AFPUB-2012-GEN-001-DRAFT-02

Regional Internet Registry Privacy | AFPUB-2012-GEN-002-DRAFT-02

评估: 一致 · Presenting a privacy draft and subsequently seeking AFRINIC's input are compatible actions. The follow-up reports an unanswered request; it does not withdraw the draft or replace its retention period.

条件: The supplied May draft specifies three months; it must not be confused with a later six-month text. · The report of no reply is the author's observation at that time, not a verified general finding about AFRINIC.

2012年5月5日

The retention period for Personal Identifiable Information is three months.

2012年5月16日

I asked AfriNIC for input about the above ( https://lists.afrinic.net/pipermail/rpd/2012/002136.html ). There has not been any reply.

IPv4 Soft Landing – bis (Alain Aina)

评估: 证据不足，无法评估一致性 · The author waits for analysis of the proposal and distinguishes allocation justification from users' connectivity. Personal addressing preferences and comments on past strategy do not establish a vote on Soft Landing-bis or a change in such a vote.

条件: The recollection of chairing an earlier soft-landing discussion is historical context, not a new position on that earlier policy.

2016年8月28日

I was waiting to read the analysis about the proposal to find the answers to the above questions.

Regional Internet Registry Privacy | AFPUB-2012-GEN-002-DRAFT-02 · IPv4 Soft Landing – bis (Alain Aina)

评估: 证据不足，无法评估一致性 · Limiting the collection and retention of personal information and preferring an ISP-assigned public address concern different mechanisms. These messages contain no express conflict, but do not support a strong cross-policy consistency judgment.

条件: A preference for public addressing does not itself endorse publishing personal information. · No complete substantive position on the Soft Landing-bis limits is stated.

2012年5月5日

The principle of data minimization has been adopted to limit the collection and/or transfer of Personal Identifiable Information (PII) to what is directly relevant and necessary for specified, explicit and legitimate purposes.

2016年8月28日

My preference is to have an IPv4 address assigned by my ISP.