ARIN-prop-10: PI assignments for V6

2005-9: 4-Byte AS Number

評価: 一貫 · The December explanation says existing two-byte ASN holders need not take transition action; the February revision changes the registry's handling of future allocation requests and explicitly avoids a flag day. Those propositions address different parts of the transition and do not contradict one another.

条件: These are historical claims and proposed dates, not a statement of current ASN rules or proof that implementation occurred. · Publishing an authored revision is not an additional independent community vote.

2005/12/13

Folk who have 2 byte AS numbers need do _nothing_ , i.e. the transition allows for "the continued use of AS2 space" indefinitely.

2006/02/04

the registry will process Global change "On 1 January" to "Commencing 1 January

2006/02/04

while no flag day is required in the transition to the longer AS Number field

ARIN-prop-20: 4-Byte AS Number Policy Proposal

評価: 一貫性を評価するには証拠が不十分です · The sole supplied reply rejects technical assertions and points back to references. Without those assertions in the author's own text or another independent position on this recorded proposal, it cannot establish a policy reversal or a complete consistency history.

条件: The same reply is cross-linked to both four-byte ASN proposal records and counts as one communication.

2005/12/13

Again, not so. I'll say it again: Please _read_ these references, as they are intended to describe the transition situation in as comprehensive manner as possible.

2005-9: 4-Byte AS Number · ARIN-prop-20: 4-Byte AS Number Policy Proposal

評価: 一貫性を評価するには証拠が不十分です · A single technical reply is linked to both proposal records. Its appearance under both records cannot serve as two independent positions demonstrating agreement or disagreement across proposals.

条件: The narrow consistency finding on the detailed transition explanation does not create missing substantive evidence for the cross-linked proposal.

2005/12/13

Please _read_ these references, as they are intended to describe the transition situation in as comprehensive manner as possible.

2005/12/13

the transition allows for "the continued use of AS2 space" indefinitely.