RIPE NCC · RIR 워치독
Revised IPv6 PI Assignment Policy
안건별 기록은 여기서 확인하세요. 무엇이 바뀌었고, 왜 중요했는지, 누가 무엇을 주장했는지, 입장이 어떻게 변했는지, 무엇이 결정되었으며, 근거가 아직 부족한 부분은 어디인지 담고 있습니다.
출처 정보
- Policy ID
- 2024-01
- RIR
- RIPE NCC
- 공식 지위
- Withdrawn
- 도입됨
- 2024. 8. 13.
- 마지막 소스 업데이트
- 2026. 11. 18.
실제로 이 논쟁을 이끈 이는 누구일까?
정책 변화 과정
End Site definition deferred to another proposal · Version 2 removes the proposed section 2.9 split between allocation-based and PI End Sites, including the detailed routing-policy, Layer 2, customer-device and anycast tests. Its rationale says the new End Site definition will be handled in a separate proposal. The remaining references to End Sites therefore must not be read as adopting those deleted tests.
출처 정보 −
An End Site for provider independent assignments (PI) is defined as any topological location in the RIPE NCC Service Region where the End User deploys Internet-connected devices and that has a different routing policy than other End Sites of that End User.출처 정보 ↗
출처 정보 +
The definition of End Site initially proposed under 2.9 will be spun off into a separate policy proposal to avoid confusing discussion of this proposal.출처 정보 ↗
Planning horizon for a larger PI assignment · Version 2 changes the expected-utilisation planning horizon used to justify larger or additional PI space from twelve to twenty-four months. Current or planned routing policies remain an alternative example of justification, and the nibble-boundary sizing sequence remains /48, /44, /40 and /36.
출처 정보 −
When requesting an assignment with a prefix shorter than a /48, an additional assignment, or an extension of an existing assignment to a size larger than a /48, the need must be justified, for example, by documenting the current and/or planned routing policies in place for each End Site or the expected utilisation according to 2.7 within the next 12 months.출처 정보 ↗
출처 정보 +
When requesting an assignment with a prefix shorter than a /48, an additional assignment, or an extension of an existing assignment to a size larger than a /48, the need must be justified – for example, by documenting each End Site’s current and/or planned routing policies, or expected utilisation (see 2.7) within the next 24 months.출처 정보 ↗
One growth procedure for existing PI holders · Version 2 applies the extension procedure to holders of one or more PI assignments without the former implementation-date distinction. It deletes the separate legacy reevaluation section. When contiguous expansion is unavailable, the holder may request a new assignment and must return previous assignments within six months; the old automatically described replacement becomes a request option.
출처 정보 −
If an End User or LIR already holding one or multiple PI assignments issued after <DATE OF PROPOSAL IMPLEMENTATION> needs more IPv6 PI address space, they must submit a request for an extension of their current assignment to the next nibble boundary satisfying the new needs.출처 정보 ↗
출처 정보 +
If an End User or LIR already holding one or more PI assignments needs additional address space, they must submit a request for an extension to the next nibble boundary satisfying the new needs.출처 정보 ↗
Legacy renumbering extensions removed · Version 1 offers older assignments a twelve-month renumbering period with repeat twelve-month extensions on proof of continuing use and inability to renumber. Version 2 omits that exceptional regime and states six months for returning previous assignments after a replacement. It does not impose a new immediate renumbering obligation on every untouched existing assignment.
출처 정보 −
For PI assignment requests evaluated before <DATE OF PROPOSAL IMPLEMENTATION> the initial renumbering period is twelve months, which can be extended by twelve months every twelve months, if the End User provides the RIPE NCC with documentation demonstrating that: A renumbering is currently not feasible, and The prefixes are currently in use.출처 정보 ↗
출처 정보 +
If the requested extension to the next nibble boundary cannot be made, the assignment holder may request a new Assignment as per "7.1.1. PI Assignment at the Nibble Boundary" and must return the previous assignment(s) within a six-month renumbering period.출처 정보 ↗
Explicit prohibition on splitting registrations omitted · Version 2 removes the sentence forbidding post-implementation PI registrations from being split into independent smaller assignments. The aggregation objective and permission to route more-specific prefixes without sub-assignment remain. Deleting this specific sentence does not by itself grant a general right to sub-assign or transfer fragments.
출처 정보 −
Registrations for PI assignments made after <DATE OF PROPOSAL IMPLEMENTATION> cannot be split up into smaller prefixes (for example, a /44 assigned PI cannot be broken into two or more independent assignments).출처 정보 ↗
출처 정보 +
To aid aggregation and reduce the need for renumbering in case of growth, justified assignments are to be made in nibble boundary steps (i.e. starting with /48, followed by /44, /40, and /36, in steps of 4 bits).출처 정보 ↗
Special-purpose size exception omitted · Version 2 drops the express permission for more-specific special-purpose PI policies to depart from generic assignment criteria. The generic bounds remain. The deletion removes that cross-policy clarification; the retained proposal alone does not determine the continuing effect of a separate IXP assignment policy.
Reservation responsibility made explicit · Version 2 expressly recommends that RIPE NCC reserve space up to the next nibble boundary, replacing the recommendation simply to leave that space unused. The amount of recommended growth room is unchanged; the operational actor is now named.
Remote End Site prohibition qualified by routing exchange · Version 3 adds without the exchange of Internet routing information to the sentence prohibiting use of a PI prefix to connect another entity’s separate End Site. This qualifies the prior blanket wording and aligns it with the preceding ISP interconnection example. It does not delete the general prohibition on sub-assignment or establish unrestricted permission to provide customer access using PI space.
출처 정보 −
Any other use of a prefix from an assignment (up to prefixes of /128) to connect the separate End Site of another entity to the Internet constitutes a prohibited sub-assignment.출처 정보 ↗
출처 정보 +
Any other use of a prefix from an assignment (up to prefixes of /128) to connect the separate End Site of another entity to the Internet without the exchange of Internet routing information constitutes a prohibited sub-assignment.출처 정보 ↗
Persistent addressing terminology · Version 3 changes static to persistent in the server/appliance addressing example and its explanatory purpose. It supplies no new duration, assignment-size rule or addressing mechanism. The same-site condition and the surrounding /56-or-longer connectivity wording remain unchanged.
출처 정보 −
This includes letting visitors connect to the assignment holder's network, providing static addresses when connecting a server or appliance to the assignment holder's network, providing a single service with multiple addresses, or using a /64 or longer when setting up point-to-point links with other ISPs for the purpose of exchanging traffic and Internet routing information.출처 정보 ↗
출처 정보 +
This includes letting visitors connect to the assignment holder's network, providing persistent addresses when connecting a server or appliance to the assignment holder's network, providing a single service with multiple addresses, or using a /64 or longer when setting up point-to-point links with other ISPs for the purpose of exchanging traffic and Internet routing information.출처 정보 ↗
논의 연표
참여 주체
불러오는 중…
출처 및 적용 범위
공개 토론 기록 보관소
- ripencc-address-policy-wg –
- ripencc-accountability-tf-ripe.net –
- ripencc-agm-nominations-ripe.net –
- ripencc-all-anchors-ripe.net –
- ripencc-anti-abuse-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-atlas-sponsors-ripe.net –
- ripencc-atlas-sw-probes-ripe.net –
- ripencc-bcop-ripe.net –
- ripencc-coc-tf-ripe.net –
- ripencc-connect-bof-ripe.net –
- ripencc-connect-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-cooperation-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-db-help-ripe.net –
- ripencc-db-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-diversity-ripe.net –
- ripencc-dns-resolver-tf-ripe.net –
- ripencc-dns-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-dp-tf-ripe.net –
- ripencc-eb-candidates-ripe.net –
- ripencc-eix-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-election-cc-team-ripe.net –
- ripencc-enum-announce-ripe.net –
- ripencc-enum-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-hackathon-list-ripe.net –
- ripencc-icann-plan-ripe.net –
- ripencc-iot-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ipmap-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ipmt-dev-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ipv6-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-irrtoolset-ripe.net –
- ripencc-lir-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-mat-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-measure-voip-ripe.net –
- ripencc-members-discuss-unmoderated-ripe.net –
- ripencc-members-discuss-ripe.net –
- ripencc-myasntesting-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ncc-announce-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ncc-services-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-opensource-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-persian-lir-ripe.net –
- ripencc-policy-announce-ripe.net –
- ripencc-raci-list-ripe.net –
- ripencc-regional-russia-ripe.net –
- ripencc-regional-ukraine-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripe-atlas-ambassadors-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripe-atlas-tools-maintainers-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripe-atlas-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripe-chair-discuss-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripe-db-requirements-tf-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripe-forum-test-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripe-list-unmoderated-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripe-list-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripe-parents-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripecast-ripe.net –
- ripencc-rirs-lea-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ris-int-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ris-users-ripe.net –
- ripencc-routing-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-rpslng-ripe.net –
- ripencc-security-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-see-regional-ripe.net –
- ripencc-techsec-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-tld-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-tt-tf-ripe.net –
- www.ripe.net/community/wg/active-wg/ap/minutes
- ripencc-green-tech-hackathon-orga-ripe.net
- ripencc-nccdays-pc-ripe.net
커버리지
가장 처음 수집된 시점: 1992. 6. 30.
최근 수집: 2026. 11. 14.
