Summary

  • On 14 October 2025 the ICANN Board appointed Thomas Barrett as 2026 Nominating Committee chair and James Gannon as chair-elect: twelve in favour, Chris Chapman and Tripti Sinha abstaining, the item taken in confidential session.
  • The Bylaws vest that appointment in the Board and impose no recommendation step on any named body; the committee's operating procedures require a published timeline and a fair evaluation, and no published reasons for declining to reselect a sitting director.

What the minutes print

The approved resolutions give the operative words: Resolved (2025.10.14.01), the Board appointed Thomas Barrett as the 2026 Nominating Committee Chair and James Gannon as the 2026 Nominating Committee Chair-Elect. The second resolution keeps specified items in the package confidential under Article 3, section 3.5(b) until the President and CEO or a designee releases them. The page was published on 16 October 2025 and records the item as an Organizational Administrative Function that does not require Public Comment.

The minutes add the machinery. A Special Meeting held telephonically on 14 October 2025 at 20:30 UTC, the appointment taken in confidential session, twelve members in favour, Chapman and Sinha abstaining, Catherine Adeya and Byron Holland unavailable, the resolutions carried. The minutes also state that Chapman provided a voting statement and that Sinha provided one.

That is a complete procedural record. It tells you who was appointed, by how many, and in what forum. It does not tell you why Chapman — a sitting director who had applied again — was not among the appointees, and it does not claim to.

What the rules owe

Article 8 of the Bylaws puts the Nominating Committee in its own article, and the adopted text is plain about the appointment: section 8.2 provides for '(a) A non-voting Chair, appointed by the Board' and '(b) A non-voting Chair-Elect, appointed by the Board as a non-voting advisor'. Section 8.3(c) fixes the term at the conclusion of the next annual meeting; section 8.3(d) anticipates the chair-elect's succession while reserving to the Board 'the discretion to appoint any other person to the position of Chair'.

Nothing in that text requires any body to recommend. The recommendation is a delegated function, and the Board says so itself: its rationale states that the Bylaws require the Board to appoint both officers, and that the Board 'has delegated the responsibility for recommending the NomCom Chair and Chair-Elect for Board approval to the Board Governance Committee' under BGC Charter, Section II.G. The charter text is known here only through that citation.

The process around the recommendation is documented in detail. ICANN's call for expressions of interest, published 15 April 2025, set a 13 May 2025 deadline, promised confidentiality for the submissions, and noted that an independent third-party provider interviews committee leadership and members to evaluate the sitting leadership before the recommendation is made. Board submission 2025.10.14.1a records the committee narrowing eight applicants to a shortlist for interview and weighing the members' evaluation of the 2025 leadership.

The Nominating Committee's own operating procedures are equally specific about inputs. Criteria come from the Bylaws, are refreshed each year in community consultation, a timeline with milestones must be posted, and candidates must be evaluated 'in a fair and consistent manner, considering the application, references and, as needed, interviews, consultations, and third-party information sources'. Continuing membership of the Board must be weighed. What the procedures do not contain, in the sections read, is any clause requiring a published reason when a sitting director is not reselected.

Two boundaries belong here rather than in a footnote. The consolidated Bylaws page is dated as amended 3 July 2026, but its Article 8 body did not render for this reading, so the wording above comes from a 15 September 2023 Secretary's notice reproducing the adopted article. And the committee's procedures page is undated in the text read, so no assertion is made about which version governed the 2025 cycle.

The question asked the day before

On 13 October 2025, at the ICANN84 preparatory session on the 2025 Nominating Committee, the question was put directly. A participant asked how the committee goes about not reappointing sitting Board directors, 'particularly when those Board directors may be in a position of leadership put there by the entire ICANN Board'. The transcript records chair Amir Qayyum answering that the committee is not a permanent constituency, that its leadership holds no vote, and that the delegates decide, assessing candidates against the Board's desired job description. Chair-elect Thomas Barrett added that 'The Board has the opportunity to provide additional feedback to the NomCom if there are reapplying candidates, and the delegates then consider that feedback along with all the other candidates who are applying.'

Both answers describe a structure. Neither names a person, states a reason, or points to a written statement of reasons. One day before the vote, the public record of the committee's reasoning about a sitting director was a description of the machine rather than an account of the decision.

The only signed account

On 14 October 2025 Chapman signed a Director Voting Statement addressed to the Chair of the Board and copied to the Board Governance Committee. The text below is as returned for that PDF; the direct read of the file reported no readable text, so pagination and letterhead are unverified.

He writes that he had told the Board at its Madrid workshop 'that I would be a dissenting voice if the BGC recommendation to appoint Tom Barrett as the ICANN Nominating Committee (NomCom) chair for 2026 was moved and passed'.

He records that he was the only person 'fired by NomCom by the issuing of its determinations following the completion of its 2025 processes', and quotes the committee chair's letter to him: a reference to 'the extraordinary contributions I had made to ICANN', advice that he would not proceed to the deep-dive stage 'as there were others better qualified', and the sentence that the committee's 'decisions are informed by evolving community needs and shifting priorities'.

His own assertion follows: that 'nowhere in any of the documents published by NomCom in calendar 2025 were these evolving community needs and shifting priorities mentioned, let alone explained; nor were they asked to be addressed in my Nomination form or raised with me in either of my two NomCom interviews'. He adds that the four lines of enquiry he asked the committee's recommending body to put were not put. And he explains the form his objection finally took: he abstained rather than dissenting formally because he judged there would be a grave perception of a conflict of interest.

That last sentence matters for how the document should be read. It is not a dissent. It is an abstention with a written explanation, which is the thinnest instrument a director can file and still be on the record.

What is not on file

Sinha abstained on the same resolutions and the minutes say she filed a statement too. That statement was not obtained, so nothing here characterises her reasons. The committee chair's letter to Chapman was not located as a public document; its wording is known only through the statement that quotes it. The 2025 committee published a Year in Review on 8 September 2025, which the announcement describes as setting out the criteria provided to the committee, its outreach and its preselection process — the report itself was not read, so whether it used or explained the language quoted back to Chapman is unestablished in either direction. His assertion of absence is reported as his assertion.

The 2025 committee's own record lists Qayyum as chair, Barrett as chair-elect and Vanda Scartezini as associate chair, and states that the committee 'is designed to function independently from the Board, the Supporting Organizations, and Advisory Committees'. It also announced ten leadership selections on 19 August 2025 after 106 completed applications between 14 January and 28 March 2025. None of that answers the question the Dublin participant asked.

What the gap costs

Assemble the chain and the shape is clear. The Bylaws give the appointment to the Board and name no recommending body. The Board has delegated the recommendation to a committee of its own members. The Nominating Committee owes the process fair inputs and a published timeline, and owes no one a published reason for declining to reselect a sitting director. The minutes then record the vote and stop.

Where the rule is silent, the record is silent, and authorship of the reasons defaults to the person removed. That is the finding, and it is about design rather than conduct. Nothing above shows a rule broken, an appointment improper, or a director's objection suppressed — Chapman's statement was accepted, filed and published on ICANN's own file system. What it shows is that the only signed explanation of a consequential reselection decision came from the losing candidate, because nobody else was obliged to write one.

Against that, the ordinary defence is real: candid evaluations of sitting directors are hard to publish without turning every non-reappointment into a trial, and confidentiality protects candidates who apply and fail. The answer is not to publish the file. It is to require a short, published account of the criteria applied to a sitting director who is not reselected — the standard the committee already sets for itself in every other part of the cycle.

BTW has followed nominating machinery before, including ARIN's gatekeepers and two earlier briefings on ICANN committee membership. None of them read this: a director's own abstention statement against a Board resolution, set beside a committee that answered the same question in public without reasons.

ICANN will seat the 2026 committee, take applications, and run the cycle again. When it next declines to reselect a sitting director, the only document explaining why will once more be written by the director rather than by the body that decided. For readers tracking who nominates a third of ICANN's board, that is the gap worth watching — and the one an appointment this consequential should close. The governance record is available in BTW's ICANN directory entry.