ARIN · Veille des RIR
Commencez ici pour consulter l’historique, proposition par proposition : ce qui a changé, pourquoi cela comptait, qui a défendu quoi, comment les positions ont évolué, ce qui a été décidé et quelles lacunes subsistent dans les preuves.
Faits sourcés
Qui a réellement façonné le débat ?
Analyse BTW
The verified record shows one original version of ARIN-prop-353, introduced on 2026-08-02, with no later version recorded. The proposal would define “Out Of Region Use” as the sole use of ARIN-allocated resources in, or advertisement from, locations outside the ARIN region, excluding simultaneous use inside the ARIN region and elsewhere.
The proposal addresses whether an undefined term in Section 9 should be narrowed through a bright-line definition so that mixed in-region and out-of-region deployments, such as anycast-style use cases, are not included in the proposed category. The supplied record does not contain a captured debate population or individual participant arguments.
The proposal is recorded as “Under Discussion” with normalized status “under_discussion.” No decision date, decision source, successor version, or outcome is present in the supplied facts. Therefore, the record supports discussion status only, not adoption, rejection, or deferral.
All supplied participation metrics are zero, including message count, participant count, active days, HHI, and top-1, top-5, and top-10 message shares. These values are degenerate and uninformative for concentration analysis because no captured discussion population is present; they do not establish that no debate occurred elsewhere.
If adopted, the proposed definition would narrow the classification discretion available at the registry interpretation layer by replacing an undefined term with a more auditable rule. The proposal text leaves the placement question open between Section 2 and Section 9. Whether that change occurred cannot be determined because no decision or later version is supplied.
La couverture de la source est incomplète.
Partielle
Première capture: 1 janv. 1997
Dernière capture: 27 oct. 2026