APNIC · RIR Watchdog
Start here for the proposal-by-proposal record: what changed, why it mattered, who argued for what, how positions evolved, what was decided, and where the evidence still has gaps.
Source facts
Who actually shaped the debate?
BTW Analysis
The verified record shows two labeled proposal versions, v001 and v002, followed by introduction on 2022-02-02 and acceptance on 2022-08-08. This establishes version evolution and a change in official status to accepted, but the supplied evidence does not reveal the substantive differences between the versions, implementation, or operational effects.
The substance of the debate cannot be determined from the supplied record. No proposal text, change log, discussion messages, participant stances, or stated incentives are included. The record supports only that the proposal underwent at least one version revision before its accepted outcome.
A formal outcome is documented, but the deliberative path is not: the proposal was accepted on 2022-08-08, while the participation dataset captured zero messages, zero discussion participants, zero active discussion days, zero stance participants, and zero stance transitions. These zero counts establish an empty observed discussion dataset, not that no public or meeting-based discussion occurred.
No meaningful concentration analysis is possible because zero messages and zero discussion participants were captured. The zero top-message shares, HHI, effective-participant count, and core-contributor counts reflect the absence of observed messages rather than broad or evenly distributed participation. The captured participant population consists of one formal actor and no discussion participants, but that actor's identity and role are unspecified.
The only visible institutional chokepoint is the formal decision that produced acceptance on 2022-08-08. The supplied facts do not identify the deciding body, consensus or voting procedure, criteria, intermediary review stages, or the role of the single formal actor. Consequently, the record cannot establish who controlled passage, whether revisions were required to pass, or whether any participant or institution exercised disproportionate gatekeeping power.
Referenced policy sections in the problem statement · The goals are referenced as Section 5.7 instead of Section 5.7.1.1, and the qualifying experimental-allocation requirements are referenced as Sections 5.7.2.1 or 5.7.2.2 instead of Section 5.7.2 generally.
Placement of the reserved-pool provision · The proposed insertion point changes from the end of Section 5.7.1.1 to Section 5.7.2 of the policy document.
-- We propose adding the following text to Section 5.7.2 of the policy documeSource facts ↗
Duration, purpose, and expiry of the reserved IPv4 pool · The /21 reservation is changed from five years from policy publication followed by availability for routine allocation and described as decaying, to five years from policy implementation for experimental allocation requests and described as expiring. The explicit statement that the space becomes available for routine allocation is removed.
- �A dedicated /21 IPv4 address space has been reserved under this policy for five years from the date of publication of the policy after which the address space will be available for routine allocation. This reservation will decay 5 years after the policy implementatiSource facts ↗
. �A dedicated /21 IPv4 address space has been reserved under this policy for five years from the date of implementation of this policy to use for Experimental allocation requests. This reservation will expire 5 years after the policy implementatiSource facts ↗
Section 5.7.5 fee terminology · A new amendment is added to replace “IP resource application fee” in Section 5.7.5 with “assessment of a Member’s annual fee”; the supplied old proposed-policy section contains only the reserved-pool amendment.
.� Additionally, we propose to alter Section 5.7.5 of the policy by replacing the words IP resource application fee with the words assessment of a Member�s annual fSource facts ↗
Partial
Earliest captured: Jun 1, 2001
Latest captured: Oct 9, 2026
