seats 9 and 10 of the ICANN Board." A regular cycle runs nomination, comment, interview and selection; the nomination phase lasts at least 60 days and anyone may nominate any person; a five-member Qualification Review Committee, with no more than two members from the same region, builds the slate; the selection phase lasts at least 14 days and the Address Council meets, evaluates and votes; the result is announced only after ICANN completes due diligence without significant concerns; and candidates must meet the Bylaws' criteria, clear conflict-of-interest requirements and sign a Certification Letter. Where a seat falls vacant mid-term, the Address Council goes to one of the extraordinary procedures in Section 9.5, chosen by majority vote, and the selected person serves the remainder (ASO AC Board selection procedures). That page carries "Last modified on 04/12/2023" and no single adoption date for the document as a whole.
Note the verb drift. The charter sentence says the Address Council "shall nominate". The procedure says the ASO is responsible for "selecting". Both are accurate about different halves of one process, and the difference is exactly where readers get lost.
The deadline that actually bites
On 15 September 2026 the ASO opened the next regular three-year Seat 9 term, beginning at the conclusion of the ICANN Annual Meeting in 2027, expected in November 2027. Its own words keep the two halves apart: "The person selected by the ASO AC will be nominated for designation by the ICANN Empowered Community." The call also applies Section 7.2(c) to the field: because the Seat 10 director comes from the Europe Geographic Region, the Address Council cannot consider a Seat 9 candidate whose nomination country sits in the RIPE NCC Geographic Region (ASO call for nominations, 15 September 2026).
Then the dates, which are described as proposed and may be adjusted: nominations close 15 December 2026 at 23:59 UTC; public comment runs 16 December 2026 to 14 March 2027; interviews 15 January to 14 March 2027; deliberation 15 March to 29 April 2027; voting 30 April to 7 May 2027; announcement expected around 15 May 2027. Two seats on the Board are not two free choices, and the door that closes first is in December.
What this review did not obtain
The consolidated Bylaws page was retrieved twice and truncated both times inside Article 1, so Sections 7.2, 7.2(e), 7.8(d), 7.12(a) and 9.2(b) are used here only as reproduced by the instruments listed against each. Sections 7.2(a) and 7.2(a)(ii) come from ICANN's April 2023 public-comment draft, which is evidence of the drafting of the seat assignment, not a certified copy of the compilation amended 3 July 2026. Section 9.2(b) was obtained only as its first sentence, quoted inside 2019 minutes. The text of Section 7.2(e) and of Section 9.5 was not obtained in this review.
No NRO Executive Council record, Address Council voting tally, nomination count or dissent record for August 2026 was obtained, and the Address Council minutes of 1 July, 24 July and 15 August 2026 were not read — the ASO chronology is the summary of those steps.
Why the distinction pays rent
A community that believes it appoints two directors will spend its energy in the wrong room. The Address Council builds the slate and casts the vote; the nomination belongs to the Council itself, and its chair signs the letter on the Council's behalf; the Empowered Community Administration signs the designation, and it is one signature block shared with four other communities. Anyone who wants a different director for Seat 9 either gets into the slate before 15 December 2026 or persuades the Address Council, which holds the nomination.
Between those two moments the charter hands the pen to five representatives, and the ASO holds one of them.
That is a channel with a clear start and a shared finish: legible, and narrower than its reputation. The September call's plain language — selected, then nominated for designation — is the most honest summary the address community has published of its own position. Read alongside the two August letters, it says the same thing the Bylaws do, in three different voices.
The directory entry for this selection is ICANN Board Seat 9 and 10 Selection.
Member Briefing
Read the full trend briefing
Members read the full briefing with the source notes behind every finding.
Strategic Circle
A daily briefing in your language, built from changes we have verified.
Join for USD 20/monthCancel anytime.
Members also get the full research library, a daily briefing on the networks they follow and the private forum.






