AFRINIC · RIR 观察
AFPUB-2019-GEN-006-DRAFT03
从这里开始,逐项查看提案记录:发生了哪些变化、为何重要、各方提出了什么主张、立场如何演变、最终作出了什么决定,以及证据仍存在哪些缺口。
来源事实
- 政策编号
- AFPUB-2019-GEN-006-DRAFT03
- RIR
- AFRINIC
- 官方状态
- Ratified
- 标准化状态
- 已接受
- 提出时间
- 2021年4月19日
- 最近来源更新
- 2026年11月7日
- 覆盖范围
- 部分
究竟是谁影响了这场辩论?
政策演变
Trust anchor named in the explanation · Draft 2 corrects the explanation of AFRINIC's bogon ROAs to name AFRINIC's TAL instead of APNIC's. This corrects the stated validation context; it does not direct AFRINIC to issue ROAs under APNIC's trust anchor.
来源事实 −
When AFRINIC issues a ROA with AS0 for unallocated address space under AFRINIC’s administration, BGP announcements covering this space will be marked as Invalid by networks doing RPKI based BGP Origin Validation using APNIC’s TAL.来源事实 ↗
来源事实 +
When AFRINIC issues a ROA with AS0 for unallocated address space under AFRINIC’s administration, BGP announcements covering this space will be marked as Invalid by networks doing RPKI based BGP Origin Validation using AFRINIC’s TAL.来源事实 ↗
Separate trust anchor option · Draft 2 adds the option of a distinct TAL for AS0 ROAs, allowing opt-in use and separate measurements, particularly during initial deployment. The choice and other operational details remain at AFRINIC's discretion. The requirement to remove AS0 ROAs before allocating covered resources remains unchanged.
来源事实 −
Address space can only be allocated once the ROA or ROAs with origin AS0 have been fully removed and are not visible in the repositories.来源事实 ↗
来源事实 +
The AS0 ROAs could be under a distinct Trust Anchor Locator (TAL), so it becomes an opt-in service and provides separate measurements, at least in the initial deployment phases. This and other operational details are left to the discretion of AFRINIC.来源事实 ↗
Staff interpretation of covered resources · The draft-2 snapshot adds a staff interpretation that unallocated and unassigned space includes available and reserved inventory, newly received IANA/PTI prefixes, and returned or reclaimed resources. This elaborates the existing coverage rule in a staff assessment; it is not a separate adopted policy clause.
来源事实 −
AFRINIC will create ROAs with origin AS0 for all the unallocated and unassigned address space (IPv4 and IPv6) for which it is the current administrator.来源事实 ↗
来源事实 +
unallocated and unassigned space here means available and reserved space as per the AFRINIC extended delegated stats file. New prefixes received from IANA/PTI would immediately have AS0 ROA's. Any prefixes returned by or reclaimed from members will also have AS0 ROAs来源事实 ↗
Staff assessment of ROA validity · New staff assessment text assumes a ten-year validity period unless proposal authors specify another period. The proposal itself continues to leave validity and revocation procedures to AFRINIC staff, and the assessment also asks for clarification. The ten-year assumption is not presented as a new binding policy duration.
来源事实 −
The process for ROA validity periods and release of ROAs before assignment/allocation by AFRINIC is left for AFRINIC staff to define in internal procedures.来源事实 ↗
来源事实 +
The validity period for these ROAs shall be 10 years (as it currently is for all ROAs) unless a specific validity period is specified by the policy proposal authors.来源事实 ↗
Staff deployment recommendation · The added staff assessment recommends a separate trust anchor and estimates implementation within six months of Last Call. These are the staff's historical recommendation and estimate, not evidence that deployment occurred.
来源事实 −
The process for ROA validity periods and release of ROAs before assignment/allocation by AFRINIC is left for AFRINIC staff to define in internal procedures.来源事实 ↗
来源事实 +
Impact on RPKI On the RPKI side, 3 options have been scoped notably, Use the existing AFRINIC RPKI Tree Additional Production certificate (0/0) for unallocated space only New Trust Anchor with a single Production Certificate AFRINIC recommends option C because it then becomes an opt-in service and does not pollute the current RPKI. Legal Assessment No comments 5.0 Implementation Timeline The policy can be implemented as written within 6 months from the Last Call.来源事实 ↗
Cross-registry context · The references change from APNIC consensus, a RIPE NCC proposal and intended submissions elsewhere to reported consensus in APNIC and LACNIC. This updates the proposal's historical context and does not establish any other registry's present policy.
来源事实 −
4.0 References An equivalent proposal has already reached consensus in APNIC (https:// www.apnic.net/community/policy/proposals/prop-132) )and has been proposed in RIPE NCC (https:// www.ripe.net/participate/policies/proposals/2019-08). )It is also in preparation for submission to the other RIRs.来源事实 ↗
来源事实 +
4.0 References An equivalent proposal has already reached consensus in APNIC and LACNIC.来源事实 ↗
Timing for reclaimed resources · Draft 3 adds an explicit condition that reclaimed resources enter the AS0 ROA coverage only at the end of the reclamation process. Draft 2 required coverage of all unallocated and unassigned resources without this explicit timing qualification. The separate-trust-anchor option and removal of ROAs before allocation remain.
Staff choice of deployment architecture · The draft-3 staff implementation section commits to a new separate trust anchor if the proposal reaches consensus and ratification; draft 2 only recommends that option among three alternatives. This is the documented implementation plan, not proof of an operational deployment.
来源事实 −
AFRINIC recommends option C because it then becomes an opt-in service and does not pollute the current RPKI.来源事实 ↗
来源事实 +
5.0 Implementation Should this proposal reaches consensus and is ratified, the implementation will be done on a new (separate) Trust Anchor so that it becomes an opt-in service and does not impact the current RPKI setup来源事实 ↗
Historical implementation estimate · The staff estimate changes from six months after Last Call to implementation by Q2 2022, linked in the surrounding text to the planned myafrinic v2 migration. These are historical planning statements; neither establishes the present deployment status or a new current deadline.
Staff clarification status · The draft-3 assessment records no clarification requests where draft 2 asks about the AS0 ROA validity period. Both assessments retain the ten-year assumption unless authors specify otherwise, so this change does not itself alter the duration.
Recorded proposal status · The draft-2 snapshot is marked Archived and the draft-3 snapshot Ratified. These are captured page labels, not proof of the date of ratification or implementation; draft 3's implementation table still describes the policy as awaiting implementation.
讨论时间线
公开讨论
[rpd] REPORT ON Appeal against the non-consensus determination on proposal AFPUB-2019-GEN-006-DRAFT02 (RPKI ROAs for Unallocated and Unassigned AFRINIC Address Space – Draft 2).
16 讨论消息 · 7 实体
来源事实 ↗公开讨论
[rpd] REPORT ON Appeal against the non-consensus determination on proposal AFPUB-2019-GEN-006-DRAFT02 (RPKI ROAs for Unallocated and Unassigned AFRINIC Address Space ? Draft 2).
6 讨论消息 · 5 实体
来源事实 ↗公开讨论
[rpd] REPORT ON Appeal against the non-consensus determination on proposal AFPUB-2019-GEN-006-DRAFT02 (RPKI ROAs for Unallocated and Unassigned AFRINIC Address Space ? Draft 2).
17 讨论消息 · 9 实体
来源事实 ↗公开讨论
[rpd] REPORT ON Appeal against the non-consensus determination on proposal AFPUB-2019-GEN-006-DRAFT02 (RPKI ROAs for Unallocated and Unassigned AFRINIC Address Space ? Draft 2).
2 讨论消息 · 2 实体
来源事实 ↗公开讨论
[rpd] [PDWG-Appeal] REPORT ON Appeal against the non-consensus determination on proposal AFPUB-2019-GEN-006-DRAFT02 (RPKI R
22 讨论消息 · 8 实体
来源事实 ↗
实体
加载中
来源与覆盖
公开讨论记录
- afrinic-rpd
- 最早收录
- 2004年8月4日
- 最近收录
- 2026年8月25日
- 最近刷新
- 2026年11月7日
- 覆盖范围
- 来源覆盖尚不完整。
- 加载中
- 11,100
- 已知缺口
- 0
- www.afrinic.net
- afrinic-africann
- 最早收录
- 2026年8月3日
- 最近收录
- 2026年11月3日
- 最近刷新
- 2026年11月7日
- 覆盖范围
- 来源覆盖尚不完整。
- 加载中
- 2,576
- 已知缺口
- 1
- afrinic-afripv6-discuss
- 最早收录
- 2015年8月17日
- 最近收录
- 2026年9月18日
- 最近刷新
- 2026年11月7日
- 覆盖范围
- 来源覆盖尚不完整。
- 加载中
- 2,538
- 已知缺口
- 0
- afrinic-announce
- 最早收录
- 2015年8月18日
- 最近收录
- 2026年9月18日
- 最近刷新
- 2026年11月7日
- 覆盖范围
- 来源覆盖尚不完整。
- 加载中
- 2,497
- 已知缺口
- 0
- afrinic-community-discuss
- 最早收录
- 2015年9月11日
- 最近收录
- 2019年12月29日
- 最近刷新
- 2026年11月7日
- 覆盖范围
- 来源覆盖尚不完整。
- 加载中
- 3,209
- 已知缺口
- 0
- afrinic-dbwg
- 最早收录
- 2016年9月9日
- 最近收录
- 2026年10月21日
- 最近刷新
- 2026年11月7日
- 覆盖范围
- 来源覆盖尚不完整。
- 加载中
- 704
- 已知缺口
- 0
- afrinic-dnssec-ops
- 最早收录
- 2015年8月18日
- 最近收录
- 2016年12月1日
- 最近刷新
- 2026年11月7日
- 覆盖范围
- 来源覆盖尚不完整。
- 加载中
- 307
- 已知缺口
- 0
- afrinic-icp2-review
- 最早收录
- 2025年4月10日
- 最近收录
- 2025年11月10日
- 最近刷新
- 2026年11月7日
- 覆盖范围
- 来源覆盖尚不完整。
- 加载中
- 0
- 已知缺口
- 0
- afrinic-measurement-wg
- 最早收录
- 2018年2月1日
- 最近收录
- 2024年11月22日
- 最近刷新
- 2026年11月7日
- 覆盖范围
- 来源覆盖尚不完整。
- 加载中
- 138
- 已知缺口
- 0
- afrinic-mira
- 最早收录
- 2020年11月17日
- 最近收录
- 2024年11月22日
- 最近刷新
- 2026年11月7日
- 覆盖范围
- 来源覆盖尚不完整。
- 加载中
- 0
- 已知缺口
- 0
- afrinic-ois-wg
- 最早收录
- 2021年9月9日
- 最近收录
- 2024年11月22日
- 最近刷新
- 2026年11月7日
- 覆盖范围
- 来源覆盖尚不完整。
- 加载中
- 0
- 已知缺口
- 0
- afrinic-rpki-discuss
- 最早收录
- 2016年1月15日
- 最近收录
- 2026年4月23日
- 最近刷新
- 2026年11月7日
- 覆盖范围
- 来源覆盖尚不完整。
- 加载中
- 154
- 已知缺口
- 0
覆盖范围
部分
最早收录: 2004年8月4日
最近收录: 2026年11月7日
新鲜度
已知缺口
- www.afrinic.net: 来源覆盖尚不完整。 · 尚未达到来源边界。
- www.afrinic.net: 来源覆盖尚不完整。 · 尚未达到来源边界。
- afrinic-rpd: 来源覆盖尚不完整。 · 尚未达到来源边界。
- www.afrinic.net: 来源覆盖尚不完整。 · 尚未达到来源边界。
- afrinic-africann: 来源覆盖尚不完整。 · 尚未达到来源边界。
- afrinic-afripv6-discuss: 来源覆盖尚不完整。 · 尚未达到来源边界。
- afrinic-announce: 来源覆盖尚不完整。 · 尚未达到来源边界。
- afrinic-community-discuss: 来源覆盖尚不完整。 · 尚未达到来源边界。
- afrinic-dbwg: 来源覆盖尚不完整。 · 尚未达到来源边界。
- afrinic-dnssec-ops: 来源覆盖尚不完整。 · 尚未达到来源边界。
- afrinic-measurement-wg: 来源覆盖尚不完整。 · 尚未达到来源边界。
- afrinic-rpki-discuss: 来源覆盖尚不完整。 · 尚未达到来源边界。
