Aller au contenu principal

ARIN · Veille des RIR

Define Out Of Region Use

Commencez ici pour consulter l’historique, proposition par proposition : ce qui a changé, pourquoi cela comptait, qui a défendu quoi, comment les positions ont évolué, ce qui a été décidé et quelles lacunes subsistent dans les preuves.

Faits sourcés

Identifiant
ARIN-prop-353
RIR
ARIN
Statut officiel
Under Discussion
Introduction
2 août 2026
Dernière mise à jour des sources
16 nov. 2026

Qui a réellement façonné le débat ?

1Total des participants
1Acteurs formels

Analyse BTW

Analyse BTW

Ce qui a changé

ARIN-prop-353 was introduced on 2026-08-02. The supplied original versions have substantially identical proposal text; the later capture adds page framing, with no substantive policy change shown. The proposal would add a definition of “Out Of Region Use”: exclusive use or advertisement from outside the ARIN region, excluding use or advertisement that also occurs within the region. It remains under discussion.

Objet réel du débat

The proposal addresses a classification ambiguity: whether resources used both inside and outside the ARIN region, including geographically distributed or anycast deployments, could be treated as out-of-region use. Its proposed exclusivity criterion would clarify that boundary without changing the substantive requirements of Section 9 in the supplied text. No debate messages are present to establish participants’ actual arguments or motivations.

Décision et débat

The recorded status is “Under Discussion”; the chronology shows introduction and version records but no decision event. Adoption, rejection, and entry into force are not established. The proposal’s stated rationale and potential effects must not be mistaken for a decision or an official position.

Concentration de la participation

The measured dataset records zero messages, zero discussion participants, and zero active days, alongside one formal actor and one total participant. Message-share and HHI values of zero are non-informative here: with no messages, there is no distribution from which to assess concentration or breadth. These metrics do not establish diffuse support, consensus, or opposition.

Analyse du point de contrôle

If adopted, the definition could reduce interpretive discretion for mixed in-region and out-of-region use by expressly excluding that combination from the proposed category. It would be a targeted classification clarification, not a demonstrated transfer of general policy authority. Because the proposal remains under discussion, no effective power shift is shown. The exclusive-use wording also leaves practical questions about thresholds and proof unresolved.

Incertitudes

  • The supplied metrics do not specify whether all relevant discussion channels were captured; zero activity applies to the measured dataset, not necessarily every channel.
  • No participant stance timelines or debate messages are supplied, so support, opposition, consensus, and stance changes cannot be inferred.
  • The practical meaning of “sole use,” including thresholds, edge cases, and evidentiary standards, is not specified.
  • The proposal’s eventual disposition and any implementation or operational effects are unknown.
  • The two version records differ in document hash and page framing, but no official change log is supplied; their proposal text is substantially identical.

Évolution de la politique

original
2 août 2026
Faits sourcés ↗

Header/Navigation · Added a header line 'Close The ARIN 58 Public Policy and Members Meeting is now in progress. Learn more about ARIN 58 and register to join us, or view the agenda and livestream .' and a navigation link 'Skip to main content' at the beginning of the document.

Header/Navigation · Added a line 'Your IP address is' and the text 'Log in Log in User Dashboard Settings Profile and security information Log Out Search all requests subject to terms of use' between the proposal title and the date.

Chronologie du débat

  1. Version officielle

    original

    Faits sourcés ↗
  2. Présentation

    Présentation

    Faits sourcés ↗
  3. Version officielle

    original

    Faits sourcés ↗

Entités

Dernière mise à jour:

Chargement

Sources et couverture

Archives des discussions publiques

Couverture

Première capture: 1 janv. 1997
Dernière capture: 16 nov. 2026